Since November I have been trying to put up hubs and was always
marked 'substandard'. I only receive a automated notice with a list of what could be wrong. Then, at the bottom a list of suggested hubs which are perfect.
How to make a Tuna Melt Sandwich
St Regis Bora Bora
How to Refinish Floors
How to Build a Brick BBQ smoker
I am grateful for suggesting to read these hubs but it didn't really help to find what is really wrong with mine.
In November I wrote a hub about Tenko and Wallenberg. Both were rejected as 'substandard'. I managed to rescue Tenko but not Wallenberg. I thought it would be a perfect idea to pay a tribute to a man who was a Swedish diplomat in Hungary and saved thousands of Jewish children from the Nazis. He himself was then captured by the Russians and never heard of.
Another hub was my Christmas wishes to all my friends and it was marked too personal. I re-wrote it twice just to make sure I reached my friends otherwise I wouldn't have bothered. Eventually it was accepted.
Then I wrote a hub about Christmas being the feast of peace and good will and questioned if the message reaches people after over 2000 years. The reason I made this because 11 people were murdered over the holiday alone. It made me wonder how much people really listen to the message.
Now I wrote about Sports Industries and again it was rejected as 'substandard'. I pointed out that we only watch and know the stars but there is a tremendous number of people working behind the scene. The sportssonsor amounting to a huge amount of money. The implication of TV and so on. There is a lot of information which people don't know or think about it. So what was wrong with that. Again 'substandard'
I email the team to find out exactly what is the problem all over sudden but never received a reply. I re-worked my hub but again it was rejected 'substandard'.
I have been here two years and have almost 400 hubs with quite a number of good comments. Now I am trying to increase my hubs and also to increase my earning but I have all the time this problem.
Please help me to sort it out. The last hub I hardly had it up and I received this email. Is there some Internet malfunction because I click on PUBLISH closed Google down and went over to Yahoo and had already the email. If it is then please sort it out.
This post was made about two hours ago, right around the time that this Hubber received a reply to his/her email, which was received about 22 hours ago, meaning it took us about 20 hours to reply. We'd like to make it clear that if you email us for help or clarification, you will receive a response. Exceptions include completely unreasonable requests, such as repeated emails asking the same question, etc.
Your response in this thread is completely inappropriate. Hello, hello has been a Hubber in good standing, with a loyal following, for more than two years.
This thread has nothing to do with how HP responds to something within a time frame. This thread has everything to do with how HP has not found fault with HH's Hubs until now, after two years. So, her hubs have not been "substandard" for two years, but are now?
Yours is a total non-communication.
Thank you, Sally's Trove, for kindness to help me. That is the reason I find it so hard to just take off my hub and go away. I made such wonderful friends here. I don't think HP deserves them anymore. I hope you are not getting into trouble for my sake.
Apologies for perhaps not making my intentions clear. I was merely trying to make the incidental point that, though in emails and elsewhere I often see statements such as "HubPages did not get back to me", the reality is that we get back to everyone, excluding the most marginal of circumstances - i.e., when the same question is being asked over and over, spam, etc.
I didn't want users to get the idea that we choose to simply ignore their questions. We do not.
As for the substandard Hubs, I stand by the judgment of our moderators, and I remind everyone that while the standing of individual Hubbers can factor into moderation decisions in certain cases, we make every effort to review Hubs on their merits and their merits alone. It is in our and the community's best interests to do so.
While you may send a reply email, in many cases those emails don't answer the question asked and simply state some policy of its in everybody's interest. Non denial denial if you will. You probably sent some link sending her somewhere that listed some vague policy.
Quite. At the very least you have to reply and restate what you actually needed to know. I imagine some people give up rather than do that.
Well, I was banned for 7 days and sent 2 emails to find out why. Never heard anything at all. So, they do not always reply to queries made by members, despite the claim.
Yes, Dan, what I said was true. I did not lie about this fact.
From looking at your Hubs, there are consistent grammatical English language errors throughout. As this has now become one of those points that Google is emphasizing in the wake of the Panda updates, I'm guessing this is what is causing your account to be on moderation as being substandard.
Thank you for your comment. I know I got problems sometimes.
Ayup. That last sentence is an example, by the way.
I know that from time to time a few people have offered to help other folks with grammatical issues. I think some wanted to be paid, but others were willing to offer at least some help out of the goodness of their hearts.
I know I would not mind helping now and then. Maybe posting in Extreme Hub Makeover and specifically saying "I need help with grammar" would elicit some useful responses? Can't hurt to try..
Thank you for your comment.. I don't know anything about the advice you made. I certainly would be willing to try.
Greetings, Hello, hello. I am relatively new here, but at anytime you would like to message me off of my profile to assist you in proofing your yet to be submitted hubs based on grammar issues, I will take the time to assist.
