Do You Believe The N.R.A. Should Have Any Voice In America?
I've been watching the actions of the NRA which I once belonged to and supported and you know what. I'm not sure they should have any say in America and the politics of gun control. As a retired US Naval Officer and Native American I once supported them but I no longer can. I fear how many more school shootings we will see before school goes out. Maybe its time that we radically changed the gun laws in the USA. We must protect our children. I saw a ambulance headed toward an area Elementary School today and it scared the hell out of me. I would give up my guns to protect the youth of America.
I don't know how much say they have exactly. They represent millions of people who believe in the 2nd amendment and they lobby based on their constituents wishes. Like tons of other groups.
They have the right to lobby and state their opinion as much as the anti-gunners do. Congress can listen or not. But to say they should not be allowed to make their case as fervently as the other side strikes me as being out of tune with the 1st amendment.
I wonder how much the Gun Lobby though is about big money and how much is about the constitution. I'm not sure that all lobbyists shouldn't be outlawed. Why are they necessary. Any lobbyist. Not just gun lobbyists. Maybe we should throw them all out.
I have to agree with you. I wrote a hub on kicking them all out of washington, they certainly do not represent "the people" and their ability to bribe politicians has gone too far.
The NRA should have a voice and should be allowed to speak up just as any association in a democratic country should be allowed. You can't deny anyone the right to voice an opinion.
However as you point out they do seem to have more political clout, a disproportionate amount, and this is due to the power of the dollar, and congressmen fearful of their status. The pro gun lobby is very powerful and has some celebrity behind it which also helps to maintain its image as a positive force for American values.
Sandy Hook however seems to be the final straw. The US must reform its gun laws and I hope Obama succeeds (where other presidents have failed) because how can you not do anything after 20 children are slaughtered?
As a Brit it's very hard for me to relate to the power of the gun in your country but when I see and hear the NRA spokesman I shudder! I don't want to relate at all. He wants teachers to be carrying guns inside school? Am I correct? If so then that's the straight road to madness. Perhaps they need a new spokesperson.
With over 300 million guns, a zealous pro-gun mentality, the NRA, a stubborn congress, Obama's challenge is massive. But a good start would be to get these horrific assault weapons out of the public domain. These things are so powerful, who would want to own/use such a weapon apart from a professional soldier?
As long as there is a 2nd amendment the NRA should have a right to lobby for its validity. They maybe powerful but their power is no more than a judge whos sole power is to decipher the law and apply just decisions in disputes. Society as a whole should reexamine the moral implications of protecting the 2nd amendment as it stands now and make appropriate changes according to the health of the republic.
No organization should have the power to influence governmental decisions. The NRA is no different than the religions, and any other corporation that influence our politics.
What is wrong with their lobbying is the influence they "buy" from politicians who have no understanding of what they are defending, and who don't even care, as long as they are paid large sums of money to be someone's mouthpiece in Washington.
It has never been about what is right, or what is wrong, but rather, the influences by any single enterprise is all about money, power and greed. What happens to civilians in that process is simply collateral damage in that quest for the almighty dollar. It was also a shame that the original motto of our government was misspelled and ended up: "in God we trust", instead of "in Gold we trust".
Yes, They should. When they had the incident in Waco Texas, it was said that children were being abused. It turns out that what those people were really trying to do was break away from an oppressive system. Remember what happen. Children are scarified when someone is attempting to pull a con job on the public. I feel sad of the parents who lost there children. But there is not enough legislation on the mentally Ill were the problem seem to lie. In Newton, the young man killed his mother first. I wonder what happen when a person can murder the person who delivered you into the world. I own two nine millimeters and I have never shot one outside of the firing range.
The NRA as a group should not have a say in any political policies/laws.
I believe that people have a right to have a gun. Not an assault weapon made for the purpose of killing anyone!!! I also believe every person should have a background check and any history of mental illiness in the home that person should be denied a permit and the application for a permit from any person who is mentally ill should be reported and the person should be forced to get treatment.
This fight to get gun laws passed is really good for the NRA's pocket book...
That is what they care about and all they care about.
I once was given a gun permit application and TOLD to mail it. I had in my possession a piece of paper as to this person's mental state and I enclosed a copy with the request. Permit denied!
"I believe that people have a right to have a gun. Not an assault weapon made for the purpose of killing anyone!!! "
So, ummmm, are you less dead if I shoot you with a handgun? What, exactly, do you think guns are for??
The government cannot protect us from random acts of violence.
And the government would be protecting our children more by going after the drug cartels and gangs that sell illegal drugs to the children, use children for prostitution, and human trafficking.
There are over 33,000 known gangs in the US with over 1.4 million gang members, They use guns to protect their illegal businesses.
Thomas, your question is so very irrational. I'm not saying this to be mean.
"Should the NRA have a voice in America?" They have as much right to a "voice" as any other group, whether you agree with them or not.
"Giving up our guns" would not prevent school shootings, sorry to inform you. We can't let tragedies cloud our judgment out of fear.
It's pretty much a given that those who are anti-firearms are also all-in for being anti-1st Amendment and all the other various freedoms and liberties we enjoy as Americans. This Hub Question is all the proof we need to know that for sure.
by Susan Holland 4 years ago
Do you believe the horrific school shootings are being used as an excuse for gun control?Are there other factors that should be focused on to help prevent other tragedies? Parenting? Discipline? Positive and negative reinforcement? Mental health care? Is it the guns or the people that...
by Mr. Happy 5 years ago
A question for people who are against gun control: does the fact that 'the founding fathers" wrotethat the 2nd amendment shall not be infringed lead them to believe that gun laws will never change? With this kind of thinking, should Italy return to Roman laws and should Egypt re-enact the laws...
by Warren Samu 5 years ago
Is the 2nd Amendment to the US Constitution obsolete?Should it be repealed or a new version more applicable to modern realities be ratified?
by Victoria Van Ness 5 years ago
"With unemployment down and the housing market showing some good numbers. The second part of the health care bill taking effect and with spending up. The country is slowly moving in the right direction." -from another Hub (unnamed)I don't agree. Unemployment is actually higher now than it...
by flacoinohio 5 years ago
Do you believe modifying the Second Amendment is going to prevent mass acts of violence?This questions is for all of those situational or sunny day anti-gun advocates. Pro-gun advocates spend a lot of time and effort, not mention millions of dollars protecting the Second Amendment. If...
by WTucker 9 years ago
What does the second amendment mean to you? Please include historical precedence and logical deduction for your meaning. I would discourage what you wish the gun policy would be for the US but rather what you feel the amendment actually means.A well regulated militia being necessary to...
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|