jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (4 posts)

What is THE ONE reason why many Black Americans AREN'T highly successful educati

  1. gmwilliams profile image86
    gmwilliamsposted 17 months ago

    What is THE ONE reason why many Black Americans AREN'T highly successful educationally &

    socioeconomically?    Is IT endemic racism, negative environments, parents advocating just getting by/surviving, a poverty mentality, &/or anti-intellectualism?


  2. profile image59
    Setank Setunkposted 17 months ago

    I think it is all race related but compounded by the complex nature of social perception. With all the concerns you mentioned, consider this: If I ran up to Samuel L. Jackson in an airport and said " OMG, it's Morgan Freeman", what would you think? What would Sam L. think in this situation? But more importantly, what is the affect of having to consider the nature of my error, or to validate or moderate your own perceptions regarding my error. What affect does this conflict of perception have on the sense of self?
    These conflicts or challenges to perception are relentless and restrict or interfere with, what would normally be, simple subjective cognition, and this problem is far more pronounced in children. This resistance to subjective cognitive assimilation is common in rural white communities as well, but for very different reasons.
    Really good teachers can work through these challenges, but really good teachers are far to rare to serve as a viable solution. I think we have to start from scratch, and this must begin with relocating entire oppressed communities to new locations. Places were they can maintain their culture and sense of racial identity but have access to all the things the rest of us take for granted: Good paying jobs, Houses(not Housing), quality education, jet skis, deer hunting, bike trails, room to go a bit wild and the like.

  3. tamarawilhite profile image91
    tamarawilhiteposted 17 months ago

    The illegitimacy rate that has gone from 1/4 to 3/4 in the past 50 years. The child of an unwed mother is three to four times more likely to be held back a grade, drop out of school, become mentally ill and dependent on welfare REGARDLESS of race or mother's income.
    The lack of a married father to provide stability, discipline and guidance makes the odds much worse a child will fail in life. The problem for blacks is that the broken family is their norm.

  4. gmwilliams profile image86
    gmwilliamsposted 17 months ago


    In the average Black American community, there is endemic negativity in consciousness, mentality, mindset,  outlook, philosophy, psychology, purview, & outlook.  Many Black Americans have a passive philosophy towards life.  They even have a dependency on varying levels.   Racism only plays a very minute part in the majority of Black Americans not being successful in American society.

    Many Black American parents don't take education seriously. They seldom appear at their children's PTA meetings.  They believe that it is the teacher's job to help THEIR children w/schoolwork, not them.  They refuse to be proactive regarding their children's education as opposed to other racial/ethnic groups who are very proactive regarding their children's education.  They don't stress to their children a high level of success & achievement.  They furthermore emphasize being social over being intellectual.  This behavior is evident even among middle class Black Americans as I have witnessed such behavior first hand.  Black American children who are more intellectual are told to "get with it", "hand out", & "be more like others".  Have you noticed that the most popular Black American children aren't that smart while the smart Black American children are ostracized, even demonized?

    Many Black Americans seem to be happy working for others instead of working for themselves.  That is the dependency nature.  They want others to take care of them & not assume any responsibility.  In addition to working for others, they seem to be concentrated in lower to middle level positions-this goes even for educated Black Americans.  I know one Black American male who refused promotions because he indicated that it would be too much of a hassle.  Many Black Americans, including relatives, indicated that it is just TOO MUCH HEADACHE to assume responsible positions.  So they remain in lower level positions where they have the least autonomy & ownership.

    Many Black American parents advise their children not to reach "TOO HIGH" but to settle for middling.  They seem to be afraid of success or that success isn't for them but for someone else.  They appear to be comfortable with poverty or middling.  They may even feel that they aren't deserving of socioeconomic success & the good things it brings.  So they settle & teach their children to settle instead of aiming for the highest.