I'va just noticed that one of my hubs is on a site called Xomba.
Why is that? and how did it happen? I am completely lost.
Xomba's down for maintenance right now, but from what I saw elsewhere online, it looks like a HubPages copycat. If your article is up there, and you didn't put it there, you need to report it to the site administrators. Someone copied your hub and put it up on Xomba. According to reviews of Xomba, the site splits Adsense money with its writers 50/50. So someone over there is making money on work you did.
Usually, there's a "Contact Us" link somewhere on the homepage where you can report stuff like this. If you want it taken down, contact the administrators. Give them the URL of your original hub, and then the URL of the Xomba copy. Tell them you are the original author, and that it was posted on Xomba without your consent.
Good luck. Let us know what happens!
So, while Xomba's site is out for maintenance... I just wait? Wait until the page is up again and then contact the admin.?
Thanks for your reply Vanderlinden. It is very frustrating things like this happening. I hope it can be sorted. But, how can they know that I was the original writer?
Is there any way I posted it there by accident? (ok. I am not that daft yet... I hope!) but could it be done somehow automatically?
It looks like you'll have to wait---they don't have any links on the maintenance page they have up.
As far as proving you're the original author, it's a good idea to also include the original date you published the hub in question---they should be able to tell on their end when something on Xomba was published. Undoubtedly, the copy will have been published after the original
Most sites have policies against plagiarism, and since Xomba is claiming to be a site for writers, I'd imagine they have one, too. I know that someone recently copied some hubs of jimmythejock's, and he wrote to the site admin. The copies were taken down and the person who posted them had their account suspended.
I highly doubt you posted by accident. Unless you black out every once in a while
It is frustrating. I hope it all gets worked out quickly!
Anytime Xomba's back up, BTW---and their TOS specify no copied material. From Xomba:
Some of my content is being linked as a Xomblurb, I just sent a message to the site asking that the content be removed as the submission was placed without my permission. *sigh*
It's always something. I looked at the Xomblurb FAQ and it says:
So, on one hand, it sounds like a good deal since it's supposed to be like a social bookmarking tool. On the other hand, without putting any real work in, whoever posts the link to your article gets Adsense money from it. Not sure how I feel about this yet. Any opinions?
I'm thinking it might not be a terrible thing, because you could argue that anyone we link to in our hubs we are kind of making money off of as well. Except that we have to write an entire hub to get paid, not just submit a link......
I think that is a valid point. But we write something original and have a few links. We do not base a whole hub on a link to another site.
BTW still not sure how I feel about it... I suppose at the end is driving more traffic to my hub...
I think I may take control of this situation myself by joining Xomba and submitting my articles before anyone else can try and make money off of it, though Hubpages' Alexa ranking is much higher. (Hubpages - 2632, xomba - 7774)
I don't see where it wouldn't be allowed, but I may be called out on that. From what I see if you post their snippet thing it would be the same as your content being submitted to stuff like stumbleupon or digg.
Well, except that stumbleupon and digg don't pay Adsense money to their users.. so, errrr, gosh, I don't know now!
Maybe paul will poke his head in and let us know what the official Hubpages stand on it is?
I could be wrong, of course, but a link is a link, whether we got paid to submit it or not. So I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with us signing up over there to submit Xomblurbs for our own hubs. I like gamergirl's idea of beating them to the punch by submitting our links ourselves, and making any adsense money that comes from that.
I'd much rather see Hubbers make money off of submitting a link to their work than see someone else profiting by doing the "easy" part of submitting a completed hub. It's probably not a huge deal either way. It's just one of those weird little things that seems to pop up every once in a while
From what I can see, I don't think your going to make much money directly by submitting xomblurbs. I can't find where the ads are that they supposedly sharing revenue on (for the xomblurbs). At any rate, If you want to submit your hubs I think that's fine. I'd suggest that you only use a small part of the text of your hub in the blurb (or better yet, new unique text), so that you don't run into duplicate content problems.
