Here's something interesting for those of you wary of sharing your personal data & stats with other users.
Each of our personal subdomains is now displayed on quantcast. Case in point: Paul Edmondson's page visits.
I believe this would be considered a breach of privacy and hope that Hubpages removes the codes that allow this information to be publicly available.
I wrongly attributed this initiative to Eric, so allow me to correct this and thank you for bringing this to the attention of hubpages which has resulted in the desired outcome.
It would appear that this is a gross breach of privacy for those who use their real name to post on Hub Pages.
Yet I understand that HubPages have refused point blank to allow people to change their real names to one that is non identifiable.
I would welcome an explanation from Hub Pages management to explain how the publication of detailed statistics for such a hub pages user is NOT a breach of privacy.
And the fact that it is Quantcast not Hubpages that provides this information is irrelevant, because HubPages has authorised Quantcast to compile this information and make it available.
Holy exposure batman! Some of our best contributors use their own name!
Has anyone asked the hubpages staff the direct question yet?
Yes, this is a bit too much...I wonder why they've approved this...ah well it's their site, I've got sites to build and control on my own, busy busy busy like a bee on acid with no pants on...
Wayne -- It may be THEIR site, but they are YOUR private stats -- at least 60% of them anyway.
BTW, glad to see you've got a little uptick in pageviews going. It's not much, but I hope it lasts for you. With 617 hubs, though, I'm surprised you're not getting more traffic than you are, as you're averaging less than 2 pageviews per hub per day. Yesterday, you only had 1,000 global pvs and 583 from the US. Hope things get better for you. I'll be keeping an eye out and crossing my fingers!
The downside to subdomains is that they are treated as a website
Ex; hubpages.com = luisegonzalez . hubpages.com and Quantcast is allowed by HP to post information about the website (luisegonzalez . hubpages.com), although the information is relevant to number of visits, geographical data etc. No personal information is displayed, albeit with some of the subdomain names (like mine) it would not take much for some unsavory characters to use this for shady purposes.
I don't see that Hubpages has released any information here. I looks like information anyone could scrape if they wanted to. Sites like this have been around for years. Now we have subdomains we will appear on them and the data is not more private than what is planted in your front garden.
Incorrect. HubPages HAS released this information willingly. They have signed up with the Quantcast service to track data by adding code similar to Analytics.
There are other services, such as Compete, that estimate traffic to various websites, but those estimates are usually off by 50% or more. By giving Quantcast permission to track our individual data, they are releasing actual traffic stats, and that is not something someone can "scrape."
Ironher is right, by including the code snippet on our Hubs quantcast is making our traffic levels, keywords, and business demeographs public knowledge, not happy about this as it leaves me wide open to someone stealing my niches and keywords.
Without the code snippet Quantcast can only display guestimates at data.
Where are you seeing keywords displayed, Oli?
Ha ! Checked my own self and saw that I needed to give Quantcast permission to display my subdomain. As I always like to think things over a bit, I did not. Being a bit paranoid after having way too many hubs copied and getting sick of filing DCMA's, I am laying low.
EDIT: We're aware of this. Our current setup is similar to Wordpress and Tumblr: subdomains aren't findable through quantcast.com/hubpages.com (we disabled that) but if you know the subdomain, you can find it.
We will be deciding if we want to remove the Quantcast tag entirely, which is what would be necessary for every subdomain to be untraceable.
Damn, I was actually enjoying the idea of subdomain tracking personally. Nevertheless, I understand the concerns. As always well done on being speedy, it never ceases to amaze
That's a relief. Let me know when it's done then I can go back to writing my "How I Got to Be so Successful" pages.
Your response here indicates to me that you didn't have a clue about the tracking until this thread was posted.
OK, so some people think the ability to track their traffic is a good thing.
Some of the others who use their real names on Hub Pages are quite alarmed.
Seeing that this issue is entirely due to factors that did not exist when the user names were originally chosen, I'll repeat my previous question - which you have ignored.
