Which is less harmful -
A glass of Beer or A glass of Soft-drink (Coke, Pepsi)
Soft Drink? Let us know the answer towards the end of the thread.
Well, no one's been pulled over for Driving under the Influence of pop.
I think a glass of both would not be so bad.
Sorry to sound like a dull bore but i'd go for a glass of coke.. I quit drinking after a terrible incident last year.
I don't think that either are harmful in moderation. Its when you start drinking 6 pints of beer a day, or 2 litres of coke a day, that you need to start worrying about your health.
Does it mean 2 pints of beer or 600 ml of coke does not harm our body.
I don't think that having a couple of pints is going to do much harm to your body to be honest with you. In fact, to the contrary, certain alcohol's can be beneficial when consumed in moderation. For example, a small glass of red wine each day is supposed to be good for your heart.
I don't really drink much now, but as a teenager I would go out and get paralytic two or three times a week. If I was still doing that now (5/6 years later) then I would probably be worried about the state of my liver.... other than that, it does not worry me in the slightest.
That is right ryankett, those days were good/funny when you do not really worry for health much, but now we got some responsibilities and started looking at our health
i believe neither, it is only how much thought you put in to it would make it harmful.
Well neither is good in excess of course. But I drink plenty of both and I'm still alive
Its the real thing
Probably both bad as either one screws up ya liver.
Actually that makes me think , wonder if our livers were healthier( say 50/60 yrs ago) before carbonated drinks or less sugar period.
Actually, I think that ironically, a can of coke is worse than a can of beer. The Coke has a not of unnatural acidic ingredients that can tear at your system.
Beer are usually more natural. This is good as long as you are only having one of them.
Neither of them offers any nutrition, and too much of either isn't great; but I'd have to say Coke is less harmful, based on the fact that drinking too much Coke doesn't generally lead to vomiting and/or being drunk and/or alcohol poisoning and/or Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. I'm not saying Coke is good or doesn't cause potentially serious problems. I just think, ounce-for-ounce, beer is worse.
Neither. Both are really hard on the liver. They offer no nutritional value. Beer is empty calories and lots of carbs! Soda is lots of sugar. Especially stay away from diet sodas which contain artificial sweeteners that are known carcinogens.
sorry kristie believe it or not but pepsi is harmful than a beer.
i will prefer beer if i can maintain a good healthy diet.
Captain, some guy keeps calling me "sweetheart" and "darling" over in the religion forum. Can you make him walk the plank please?
I am straight edge...so don't drink alcohol. But really I don't drink any sort of soft drinks as well...too much sugar and being that I am already to the gills in the hyperactivity department...no need to add fuel to fire.
Water or coffee...occasionally a Monster Lo-Carb when sleep has not graced my presence and I need the kick in the arse.
BTW...that dude is creepy Colebabie...yikes!
I don't drink beer but I think it is healthier than soft drinks.
Neither is good for you.
What's interesting is that people are automatically assuming that the alcohol is worse than the corn syrup (bad, empty calories) and the carbonation (leeches minerals).
But really the problem is that you've thrown out a general type of beverage vs a specific name brand soft drink. I know lots of microbrews that would literally be healthier than a Coke brand soft drink.
I will tell you something for a fact, Pepsi Max is so full of caffeine it gave me heart palputations wheras a full bottle of red wine just gave me a good nights sleep, oh and red teeth but I found it washes out ok in the morning.
Pepsi (and other soft drinks)has high fructose corn syrup,caffiene, sugar, colorings, phosphoric acid, caffeine, citric acid and 'natural' flavors.
Beer is a food made from natural ingredienets: hops, yeast, barley and malt. It is a good source magnesium, potassium, and niacin. Also has some protein calcium and other vitamins and Minerals. Studies have shown that Moderate (1 or 2 glasses a day) can reduce blood clots, lower rates of heart disease, improve mental function and bone density-- it might help reduce triglycerides and 'bad' cholesteral.
As per this post, beer seems to be very less harmful as comparison to soft-drinks. But yeah, red wine would definitely be least harmful.
As many said beer will make you drunk, question is only for a 'single glass' of either (beer or coke).
