There are tons of forums and websites that have within their TOS that you must participate in some area for X-amount of times before allowed to post in the forum. Typically, you have to reply to other threads so many times before you're allowed to start your own.
I think this would be a great way to prevent people from signing up just to talk in the forums, starting one forum thread, or just to ask 1 question and never come back. It may also prevent spam because a lot of spammers seem to sign up and spam tons of hubs or the forums.
If people had to publish so many hubs following the guidelines before being allowed to ask questions or whatever.
In a way, that would make people have to read before posting threads that have been answered many times before or are answered in the 'help' section. It may frustrate people because they can't figure it out right away, but search the forums, there are tons of threads answering just about any 'how to' question on writing hubs.
To me, it may actually cut out the rif-raf, so to speak, who just post one time and never come back. This causes stats issues with hubbers and how many hubs are published, considered that most hubbers aren't productive or never actually publish anything. Again, it may potentially reduce spammers who post in the forums, and those who sign up to spam. It won't prevent spammers who mass spam hubs and don't sign up, but it may reduce something.
Excellent idea. If it could be set up so the "Need Help? Ask Here" forum was an exception, it would be perfect.
I don't think we should get too heavy-handed, though, and start making rules about writing Hubs first. That one rule would cut out the most annoying spam.
This has been my thought exactly, for quite some time. However, I remember someone raising a good point - what if a new hubber genuinely needs help? My suggestion is to only allow them to post in one place. Maybe that section will get more spam, but at least it will be in one place and much easier to moderate.
I Agree.... and it will stop spammers if they are locked out this way.
When I first joined up with AOL round about 1995 they had a new members forum and that was the only place you could post for about a month if I remember rightly.
You could read the other forums but not post.
I too think that would be a great idea for here:)
and a quota of posts per hub would not be a bad idea to keep down the noise from forum creepers only here to disrupt and annoy.
and everyone should have to read at least 10 hubs by other hubbers before they can post a question - because reading other people's hubs really does answer most of these redundant questions newbies post. However, I like very much that the only rules on HP are rules about treating each other fairly and using HP for good purposes . . . too many rules might make it not so nice and easy like it is now!
How would a rule like this 1) guarantee people are actually READING and 2) how would it guarantee that the 10 Hubs they read were quality ones that answered their questions?
I'd really like to see a question posting limit, especially in the Answer section. People with low author score should not be able to crank out endless questions. For instance, if your author score is 1, you should only get to ask one question per day at most.
And they should have donated $20 towards our Xmas Party Fund & agreed to wash the dishes on the day.... We can Name the Newbies .... Helper Gnomes
Excellent idea, let's hope hubpages staff are reading this and taking note
I also agree with Whitney but in regards to GirlyGirl's post there is always the help section that they can use.
But sometimes I wonder of HP likes the trolls here. You know, to stir up a little trouble and get the forums busy. I've heard of other writing sites doing just this. I know, I'll just ask HP staff. Yes, that's the ticket!
Hey Paul, Maddie, or other staff, does HP have their own trolls, paid or otherwise? Perhaps you guys take turns being the trolls on the forums? Yes? No? None of my business? What's the scoop?
Sincerely, your friend,
by Jaye Denman 5 years ago
For the second time in less than a week, I just spent time opening "questions" that aren't questions, but nonsensical "garbage"--bits of a paragraph copies from somewhere and dumped into HP. In each case, I flagged them for HP, and they will likely disappear soon. But they harm...
by girly_girl09 10 years ago
I have been seeing a lot of forum spam lately. I think it could be *greatly* reduced by only allowing new sign-ups to post under the help section until they've published one hub. After they've published their first hub, then they could post anywhere. I think this would deter a lot of the people who...
by Allie Mendoza 9 years ago
Many hubbers admit to being addicted to the forums and I've been afraid that it would happen to me. I'm sure it's difficult to overcome this addiction. I know it's a lot of fun to participate, but I still want to be very productive and write as much as I can. I think I maybe at high risk for...
by And Drewson 8 years ago
People Creating HubPages Accounts to Spew HateHas anyone else noticed the people Trolling our forum lately with few, if any, Hubs?There are several I've found that keep posting thread after thread of garbage.I suggest a MINIMUM number of Hubs before being able to post to any other part of the forum...
by Tony Lawrence 8 years ago
OK, I heard the objections to my idea of no hubs/no forum posts and see the validity.How about a mandatory "Introduce yourself" post that has to survive not being flagged by X number of people in X amount of time and if they pass, they have access to every forum. Otherwise, no...
by Carolee Samuda 7 years ago
This might be my last forum post because I am tired. I can't be wasting my time beating a dead horse.HP is a business and they need to start treating their business more seriously. They need a task force to sit and brain storm about how to keep spammers out in the first place.I know that I have...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|