Why are my poetry hubs falling below the quality standards...?
I have received the following email each time I amend or update a hub. Mainly my poetry, photographic and music hubs - 'Your hub ....... falls below HubPages' quality standards and will not be Featured. Your Hub will remain published, but it will not be showcased on Topic Pages or Related Hubs listings. It will also not be made available to search engines.' Surely the quality checker should have different criteria to say 'article writing' - for creative writing hubs such as poetry, novels? I take pride in my work, love to share and read comments and this is really upsetting....WHY?
I find much the same with my work and am perplexed as to why at this late date after more than a year has gone by they have changed the rules. whonu
Hi Leni, I read a few of your poems and enjoyed them. The only thing that struck me was that several have adverts for amazon and ebay. You might do well to remove the ads and replace them with media so they seem less commercial to the bots that auto-check our work.
I read in the Learning Center that creative writing is judged on a different (and more lenient) scale than factual material, but because of its shorter nature it's not good to include more ads beyond what HubPages places there. If you wrote a 1000-word poem, it would be a different story I suppose.
Because they probably want your hub to be around 500-700 words. If you include ebay/amazon, it appears as purely promotional. Hubpages uses an algorithm to determine the quality of hubs; then they leave the community to make the real opinion, hence hub scores. Hope I've helped! HERE'S A GOOD SUGGESTION: After writing each poem, include one text box describing the poem, then a second entailing your inspiration behind it, whether it be something you experienced, heard, saw, etc. This will improve your quality score, and try to ALWAYS use what they recommend in the upper right. I hit every one of these requirements every time (at least 700 word count), the 3 photos, and the 2 capsules. Ask people what they thought in a poll, if you're referring to a location target it on a map, etc etc. Good luck!
Thanks for the advice sounds about right but also sounds like a lot of work on old hubs, some not far off three years old - can't understand why they don't just do it for new hubs. Any way I will give it a try though I know it will take some time...
I wish I knew the answer, but I have no idea. Many of mine are like this, too. I haven't posted a poem in quite some time. I have noticed my book reviews falling to the same thing as well. I have tried updating old hubs by adding a link, picture or video and sometimes more text. I hope this brings them back to life.
Most comments received to this question have been extremely helpful - plus a really helpful tip on one of my poetry hubs with explanation of why it is falling short of the QC's -useful tip - remove ebay & Amazon ads add poll, ad video, own pictur
Three months ago I wrote an article called POETS! -- DEMAND FORMATTING CHANGES FROM HP! I think I contacted staff directly, as well, and requested a response. NOTHING. which leads to the question -- does HP care much, one way or the other, about poetry and poets?....... which leads to the corollary question, does poetry bring in enuff ad revenue for HP to care about discontent among poets? Answers are probably "No" in both cases. All of this angst is a shame, because the potential readership on HP is huge and could be of great promotional value for the resurgence of interest in poetry currently underway, as well as good for individual poets.
I have no idea how poems are scored on HP. I didn't even realize they WERE scored! How dumb is that?
It looks like all hubs are scored but to which level they can score creativity is beyond me. it appears that it is not so much the content of the poems but the stuff that surrounds it. Too many non HB ads and a hub fails the QC *polls & media ne
Hi Leni, I don't have the answer to your question but just wanted to say that I have a lot of poems and all are featured. Also, I do not use videos or polls on my poems, only photos, so I'm assuming that can't be the problem. I also know that you are a good writer, and actually just read a couple of your poems and thought them excellent, with a good introduction. I wonder if it is the Amazon/ebay capsules? Can't think what else it could be.
I, too, have featured poems and they all have something-video, pics, ebay, links-so i don't think those could be issues.
Hi - Thank you I am in the midst of removing the amazon/ebay capusles so we will see. I haven't been very active on the hubs lately as I am caring for my 91 year old father in law who has advanced dementia - so I check out hubpages when I can.