Sorry but beer doesn't have any amounts of vitamins or minerals to affect a person's diet. Some beers have minimal amounts of protein. But its Carbs Carbs Carbs and a little sodium. Maybe homemade or organic beer may be more nutritional, but not the stuff ya get in a bar.
As detailed in an article by Nanci Grayson, RD, alcohol consumption directly impacts nutrition. “The process of metabolizing alcohol requires nutrients. As the liver decreases its supply of these nutrients, the blood stream is called upon to replenish the supply. As a result, body cells are deprived of critical nutrients and normal body functions suffer.”
No Beer, No alcohol.
No coke, no Pepsi.
Drink milk and fresh juice.
A beer has malt in it I am sure, so I will vote for the beer
Beer is less harmful, coke has more sugar but by far, drink water and wine, it's the best
I'll go for coke, although I seldom drink softdrink as well! I'm a juice lover!
Both are very very bad for you...I mean not good at all, but beer is worse by a longshot. You wont get a hangover from a soda.
I thought I would add to this post. Beer or Coke?
Both can do harm actually in excess.
But I will share something about soft drinks from experience.
I am an electrician. There are jobs I have been on that the walls of a building are Block. We electrician have to install metal conduits (pipe) into the block walls so we can get wires down them for outlets.
Sometimes while the walls are being constructed and we have to piece these pipes together as the wall gets taller...the "morter" that goes between the blocks to seal them together...will accidently (hum, hum) get into the pipes and dry by the time I need to get wiring down them.
How do I clear out the conduits/pipes?
I take a can of Coke/Pepsi or another brand and pour it down the conduit/pipe. Wait just a few minutes, sometimes longer....and out flows the "dissolved morter!"
Think about what coke is like in our stomachs.
And btw...I do still drink coke products, just not like I use to.
check out my hub "Soda Pop is Unhealthy" for some latest research facts and figures.
I haven't researched beer, so can't compare.
Most defiantly Coke. It cleans the tartar off of your teeth.
Coke has a ph level of 2.4 (acidic) it will dissolve a tooth, next time your child loses a tooth leave it in a glass of Coke overnight.
Coke is great for cleaning your car battery, but not for drinking.
Coke funded a Million dollar reasearch effort and as luck would have it the American Dental Association (ADA) found that it was not harmful to the teeth.
Soft drinks also leach calcium from the bones and degrade the gums.
If you're addicted and can't set it down, use a straw at least you'll save the front of your mouth.
Something in Coke changes the chemistry of the brain much like other addictive drugs, which is why like smoking and other ugly habits you want a Coke when you're stressed, bored, etc.
Why else would we become enslaved to such a substance?
As for beer, if you can do it without getting drunk and without causing someone else to get off the sober ranch - Cheers to you!
Not sure which would be more harmful. I guess it would depend on who we were talking about. If you are a recovering alcoholic and sober I would say the beer is more harmful. The next question is harmful to who? I have never seen anyone hit someone over a Pepsi but have over a beer.
by Jenn 6 years ago
I can't imagine how anyone can drink 2 gallons of Coke per DAY! But this woman also had a very poor diet nutrition-wise and was a heavy smoker, so it probably just wasn't the soda alone that caused her death. I just don't understand how she didn't see all of this as a formula for disaster, or if...
by How? 6 years ago
Is drinking beer daily good for health?
by KikiCobain 5 years ago
Would you regard someone as an alcoholic if they consumed atleast 2 beers, most, if not every day?
by Wesman Todd Shaw 2 years ago
What is the best beer to have for breakfast?I find the Blue Moon Cinnamon Horchata to be a fine start the day brew, but your thoughts and suggestions may prove useful as well.
by kozmicbluej 6 years ago
Southern Comfort - If you want it mixed, should you drink it with coke or lemonade?I prefer coke, but always get asked "Don't you mean lemonade". And incidentally is it seen as male, female or unisex drink?! Cheers!
by dailytop10 5 years ago
What stops you from drinking at least 8 glasses of water a day?Experts agree that we should drink at least 8 glasses of water every day to be healthy. However, most of us fails to do so. I usually drink less than needed out of no reason at all. I simply can't force my body to drink a full glass of...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|