Seems like there are a noticeable number of forum threads closed to reply. Veteran hubbers, are the current numbers typical? Some threads I assume get closed to reply because the topic is controversial or inflammatory, but it seems that other similar threads remain open. Some threads I really don't see at all why they are closed. Is there some consistency in these closings I'm missing?
I understand there are HP TOS, rules of engagement etc. I found this thread reply by Maggie Rudd:
There are a number of reasons threads get closed (including personal attacks, thread hijacking, etc). Sometimes I close threads because they've run their course, or there have been new developments that make them irrelevant. This is the case with the recent threads to which you refer.
If someone wants to quote or reference additional official responses, fine. But what I'm really interested in are the opinions and experiences of hubbers on this. Unless there is some rule against this.
Wierd things happen, not sure what happened there, except to say that someone was offended with the Bush picture depicting him as the joker. Or some other crazy reason people get offended. Maybe someone reported it and the Hub team agreed. It's getting to be a guessing game these days.
I have closed several of my own threads so that it would not get out of hand. I monitor them closely and if mud slinging becomes really bad I request to close.
Maddie is our playground monitor. She has to be. because sometimes our forum resembles one. No finger pointing mind - I enjoyed my playground years for the main.
I was the Marble Champion at my school and the bane of boys lives for quite a few years.
Until I lost my marbles that is
Actually - I never did. I wore a lot of my brothers cast offs. maybe he's got my marbles?
I closed a bunch of threads from people asking for fans this morning, if that's what you're referring to. Solely self-promotional threads are often closed to prevent them from being endlessly bumped.
(And it's Maddie Ruud, not Maggie Rudd. I often get Rudd, and I sometimes get Maggie, but I don't think I've ever gotten them put together before. )
Thanks Maddie. Sorry about the goof. My name is Rose Mary, and I get Rose Marie, Mary Ann, Ruth Ann, Mary Rose, Ann Mary. My favs are from kids: Mo Rary and Miss Raspberry.
Nope re: self promotional. I totally get that. I often report those threads. THey are totally tiresome.
And I'm one of 'em sorry I'm not fully aware that asking for fans to be fanned is self promoting since I usually see people doing this for the past few months, Hayz if just know it...
Yes GH, I agree there have been numerous posts regarding fans, as well as other milestones, number of views, people posting to mark milestones for others or promote helping others reach X# of fans etc. Certainly not all of the threads have been closed. Some of the recent closures were pretty obvious though. People who joined a couple days ago and wanting fans &/or people to read their hubs.
I thought it was encouraged to promote in the forums for HubNuggets for example, but then I got cold feet, mentioned it on a few posts, but did not start a thread.
Yes it is, but it has to be relevant to the thread. So for instance, in Extreme Hub Makeover, you can post a link to a Hub for review. In HubNuggets, you post a link to your HubNugget Hubs, etc. It's never really appropriate to tout for fans.
The silly thing is, people don't realise touting for fans is a waste of time anyway - your HubScore will actually suffer if you go on a fanning spree, and fans don't make you any money.
Now I see hehehe my author score dropped 4 notch down hayz, thanks for the info...
Just want to ask Marissa is it okay to inform those people that you featured their hubs and commented to visit them if they have time and at the same time you place a link to it, is this a spam...
I get what you're saying, but when you're only a few weeks into HP, money is a ways off. Fans and views are the newbie's reward.
*would have been highly amusing if Maddie closed this one. Just for the irony slant*
by Julie Grimes 8 years ago
Come on HubPages, closing threads all the time, is only going to create more animosity towards one another. The thread was drawing to end on it's own. So why close is Mauddie? I don't get that. Now nobody gets to say their sorry, and work things out to be better...
by Kate Swanson 5 years ago
I just noticed that Matthew replied to a question from a Hubber and immediately closed the threadThere used to be an unspoken policy on the forums - a thread was only closed if things got too heated and unpleasant. I hope that policy is not going to change, for several reasons. For one thing,...
by Susan Zutautas 6 years ago
I went to reply to a post in this thread and saw that it had been closed to reply and I was curious as to why it has been closed. http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/90745
by Woman Of Courage 7 years ago
I was about to post on Brenda's Christian Discussion Thread. I am stunned to notice the thread is now closed to replies. How is it possible when christians were only sharing scriptures and discussing their faith? Should the one who chose to attack, insult, and hijack a thread be banned from the...
by Kate Swanson 7 years ago
Earlier this morning I created a thread on the Hub Makeover forum, because I had emailed Team HubPages and hadn't had a response. Jason eventually responded and told me what I already knew, that the Hub had triggered the Affiliate link rule because of my RSS feed (to my own blog). Then...
by Julie Grimes 9 years ago
Okay, so after we enable someone to do something, the ENABLE them to bring it to the forefront, find out we all have just be duped, and then ENABLE them to makes us look stupid for believing in them....And, then What? They are enabled, once again by closing their threads to reply? ...
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|