The standards for judging quality on a creative writing hub are different than on informative articles. So long as you properly categorize your poetry hubs (which, from the ones I just viewed, it looks as if you have) then the qualifications will be different. For instance, word count as another hubber mentioned, is not an issue with poetry. If you notice, the 'evergreen' scale that is found to the upper right of the hub tool page when creating a hub (just above the capsule add box) is not even there for poetry hubs. Word count is not a quality issue with poetry.
I have now looked at several of your poems and, aside from being quite good, they are all set up very nicely. You have pictures and links and amazon capsules and you've used subheadings and even videos. And you even grouped a few similar poems together when they would have been sparse on their own.
Poetry and creative writing, however, are a tricky genre to be competitive in, so to speak. At least here on hubpages. A lot of the moderating done here is done by us. We use the hub hopper and we rate and vote up (or down) a hub. All of these things can hurt or help you and the sad truth of the matter is, people aren't always the wisest creatures. I see poetry like yours get lost in the site while junk gets praised and voted up. It isn't fair and it isn't right but, unfortunately, there isn't a lot we can do about it. Just keep trucking right a long and writing because you are doing a great job! I love seeing well written poetry on here
My only other possible explanation could be a traffic issue. I was reading up on the featured status just a minute ago and it says that if a hub goes 'stagnant' it can become unfeatured. It just means your poetry hubs/music/etc may need a traffic boost. Try sharing them on social media and see if that helps. Get your face out in the forums and commenting and you may find more visitors checking things out. I really hope this helps and, guaranteed I will be voting you up!!
PS I noticed several outgoing links to others' hubs in your poem. I would take those out as they could be your issue.
Thank you ** i will treasure your comments & advice and will head over & check out your hubs
I'm a lttle late with this question, but this may help:Hubpages “grades” poetry written by hubbers who largely publish articles differently from those who write creative short story fiction and poetry. I don’t agree with this philosophy; nevertheless, it is what it is. You are a creative writer who publishes many poems. The quality of the poem too often has little to do with whether or not it is featured. I write poetry and short story fiction. Whenever a poem of mine drops from featured to an un-featured status, it receives a half-moon symbol because it "does not receive sufficient engagement." I hope this helps, Lenni.
I don't understand Hubpages "grading" system for poetry--in fact,I just now realized that they actually have the temerity to judge our poetry. Do they Rubbish!
by Sheila Craan 4 weeks ago
Lately, I have had 11 hubs unfeatured due to Quality Issues. I have assured my hubs do not contain grammatical or spelling errors. I have included relevant video and changed the titles and added new supporting texts and all this to no avail. The HubPages Staff continues to deem my hubs do not...
by Clive Williams 3 years ago
Why do poems even though well written have a low hub score?Poems are not really lengthy and most poems carry less than 1250 words. Why don't poems have a different rating than a regular article?
by annasmom 2 years ago
I have some of my poetry up and the scores are consistently in the high fifties to low sixties.....Anyone with an interest in poetry and some spare time, can you look at them? I am a published poet and author, but I am getting the ego knocked out of me here on HP! Is there anyway to...
by Linda Jo Martin 7 years ago
Just wondering! I have a lot of old poems (I no longer write poetry often though I once did). I still write a lot of stories... especially flash fiction.I could put my poems and stories here on HubPages... but my main motivation would be to make money.So tell me... do you make money with your...
by Wesley Meacham 5 years ago
How well do poems and short stories do on HP?I noticed a while back somewhere that HP staff had mentioned that creative writing such as poems and short stories don't do as well as informational pieces. I'm curious to know about the earnings of some of the people who publish a lot of these. Do you...
by Gemini Fox 3 years ago
Published a hub on Oklahoma (please don’t get started on how it might be too generic – I had fun doing it). It became the template for my following hubs on Arizona and New Mexico. The Oklahoma one published just fine. The Arizona and New Mexico ones are now Not Featured due to...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|