If you try it, let us know how it works out for you.
Thanks Paul. I have submitted one of my hubs with low views to see whether it makes a difference or not. It might worth the effort...or not! will see.
So actually my corset article is on google first page, #1 spot and the url is that of that xomba site....the link includes the title of my hub and some text, but I am credited as the author and it links to hubpages, it is not copied there....are you guys saying this is a bad thing when it links to my hubpage article....
If anyone else is going to join xomba please feel free to use my affiliate link :-)
<snip>sorry, no promotional links in forums</snip>
Done, Lissie! Though I'm not sure how much I'll use it, but I signed up through you.
Hubpage network is set up so we can excuse me but whore out others content.
This is how you will get alternative traffic and links that lead to you.
Thats why is says link to this page and offers you to use your coded link to the hubbers site.
I am promoting tons of hubbers on many different networks (All White Hat I might add)
Isnt that what the network was designed for?
So we could all use each others talent to make money. I think its brilliant.
Yes, but it is very important that we all respect the rules of the sites that we promote HubPages on. We don't want to wear out our welcome or have our community cast in a bad light. Unfortunately, the actions of a small minority have the potential to drag us all through the mud.
It has been 24 hours since I joined Xomba. I am only experimenting with a couple of hubs, but to be honest, I do not see much difference yet. At least not enough to be worth the effort
Will see in a couple of days
On the Xomba front, I have posted two of my hubs as xomblurbs, these two are part of my 'best' section, so we'll see how it goes. I have decided against posting xomblurbs to all my hubs so I don't get seen as a "spammer," and will be monitoring these hubs to see how the progress goes. I will update more when I see results.
I just rechecked my article that someone put on Xomba and it actually does NOT have me listed as the author....it still does have a link to my hubpage article, but what do you think, should I complain....it is still on the first page in the #1 spot on google, that may change, I know, but don't know what to do at this point.
I looks OK - I found the one on xoomba and its a blurb? for your article and they haven't even copied the first few lines word for word - I think you have a fan!
Sure Paul I understand, We all have a vested interest in hubpages and I do observe the rules of the other networks. I think I am one of the few people even attempting promoting other people hubs. Or the only one admitting it?
I think there are some others that do. In the big scheme of things back link growth is the throttle that will regulate HubPages traffic growth. If content growth (hubs) outpaces back link growth, the average traffic per hub will decline.
We're starting to think about more ways to bring together those that are great at creating content with those that are great at promoting content. It seems like there are a lot of people with one skill or the other, but people that have both skills are somewhat rare.
Yes I would agree with you Paul, I know I fall some where in between. Promoting is just plane work to me ;-) Hub pages has really helped with my writing.
I wanted to ask if we were ever going to get credit for showing Videos through Adsense.
I'm one who could use a lot of help promoting hubs. I'm trying, but not getting too far. Is it too much of a stretch for HubPages to consider hiring someone (or several) on staff to promote hubs that have potential for greater traffic and ad sales?
Is this site similar to a bookmarking site? I just checked it out, and I'm still confused...
It looks like you write a short paragraph, insert the link to the full article, and that's it?
I'm offering the following advice to fellow members here, to simply point out that you should be cautious with some content sites out there.
I pulled my content off of one of them for a second and final time just this week. I'll leave them nameless but they caused my adsense to drop off of all my articles, with the other 50% of them still running so that the site still made revenue. I confirmed this with google adsense channels that showed the very day my part of the ads were stopped.
I had posted a series of articles on religious subjects from Bible perspective, in their "religion and beliefs" category and while I certainly can't say this caused them to do this, the timing was suspicious. If this is the case, this would mean that they are trifling with members by using punishment type methods if they rub them the wrong way, even if they are within confines of their stated posting policies. I hope I'm wrong about it and it was just a coincidental fluke both times it happened to me at the site.