Why won't you allow people to change their user names, given this drastic change in the way the Hub Pages is operating?
You could then reinstate the quantcast monitoring for the rest of your domain.
I'm not an IT specialist and I'm willing to listen and learn more
I just starting reading the right side of this page and found this link to opt-out
shouldn't this help?
http://www.quantcast.com/how-we-do-it/c … ce/opt-out
That's for keeping your personal browsing data inaccessible for Quantcast's aggregate statistics.
Sure, if you don't want your data to be used in those aggregate statistics. Like, for example, if you visit about.com 10x per month, those 10 visits will not show up in About.com's Quantcast statistics.
They do not show PII (personally-identifiable information) about any particular visitor, only aggregate figures.
I actually quite liked seeing my stats on there, but I especially liked seeing how well or otherwise Hubpages were doing. If HP removes that data we will all be playing a guessing game.
I don't know why some people are so against this data being shown, unless they've been telling porky pies all along about their views and earnings.
I'm with you, Izzy - I rather like being able to see my stats there.
At the same time, though, if my keywords are so easily available that could be a problem. It could also result in increased theft if anyone can easily find out how I'm doing. (Hey, this guy has only 25 hubs and gets 1000 visits/day - they must be worth some copying here!)
Where do you click to see someone's keywords though? I haven't seen anything like that.
And that second scenario about getting hundreds of hits with only 25 hubs is easily solved. Write more hubs until you have 100s. Make it harder for the thieves to guess which ones are doing well.
I don't know how to get the keywords and stuff - Thisisoli just posted above something about it being available.
Write more hubs. Yes, I should do that, and fully expect to if this kind of traffic continues. I pretty much quit writing this year - just wasn't encouraged enough by continually falling traffic to put any effort into it. Got some ideas going, though, and intend to get back into it.
I think that's a bit unfair, Izzy. There are many, many reasons why I wouldn't want my data shown on Quantcast, and none of them have anything to do with telling porky pies.
I understand why a site like HubPages as a whole would want their data shown, as it clearly shows accurate traffic stats to potential advertisers. I can also understand why people who are here only to write wouldn't care if their data is made public.
But...for most small affiliate marketers, secrecy is the only way to survive. If a competitor smells success, they're all over you like bees on honey copying everything you do. Just ask Nelle or Ryan. They'll tell you.
Not cool. SO not cool.
Izzy, people do not want their hard work stolen because they are successful.
If you want to see your stats, you can sign up for Google Analytics and see stats for free.
So people only get their hard work stolen when someone sees their Quantcast stats??
I don't think so. Plagiarism is alive and well on the net and has been for a long time.
Curious jump of logic there, IzzyM.
Yes, people get their hard work stolen even without these stats.
But the ability to access those stats make it a hell of a lot easier to pinpoint the stuff that is worthwhile stealing.
No it doesn't. I have 480 hubs more or less, and only a handful do well. Someone would need to copy them all to ensure they got the right ones.
Well, the availability of data may not be an issue in your case.
But someone with very high traffic levels and a small number of hubs may not agree with your assessment.
But, Eric only has 1... what if it was/is a high traffic hub?
or many of us intentionally made niche profiles for our best earners.. 30-50 hubs, 2000+ hits daily on the quantcast data.. pretty easy to see a goldmine
That was dangerously public data.
There is something to be said for security through obfuscation, but when we started our hub profiles we werent aware that our data may be compromised so easily and not all may have been properly secured.
I have no problem about them showing my HP stats, but others will if they know that their traffic data is out there to scrutinize by the competition and that really is everyone out there to be honest...keeping stuff close to your chest in this game can be very useful that's why I've bought 18 domain names with privacy I don't want anyone knowing that they originate from me.
Given my persona is based around that of a hapless loser it would severely damage my credibility were people to see how fantastically successful I am. Just grateful that my massive thing is now not visible to people.
This is clearly an issue of whether the TOS has been violated.
