Just wondering what everyone's thoughts are. For me, just staying away from my primary drug of choice (alcohol for me) isn't being clean and sober. For example, I've known addicts who still claim to be "sober" but smoke weed. It's a slippery slope, no doubt. In my mind, you cannot be clean and sober if you still drink or use substances EVER... Even if it's just once in a while. Any thoughts?
Sober means no drinking. Clean means no drinking or drugs.
I am 100% clean!!!
Hey, well that's something we agree on. I'm just not so sure everyone else does.
Clean and sober is a treatment term. The same way 'drug of choice' is a medical term. Treatment centers feel the need to distinguish between alcohol and other drugs. 12-step recovery programs which offer a life free of all drugs, do not use the term. AA uses the word sober (many try to say that means they make it okay to 'use drugs' as long as you don't drink.) This is not the case and not indicated in their literature. And is a very narrow definition of the word. NA uses the word clean, as does all the literature, in an effort to minimize the confusion (or excuse, as the case may be) that alcohol is a drug, it just happens to be legal and socially acceptable. There is a huge difference between 12 step recovery, treatment and the medical community. In short, when those with an understanding say clean, they mean from ALL substances. And those that say sober, mean that as well. Then there are those who came to 12-step via treatment or medical recommendations and they think clean and sober is 12 step language. Then there are those 'old-timers' who got clean in a time when NA meetings were scarce and AA quite prolific and the 'fitting in' led to a bastardization of language from both programs. Of course, there will always be those who live in denial and don't drink and call themselves sober or conversely call themselves clean yet still drink, this is not indicative of recovery, but of the disease. I get a chuckle when someone invites me for a drink and I choose not to go into my life story and simply say 'I don't drink" and they proceed to tell me they don't drink either, just a beer after work, or whatever...these are usually normies who have no idea what I'm talking about.
I agree with you both. I just keep running across people who claim to be "in recovery", but evidently their definition doesn't match up with mine.
To be truly "clean and sober" it means no drugs OR alcohol. Period. You can be a recovering alcoholic and addict, a recovering addict and an alcoholic, and several different variations of those words, but to be truly "clean and sober" it's nothing-zip-nada-zilch, lol!
clean sober means living without any mood altering substances and living with the ability to cope and deal without altering your emotions and lastly these words represent a way of living including serenity and spiritual growth often, ultimately happiness and contentment. The opposite being 'dry' like white knuckling while trying not to drink or get high.
All true. And, being truly sober means cleaning your house. Really digging deep and being able to be honest not only with yourself, but those around you.
I very much agree here...In fact, there is no other way to put it!
You cannot be clean and not sober
sober but not clean
abstinence of any mood altering chemicals / alcohol or drugs
Hey Kimberly!! Talk to you tonight!!Going to a meeting. Was working on Hub
true for the "real" sober and clean, but addicts and alcoholics can be a sneaky bunch, lol!
by the way-I am in that club too, unfortunately. The seventies bled into the 2000's somehow...
Yes, indeed. I've thought friends were really sober before only to find out they're still using. It actually really pissed me off. One, that I fell for the lies, but two, that I shared intimate details of my life and using days that were meant for sober ears only. I once found out a sponsor of mine had been relapsing for a long time without telling me. Oh, but she was only smoking pot. Give me a break!
Hey, Madison. Good to see you here. The 80's bled into the 90's for me... I got sober in 1995. 100% sober.
How was your evening last night? I had a good laugh and now I am a member of 2 clubs. LoL
I had a good time last night, too. It was nice to laugh in the end. You'd better free up your calendar for these club activities.
Last night was, well, uneventful as usual.
Did you make the coffee or go to bed?
I went to bed. Actually I read a little on resentments in the BB and on how for people like us it is the number one offender. I needed to read it, because I felt like I was beginning to build resentment toward him. I felt much better after reading. I usually go to 4 meetings a week, this week I only went once. So I have to get back on track.
Good, Madison. I will probably get a bunch of grief about this, but AA isn't my program of recovery. I go to Women for Sobriety which suits me a lot more. It's complicated, no doubt, but AA didn't work for me. I relapsed numerous times before getting involved with my current support group. It's a pretty active group here, so that helps.
I know AA helps a lot of people and I fully support it, however it just wasn't for me...
Everyone has their own addictions, no one is truely clean and sober.
Of course, different addictions have different affects on other people.
Yes, and you've gotta "walk the walk" not just "talk the talk".
Heck...clean and sober means being off of all mind inducing drugs including alcohol. I have nearly 12 years sobriety. Hooray!
Addiction can be more than just a physical substance, certian rituals can produce endorphines, even prayer, others could be addicted to things like picking at spots.
I had a friend who went off to university simply because he was so interested about human addictions and he could tell you a lot more fluently about it than I could!
Clean and sober means that a person is not under the influence of any type of addiction of drugs. In other words, clean and sober also means being free of toxins which you can become with the use of natural herbs, meditation, yoga, and physical exercise.
I am 100% clean and sober. I don't do drugs and I don't drink alcohol.
