Why do some people use a singular noun when they start a phrase with "one of your . . . "?
They might continue by saying "[one of your] best/worst/favorite/least-favorite/best-loved/most-hated" or something similar. Do you have a grammar theory?
I am not sure I am following you, but let me play with this a moment.
Sentence 1) In one of your best selling articles you said; "Now....".
In sentence 1) the singular noun is not singular but a plural.. Not Article singular but Articles Plural.
You would not say "in one of" (singular) followed by a singular noun... it does not fit.
When speaking or writing you do not call attention to "one of one" and then call that one Plural.
To be one of something implies that there are more than one to be considered.
Likewise Lets look at the reverse
2) In some of your best selling article you said; "Now...."
This also does not fit as having first mentioned some (meaning more than one) the grammar mandates the noun also be plural.
Was I on the right sheet of music???
Here is another example and a good example of why it is important to use the right grammar, and what happens if you do not.
"My wife and I are usually discussing issues like this. She is better at formulating actual Rules that make common sense for these common mistakes people make."
-- She should write a book on it (or them).
If "it" is the subject that is the intention of the book then the Singular is OK.
But if the Mistakes themselves are the subject of the book then the Plural "them" should be used.
Just a little thing like tense could change the meaning of the whole sentence.
Yes, MrMaranatha, you have described well the reason why a singular noun is incorrect in that situation. Yet I do hear people use one incorrectly, and I even see it in writing, as I did here on HP just before posting the Q. I'm curious to know why?
My guess would be that It's just poor grammar.
Definitely poor grammar! I wonder how such a thing comes about. What is it people hear - or don't hear - that makes it sound even remotely reasonable to their ear? As you noted, "one of" indicates that there have to be more. Thanks for answering.
In the case of Foreign Language students this problem could stem from the difference in how the native language handles its own Grammar. Sometimes we see these issues with students, but after they have seen a few good examples it is usually solved.
I believe the singular to be correct in the simplest case. If a mother has a boy and two girls, it is correct to say, "One of your children is a boy." The subject of the sentence is "One" and it is singular, in both grammar and meaning. In the same situation, one would say, "Two of your children are girls."
For another example, I have published nine books, one of them an Amazon best seller. It is correct to say to me "One of your books is an Amazon best seller," and "Eight of your books are not Amazon best sellers."
Can you give an example of a full sentence beginnign "One of your . . ." where the plural is correct?
This may take too much space (sorry). I do not mean the verb is singular. I mean that some people now incorrectly say (to play off your example), "I bought one of your Amazon book," rather than "books" Why? I admit this is not a great example.
People learn grammar unconsciously by vague imitation. If not trained in discipline of standard grammar, we guess at what to do. People hear "one" and guess "singular."Poor education, bad habit, non-standard dialect. Read Twice As Less, Eleanor Orr.
In original learning, Another element in this is that Missing Content must be supplied by the human brain. If a person hears or understands only half the sentence then the brain will supply the missing pieces thus rendering the sentence wrong.
The key is in 'books'. Amazon sells not one but many books, so the phrase has to be therefore: 'One of Amazon's books' (uno de los libros de Amazon)
The fact that I have more than one book/record on sale, or that I have more than one offspring dictates the use of the multiple, -s, even though only one of them has been pointed out (for scrutiny): 'One of your sons is a graduate'/ 'One of your records has become a hit'/'One of your children has fallen into the pond'.
As opposed to: 'A son of yours is a graduate'/'A record of yours is a hit'/'A child of yours has fallen into the pond', in which case the multiple reference has shifted to 'you'. .
Perhaps you mean as opposed to "our?" One of our most famous presidents is FDR?
I'm not entirely sure I understand exactly what you're asking; but based on the examples you've given, I'd think it may be a case of the person's leaving room for the possibility that the other person may not have narrowed down "whatever" to one, particular, favorite and therefore has a number of "favorites" (or "worst" or "best" etc.) Technically, if someone wants to "get all into it", it's not grammatically correct. Sometimes, though, people who are perfectly skilled with grammar and speech will take some liberties in favor of being more casual and friendly in their writing or speech. People who are very secure in their knowledge of grammar often feel very comfortable occasionally temporarily dispensing with what's technically grammatically correct in favor of just being more casual and assuming other people basically know what the writer/speaker means. Anyway... That's my theory.
As someone who is most often incapable of settling on any one "favorite anything" but who most often has a number of things I'd list among my favorites", I don't even really think of "favorite" as a singular thing. Personally, I may have several "favorites", "worsts", "bests", etc. I suppose, as a person, I choose to exercise some "right" to define words like "favorite" on my own terms, rather than just accept, at all times, how a dictionary defines them. Another part of the theory may be that people (especially those who truly "have a relationship with" and love words) sometimes choose to truly take command of words and use them in their own, personalized, way - and not always be "ruled by" dictionaries and grammar text books.
I think it just stems from not being a native English speaker, of which Hubpages attracts a lot, God bless 'em. Saying "one of your foot is blah blah blah" is grammatically incorrect, but non-native speakers may think that a singular noun is required to match the word "one." It's a logical construction from their point of view. It takes more refined English skills to understand the correct phrase is "one of your feet is blah blah blah."
by KMattox 7 years ago
Here is an old grammatical controversy.. Is the word none singular or plural?Does it denote "no one" or is ii a part of many as in none have it better"
by L a d y f a c e 3 months ago
Which one is right? "None were hurt" or "None was hurt" ?The statement was "None were hurt". Someone said that the word "none" is a portmanteau of "no" and "one"; and that since you wouldn't say "no one were hurt", you shouldn't...
by astigpinoy16 7 years ago
Hello guys!I just want to ask something, as you can see on my subject of my topic, I am confused when to put comma after the word "and"? I have read hubs about how to use comma, but some time I see sentences where comma is preceded by the word and.I know how to use comma like: use a comma...
by Nicholas Nelson 5 years ago
Grammatically speaking, should one place two spaces or one following a mark of punctuation?
by Kathleen Odenthal 3 years ago
Is there a difference between good writing and quality writing?I read a lot of hubs that are covering great topics, hitting key points and written in an engaging manner, but they have many grammatical errors. Now, I may be a bit of a grammar and spelling snob, but I feel like those two elements are...
by Katelyn Weel 2 months ago
Do you say "A scissor" or "Scissors"?This is to settle a debate with my bf. If you had one "chopping device" would you call it "a pair of scissors" or "a scissor"? What if you had two?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|