I'm sure some Hubbers are attorneys...maybe you could shed some light on this, hypothetically speaking of course.
Just a note: we've hidden all Quantcast data for HubPages, including those on subdomains. We're trying to get clarification from Quantcast if we can display only aggregate (site-wide) data only, but we'll keep data off until we find out.
With all due respect, knowing that you want to keep the community informed, it would be better for HP to terminate this thread, get the privacy issue resolved, and then come back with a policy statement.
Thanks for the quick response Jason. Hopefully this issue will be resolved soon with a compromise that keeps both Hubpages and Members happy.
Quantcast got back to us. They said it was a bug, and they're working on their end to resolve it. Once they've fixed it and by-subdomain stats are not visible, then we'll unhide our site stats on Quantcast.
Thank you for your patience and understanding.
Thanks for the update, Jason - it is appreciated. Sounds like it came out of the blue and was not expected.
Yes, we made the change to hide subdomains and didn't see it listed. We thought that took care of it, but apparently there was a workaround if you typed in the URL.
Yep. And with this many hubbers someone somewhere is going to find most any workaround. Oh well - can't see any harm done, and you guys got right on it.
In light of this then a sensible step that should be taken by HubPages would be to allow hubbers to change their username to a more generic one. I didn't think much of it before but my username is my real name, and that has me concerned.
What an awesome response!
Truly Terrific !!!
So you're going to force those people to jump through yet another set of hoops if they have reasons for not being personally identified?
Do you even understand the magnitude of what you are asking them to do? Especially those who have a significant number of hubs, and from whom you have derived substantial income over the years?
They will have to remove, store, and republish all their hubs under a new name. And all their comments, etc. will be lost.
Why don't HubPages management just realise that this is a valid issue for many people, and just allow people using their real names as users to change them?
The friendly, helpful folk at HP never cease to amaze me!
I quite like this, means I can spy on which hubbers are hyping up their performance, saying they earn loads
:edit: just looked at one who is always hyping and they've hidden their data lol
Fair enough, I'd like to hide my website domains on there since I wouldn't want competitors finding out my niche either
If you read the posts above, you'll see that the ability to view this data has been disabled for everyone.
LOL right back at you.
Thanks Eric, Ya blood needs bottlin!
You have done us all a great service in bringing this problem to an end.
Didn't see that soz doesn't protect my websites though
by Paul Goodman 7 years ago
Article for discussion. I know that this recent development has already been mentioned by some hubbers in forums. But I am now wondering if this might be the main reason why we are seeing the current traffic plunges for many hubbers? See link...
by Melanie Palen 4 years ago
http://www.pinterest.com/source/hubpages.com/Looks like there are no hubs on Pinterest (I noticed no Pinterest traffic today and had to investigate.)Hubs are no longer pinnable.I wish hubbers wouldn't spam social networks. :\
by Will Apse 5 years ago
In his hub 'What We Don't Know About Google Panda?', Paul Edmondson points out that Google seems to expect sites to leap high above any bar that might reasonably be set for quality purposes.Paul seems less than happy with Google's attitude. He seems to think that if a page can somehow limp over...
by Paul Goodman 6 years ago
I know that many people don't like HP cracking down, but I personally am hoping that HubPages will continue to find new ways in 2012 to encourage the good writers on here and discourage the spammers and spinners - I really do think that it helps the site's reputation overall with Google and the...
by Melanie Palen 7 years ago
The whole purpose of sub-domains, from what I understand, is to give good hubbers the chance to rise up to the search engines while hubbers who don't produce quality content to umm not.Before the whole subdomain thing, we were urged to flag spam (and otherwise "bad") content so it...
by nightnight 6 years ago
Hi everyone I'm quite a new member to HubPages. So far I love it, there is a great community of writers and I feel that publishing a article is really easy and fun to do. However I spent some time exploring the forum to see what a lot of Hubbers out there were saying and I came across the google...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|