Been recovered/recovering for 2 years now
so amazing, you rock girl
me too off 24 iv coke and heroine abuse daily
so proud of you
Pills, cocaine, heroine, alcohol, and sometimes meth for me. But it's been two years since I've done any of that crap and I swore to myself that I'd never touch it again.
Just wanted to take this opportunity to tell you, Lyrics, that your hubs are often an inspiration for me. Sometimes, when I feel weak, I read your articles and they help me to gain strength. So I just wanted to thank you.
I truly believe this entirely depends on the individual... Alcoholism isn't the sickness... addictive behavior is... that being said, an idividual with a problem in this area will never really be "clean" until he or she deals with this mental trap. They will continue to abuse whatever they are using in an effort to fill that hole... It makes no difference whatsoever if they are sober... in the end, this state of being will consume them if left to their own devices, be it food, sex, stealing, adrenaline rushes, etc... Granted, just getting off of the harsh effects of mind altering substances is a great start, but that's all it is! Substitution will continue. This is why so many people relapse. It's not so much that the particular substance was so great for them. I've seen people blow all their money replacing drugs with work out supplements in an effort to get well, but not change one bit upstairs! There are also cases of individuals who don't have this addictive issue, and don't have a problem with moderation. If this is truly the case, then I say they ARE sober and clean, even if they occasionally do whatever they do. The difference is in honesty with one's self. If you are an addict, you will know it. I, myself, completely lack the ability to do anything in moderation, therefore I must abstain... It's that simple. I just wrote a hub on this basic subject... check it out...
You raise a good point shape_shifter. Once an addictive personality always an addictive personality! That's why recovery is so important. If you simply substitute primary addition to your drug of choice(alcohol or drugs) for another (gambling, shopping, internet, etc.) then you are NOT clean and sober, are you?
Where do cigarettes, coffee and sugar fit into all this? It's damned hard to quit a drug or alcohol habit that took you to your knees. Kicking it is essentially to go against your mental and physical nature. It's a friggin' miracle!
So if you continue to smoke cigarettes (many do), it's not good, but hopefully when you feel strong enough you will stop those, too.
As to coffee and sugar -- there's a good reason they serve coffee and candy at AA meetings.
WE ARE NOT SAINTS! It's progress, not perfection.
And besides, aside from spilling scalding coffee on your lap, I've never heard of anyone getting arrested for driving under the influence of coffee -- or ice cream or pie, either!
Glad to see so many wonderful hubbers in the sobriety club.
3/25/04 is my date, and I'm sticking to it! MM
A friend professed to be sober, and he did stop drinking, but still smoked up, and indulged in any number of other self-destructive behaviors. He said he would never go to a meeting under the influence, though. Big deal! All that meant was that he ended up missing a whole lot of meetings.
Nothing to numb me. In short refusal to be numbed. 6 months in I was amazed to discover that my life was still full of really tough consequences from all the years of abuse. I mentioned this to an old timer and I remember his response now 20 years later. "Know what sober means Son?" "Son/Of/A/Bi-ch/Everything's/Real ! hehehe...
I guess I've most recently assumed it means "clean - no drugs or alcohol in someone's system; and "sober" - sober.
When I saw this thread, though, I remembered that when I was a kid I was under the impression "clean and sober" may have related to someone who may have gone out, gotten drunk, come home, and maybe passed out without changing clothes or washing up. So, it seemed to me that "clean and sober" may have started out to mean someone who has taken a shower, changed clothes, and is no longer drunk (from, maybe, a weekend binge, for example). I may be wrong, but I think I used to hear that on tv (maybe the Andy Griffith show, with Otis, who would go on a bender and then show up all fresh, dressed up, and combed - "clean and sober". (Not that anyone is looking for speculation about the possible history and evolution of that phrase. )
For me clean and sober means learning how to live life, because drugs and alcohol are just a symptom of a much deeper issue. In my opinion for a true addict to be clean and sober he or she needs to work a 12 step program daily because drugs and alcohol were only the surface of the problem. You can be off drugs and yet still remain in an unhealthy mindset. So to me clean and sober is more of a state of mind rather than just not using the drug of choice.
by Jennifer Williams 4 years ago
Tell me your thoughts; can recovering alcoholics truly stay sober?
by CindyS 4 years ago
Can You Motivate Someone To Get Clean and Sober Before They Hit "Rock Bottom"?Many people say (and even the AA big book says)that one must hit "rock bottom" before they will get sober. It is said that when one has lost enough or when the pain is great enough, then one can be...
by Amie Butchko 5 years ago
Do you think it is strange for a recovering alcoholic to cook with tequila?One of my friends has recently been battling alcoholism, completed a 28 day rehab program, and has been doing very well. Do you think it is a red flag if this person uses tequila or other alcohols in his recipes? ...
by IDONO 6 years ago
Do you believe that once addicted, always addicted?Whether alcohol, drugs, gambling or any addiction, when you stop the act of your addiction, does that mean you are cured or is it arrested as long as replaced by something else? Please don't confuse obsession with addiction.
by Shwetha Shetty 6 years ago
Which one is more dangerous to health, smoking or drinking (alcohol)?
by jcoop 8 years ago
Is having a child really as life-altering as everyone says it is?
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|