The site has a space in member's profiles for placing your google adsense ID number and warns "if there are spaces before or after the number, your adsense won't work". It has made me wonder if they use improper posting of the number as an excuse to stop a member's adsense from working. They mentioned this to me when I emailed them about the issue but if this were the case, the ads would not have appeared on my posts during my 50% timeslots for weeks and months, then suddenly have stopped.
I've seen other former members of the same site attest to similar incidents that caused them to leave or to be improperly banned.
I'm not trying to discourage anyone, so please don't take this post in the wrong way. I'm just pointing out that you should always pay close attention to what's going on with your articles and proceed with content sites, whomever they may be, with caution!
I'll end in saying I believe HubPages to be an honest and highly ethical site and I've been completely happy with them for the approx. year and a half I've been a member here!
I'm guessing jimlow that you mean Xomba since this is where you posted about the content sites you wont name?? Don't know what to tell ya about why it would work for awhile and then stop, but in any case if you enter your adsense ID wrong it only makes sense that no one is obligated to make sure it is right.
If you don't enter it in right, then adsense doesn't know to credit you for the clicks. It sounds like 50% of the time the content site was putting their links on, and 50% they were allocating the ad links to the adsense id put in but if it was wrong, no one was earning (or someone was if they had the id that was mistakenly entered)
Regardless, I have been using xomba for a little awhile. I have 13 xombytes and 9 xomblurbs. Earned $1.99 so far just from today from xomba.
I still do better at hubpages and prefer the freedom of creating pages with pictures, videos, amazon and ebay, but its good if your trying to diversify where your articles are coming from when your trying to take on a specific keyword and dominate the serps for it with article marketing.
You described it exactly right, as far as how it occurred. The thing is, it worked correctly for weeks and even months at a time before the mysterious glitches occurred. It wasn't until the second occurance that I removed my content permanently.
I write for several other sites in addition to HubPages, including HowToDoThings and BellaOnline Thyroid Health. I get to affiliate link and earn adsense on other sites and this has never occurred on any of them.
The correlation of when this occurred and what I was writting about was just too coincidental. I could still be wrong but even if it is a glitch that can occur unexpectedly, that was still enough reason for me to leave the other un-named site. Without them I was making between $150.00 and $175.00 in adsense a month (last months was $196.00).
It's too bad too because I was linking here a lot and planned to network away, so will have to use other avenues. I need to get back busy with Delicious and other social bookmarking sites. I've had friends invite me to Twitter, so may do that soon as well.
by Deborah Neyens 7 years ago
In reviewing my traffic sources recently, I noticed that I was getting traffic from a site called traffup.com, which I had never heard of before. I went to the site and signed up for it to see what it was all about, and found that someone had posted a link there to one of my hubs. I thought...
by Anna Marie Bowman 12 years ago
I found this when I logged in today. That little red c that lets you know someone copied your work. Here is the link. I know my work is my own. I have the pay stubs and personal stories to back it up. Link deletedI went back and looked, there is no way to flag posts, email...
by Luis E Gonzalez 8 years ago
Well...moths ago I posted a couple of articles at Wizzley. After several rejections I re-wrote them and they remained published on Wizzley up to today (I think) I went there today and wrote another article. To my surprise I received a message from a chief...
by thomasczech 8 years ago
Why does my hub keep saying it is a duplicate? It is my work. I even made many changes many times.I deleted it, rewrote it and tried to publish it again, after having made many changes. Still it says duplicate. It should not say this. It is my work.
by Chitrangada Sharan 7 years ago
Found two my hubs on another site. What should I do?I found two of my recipe hubs, exactly the same, may be copy, pasted, on another site. But they have given a link to my original hub at the bottom. But they have used a different photo. What should I do? Should I report it? How?
by Sullen91 10 years ago
This was a nice experiment, but I've ultimately concluded that this site blows. The two competing interests are making money and writing quality articles. Mind you, I've written a handful of stellar hubs, yet I haven't a penny to show for it. Sure, I have about 100 or so impressions on AdSense, but...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|