jump to last post 1-9 of 9 discussions (9 posts)

If one does not have a body, but exists as a digital consciousness, is one still

  1. Simone Smith profile image94
    Simone Smithposted 6 years ago

    If one does not have a body, but exists as a digital consciousness, is one still human?


  2. deblipp profile image57
    deblippposted 6 years ago

    That's so...Star Trek. But if you *started* as human, I don't think you lose your humanity.

  3. Alastar Packer profile image85
    Alastar Packerposted 6 years ago

    It all depends on which is the correct of two suppositions:
    Number one: If no energy essence, spirit/soul form exists and depending on the definition of human, then yes, digital consciousness while remaining whats called human is not only possible but a surety.
    Number two: If an energy, spirit/soul does exist in biological creations; and if that is whats called human; then the answer is no as the generative essence of the 'spirit', could never be transferred into something beyond the original intent of this 'Source'.
    Just one persons take on it and thank you Simone for this intelligent and challenging question.

  4. Ari Lamstein profile image80
    Ari Lamsteinposted 6 years ago

    This quesiton presupposes that you currently have a body and do not exist as digital consciousness. 

    Why do you believe that to be the case?

  5. ptosis profile image74
    ptosisposted 6 years ago

    Consciousness = having experienceof seeing, hearing, feeling, pain, thinking.

  6. SamboRambo profile image82
    SamboRamboposted 6 years ago

    I assume the "digital" in your question refers to an image on a computer, for instance, and that the image is governed by programs that fit the human experience. I also assume your usage of "human" is after the fact of us having been in a physical, human body.

    All things being relative, we would feel human and act human, limited only by the thoroughness of the "program" used. As 3-dimensional illusions can be programmed, and also the interaction of two solid forms can be duplicated in simulations, then we will appear to exist in a 3-dimensional world. If pain can be programmed, we will actually feel pain.

    The reason I think this way, is because I believe matter is an illusion, or mostly an illusion, as scientists still haven't been able to determine the smallest particle, but have, instead, found a lot of empty space within atoms.

    I think pain is an illusion, because sometimes when I press on a tender area, I feel a sharp jab elsewhere in my body.

  7. Miss Info profile image82
    Miss Infoposted 6 years ago

    No. Unfortunately, to "shut off" a human would be to murder him. On the other hand, to shut off annoying cellphone calls or text messages (id est, a type of "digital consciousness") is just a click of a button away.

  8. jtyler profile image57
    jtylerposted 6 years ago

    It depends on how it is transferred.  The program must be a case only, where your mind takes complete control.  Nothing must be changed, and something indeed must be transferred.  If these conditions are met, then it would be possible.

  9. parrster profile image86
    parrsterposted 6 years ago

    Define human?
    If by human is meant the synergistic composite of body, mind and soul, then by definition, no, one cannot be human without the body.