I too am willing to offer editing assistance by way of correcting grammatical errors.
Hello, Dale, these messages are so mixed up that I just discovered yours here. No insult meant. Thank you so much for your kindness to help.
I had a look at your hub which details the growth of international organisations such as the League of Nations, which I believe is your latest?
On first reading there are a number of grammatical errors which will reduce the readers enjoyment of the hub. I would suggest that you either ask someone else to proof read hubs for you or check your hub with a spell and grammar checker.
I think that HP are taking this action as sometimes hubs which have grammar or spelling errors are mass produced spam, created by automatic translation machines, which I presume is not the method you use.
Take care and don't lose heart, things will work out, just keep at it!
I have a question also
I had a hub taken down also, after I corrected the errors it took a while but they did let it be published again. Am I allowed to put it back up on spot hubbers put their new hub on again?
Right here in your OP might be one of the problems....
"The sportssonsor amounting to a huge amount of money."
What does that mean?
I meant sportssponsorship. I am so upset and that is why it happened. They taken off hubs which had been published for months and even Google was there. By tomorrow morning there will be any or hardly any hubs of mine on the Internet. I have to leave. I made such wonderful, good friends and now I have to leave them.
Or, you know, you could just fix them. But leaving works too I guess... if that's the way you want to go.
Hi, don't leave, maybe just go back and edit your hubs every time you get a sub standard sign. Just use the spell check over and over to make sure, give it a try, don't worry we all make mistakes.
Hello Nell, I am so upset, It's not the spelling, I use it every time, it's the grammar. I can't take the hub off any more to have someboby to check it over and correct it. I myself can't do it. I might see here or there some but on a whole, no.
Hanna - you have written some wonderful hubs and I, too, would hate to see you go. You were one of the first to become a fan when I joined, and you always come and comment on my hubs!
You are always so supportive of others. If you would like some help with editing your hubs for grammar etc., I will be happy to help out, too. Contact me through my email and I can edit some hubs for you.
Your English grammar can be a bit wonky sometimes, and now Google penalizes for that, so the moderators are really hard on poor grammar because it is often one of the signs of spam. I know your work is all your own, but your sometimes poor grammar detracts from your overall work somewhat - especially in the eyes of Google.
John is right - even though you can't transfer the hubs, you can copy and paste the text into an email or a word document and send the hub to be edited. With several of us helping out, we should have quite a few hubs edited back up in a short time.
And add me to the list of those you can email to. I'd be happy to help,
At this rate we'll have all your hubs sorted before tomorrow
Thank you, Pcunix, for offering me you help. My goodness, have I got wonderful friends. I am trying hard to learn to cut and paste. Computer is a bit of a problem but I will try.
If you are having to edit previously published hubs, send the url only because they are likely still in the cache which means whoever is editing can copy/paste it to correct instead.
I find copy/pasting easiest to do by simply highlighting the text, right click and choose copy. Then place the cursor where you want it pasted, right click and choose paste.
Other prefer using keyboard shortcuts ctrl+C and ctrl+V.
I can't give you a link because of forum rules, but if you put "Computer basics: cut and paste and beyond" into the search box here at the top of the page, you'll find a hub I wrote that addresses this for those who haven't mastered it yet. It might help.
If you send one hub to each of us who have offered to help, you should be right as rain in no time.
Thank you, RedElf, for your encouraging message. I can't belief I had so many supporters. Thank you is too inadaquate for what I feel receiving all this kindness. I know it sounds woolly but I am really overwhelmed. I will go now read your email. Thank you for giving so much time which is always short, I know.
I am retired Language Arts teacher and can tell you I have seen grammatical errors in almost everything you have written here. I write my articles on Microsoft Works and use their spelling and grammar checker before ever submitting anything. This doesn't fix all of it, but it does get most of the errors. It also forces me to read everything several times. I then find further mistakes.
Asking people to help you improve your grammar is a huge request. Once you are an adult, it is almost impossible to improve your grammar to the point where you will be able to write really well. It wouldn't hurt you to take an adult ed class to refresh your skills. Good luck.
I hope this will work out well in the end for you. It takes a lot of time and effort to make that many hubs. The amount of work invested in them shows commitment which will help you to keep writing and editing.
It is possible that updating them will be useful as Google's November algorithm update was supposed to favor regular updates.
They took ten more hubs off the Internet which had been published for a long time and even Google clicked on it. So, what is this all about? Thank you for your visit and your encouraging words.
With Google's Panda update (first version launched in Feb 2011) quality standards changed and thus so did HubPages' standards. This situation has been discussed extensively for months in the forums and in the site newsletter and Hub authors have been given a lot of time to review and fix their Hubs.
Now HubPages is slowly working their way through the entire site, moderating everything that wasn't fixed or improved to fit the new quality standards. If you haven't been keeping up with the changes on the site, that's unfortunate but the site rules have gotten more strict over this past year and a lot of what was okay two years ago isn't now.
This is true. But it's no excuse for Dan's inappropriate comment.
At the same time, Hh is a valued presence here. Any help she'd like, many are willing to give.
Oh Sally's Trove, your words are so kind and welcome. It really threw me. If HP wants it so correct why don't install a grammar check. The spelling check isn't very good. Other sites have a much better one. Thank ou again for your kindness.
Hello Palache, but I am sorry to say that I can't see it is Google because Google is still coming to all those sites which have now been blocked. Surely Google wouldn't click on it if it wasn't good enough. That is just my opinion not having any comuter knowledge or Internet at all. I thank you for your viist and comment.
Hello hello, you might want to write your hubs on your computer file first (I use Microsoft Word) because it easily corrects spelling and grammatical errors in your writing before you ever get it on the hub. Hope this helps.
Hanna, I'll help you. Send me an email. I know English isn't your first language, and English grammar is tough enough for native English speakers! Please don't give up and leave!
I agree...I've been enjoying the information you share with the world for as long as you've been here. I've been a fan of yours for a very long time.
We all know English is not your first language, but you always get your point across. I join with Holle in offering help.
Hello, habee, and thank you so much. It is so heart warming to read these words after I was so devasted. The friendship from you all was the reason why I just couldn't walk away. Why don't they put a grammar check in their programme it would have saved a lot of hurt and it isn't just me. I read a lot of complains from other writers, not only about grammar, who then just went somewhere else. I couldn't do it because of all the nice people I met here.
Hannah, don't leave. just do one hub per day. It takes me many, many hours to write one simple hubpages. We all receive warning notifications and learn from each message. Your English grammar will slowly improve. This can be your university experience as your refine your blogs. The information contains quality content. Blessings, Debby
Habee , that is so kind of you. Well done .
I will help too . I'm not too bad on grammar, spelling, and stuff.
Hello, hello; I hope you accept the help people are willing offer here. You have a lot of informative Hubs about a lot of interesting subjects. It would be a waste for you to start over, and it would unfortunate if you just gave up writing altogether.
I hope you hang in, and try not to let something like this particular "issue" upset you too much. Besides, maybe if you accept the help of friends who are more than willing to try to help; you'll iron out some of the grammar stuff that results from English not being your first language. Considering, and compared to, the problems a lot of people (including me, with fluency only in my own language) would have trying to write in a second language, any issues that show up in your Hubs are really pretty minor.
What if you started by first putting any new Hubs in the Extreme Make-Over forum and asking for grammar help as you write them? And then, what if you dealt with any unpublished ones a few at a time, and with the help of anyone who has offered it (through e.mail). If there are other old ones that are eventually unpublished then deal with those as they happen.
If you don't have MS Word (which catches a lot of grammar stuff), there's also Open Office (from Open Office dot org), which you can download free and which is very similar to MS Word. White Smoke is another one that you can download for free (I'm not sure if it's only a trial, but you might be able to get some grammar-checking done within in the trial period if that's the case). Grammar checkers won't always get everything, but they can pick up enough stuff that would eliminate a lot of "issues".
Anyway, hope you hang in and try not to be too upset by this.
I agree with everything Lisa says. Use this as an opportunity to let others who want to help do just that.
Hello, Lisa, and thank you for your kind and encouraging words. All of you really helped me already in putting me back on my perch again. I must admit I was devastated and that is not easily done. I am on a whole quite tough but this really knock me. It was mainly the mannerism. One after another was rejected and only by this standardized notice which says everything and nothing. I will never forget all your friendship at a time like this. A most sincere thank you.
Hannah, You can edit it as time permits, one at a time. I can feel your frustrations. Take this as a challenge and don't give up. You are a valued hubber here!!
Hello my friend, yes, I would but they are blocking or pulling it off one by one and I won't get any views or clicks. By now they blocked 12 hubs and they all had clicks on it. Thank for your visit and your re-assurance.
In the future, you would do well to keep copies of your work in a separate place on your computer. I did this when I was writing for another site and was glad I did so.
I do hope you stay, Hello, hello. You've always been a very supportive member of the community and we'd hate to lose you. Take advantage of the offer those with grammatical expertise have offered you and you'll do fine. Don't get disheartened!
Thank you, Randy, for such encouraging words. It is such good friends made me stay here. I just couldn't walk away. Therefore, I wrote on the forum to help others too because I am not the only one that it happened too.
Yes, I would have gladly accepted all the help I was offered but with the hubs being blocked nobody can get to it. I even can't transfer them to be checkout. So I have to keep going through and hopefully I get it right this time. It is such a waste of time. I don't belief it is Google because they still visit my hubs, even the once before they were blocked , and click on it.
Hey I'm not writing new hubs at the minute, so if you care to send any that need edited just contact me through my profile and I will happily help
Hey, maybe you could help me with my awkward writing style, Izzy?
Actually, in all seriousness here Randy, why are you and me the only ones still in the doldrums?
We got told we had awkward writing style (ie it doesn't read well aloud) but Google can't read.
I was so sorry to see HP user 'Hello, Hello' in such a serious predicament earlier.
Google really can't read. Otherwise they would never permit to have such obviously spun, unreadable shit ahead of my hubs in the search engines.
My question is now, are we being manually held down by HP? Can they do it? Is it possible?
Wow, that is interesting. I tell you something which happened before. I clicked EDIT on my hub about King Louis XIV and I was straight told that it will be newly looked at before re-published. Now this hub is one of my bestsellers so-to-speak. I was furious to have it taken it off for some time. Then informed me that my picture are not right. They weren't fuzzy but were quite good and I had them half sized. Now he was known for its glamour and these showed the eleborate halls and rooms he built. I had to reduce them to small which don't give the impression of the glamour at all. I was furious because people will just pass them over and I lose money.
They installed now a button that when you click on any of your hubs, even just to add some more information, they have to re-examining it before publishing it again. It loses two days, at least, of earning.
Hello, Randy, I read all your hubs and to me I don't think you have an awkward style of writing at all and the same goes for Izzy. I am not just saying this. I was most surprised when I read Izzy's and your notes about this.
Thanks, Hello, hello. I don't think either of us took it too seriously, especially with some of the stuff which seems to be doing okay by others here. I do hope you can solve the problems with your hubs as you certainly try very hard to do things correctly. Too bad some native English speakers are actually much worse at writing than you. I'd be glad to help you too, but I'm simply not qualified to do so.
I do admire your trying so hard, though
Thank you so much Randy for your wonderful message. If they only would have pointed out by email to correct my grammar and not just blocked them with that standard notice I would not floored me so much. Oh don't say this about the native English speakers you will be marched out and shot lol. Take care and all the best.
Hello, IzzyM, and thank you so much for offering my help. The problem is now that they blocked the hubs they don't agree with. I can't transfer them and nobody can click on them. When eanybody else but me goes to my hubs they just don't exist. Another 'nice' thing that happened.
NOW I AM REALLY COMPLETELY FLABBERGASTED.
On my hub -- All About Financial Market -- it states there, of course, substandard but also watermark and pixelated pictures
I EVEN HAVEN'T GOT ANY PICTURES THERE. PLEASE HP EXPLAIN
That really puts the cream on the cake.
I have to say this is Hubpages at its finest.
Hello, hello is a much loved Hubber and the mere fact that so many have come out to help just shows the love and support one can find here on HP.
Good Luck Hello, something tells me you are going to be just fine ♥
This stinks.. Hello hello I hope this is just a mistake and they lift the ban.
Finally hello hello counted her last breathe here.. And she was banned...
I got an email from Hanna today. She asked me to thank everyone here who was concerned about her.
Thanks so much Habee. I hope she is doing well and finding a new place to post her blogs.
by cre8ivOne 9 years ago
Do hubs with spelling errors make you think less of a hub?Is anyone else distracted by a hub that has decent content but several spelling errors or grammatical errors?
by the pink umbrella 7 years ago
"one should always aim at being interesting rather than exact" -VOLTAIREYes, i know that checking your spelling and grammer make for a better hub score, but is anyone else sick of other hubbers who you arent familiar with commenting on your page that you misspelled something? Lets chat...
by Don Bobbitt 10 years ago
Why am I seeing SO MANY Hubs with obvious GRAMMATICAL ERRORS in the TITLE?I mean, People? The Title is your HOOK!
by Wendy S. Wilmoth 9 years ago
Would you want to be told if your hub had a few grammatical errors?I see a lot of hubs that are basically good, but their quality is marred by an unsightly grammatical error or two. I am tempted to comment with a suggestion for fixing it. If your hub had such an error, would you want to know?
by RocketCityWriter 4 years ago
Is it rude to point out grammar/spelling mistakes on hubs via comments?I've come across numerous hubs that have grammar and spelling errors, some minor and some littered with mistakes. Otherwise, these hubs would be interesting and will written in my opinion. Is it rude to point out these mistakes...
by Dennis L. Page 10 years ago
Why do fellow Hubbers fawn over a Hub filled with errors?Many times I will see an attention grabbing title and within the first sentence there will be a misspelling of a word. Okay, to err is human and we have all made typographical errors. However, in proceeding further into the story presented I...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|