Thousands rally at Illinois Capitol — for a tax raise
Thousands of teachers and other union workers descended on the state Capitol on Wednesday and chanted "raise my taxes" to try to pressure politicians to avoid major budget cuts.
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2010 … income-tax
This is like fleas and ticks protesting me that I need to feed my dog more.
I agree with them! The legislature should raise the taxes of those who desire it and leave the rest of us alone!
And that you need to feed it more by having you eat less.
There's no way in hell I'd be able to afford a private teacher for my kids that could provide the same service as public education. I get a fantastic value for what i pay in taxes and I'm very happy with it, thank you.
Do you take any deductions when you file your taxes? Why?
Do you accept a refund from the IRS if you have one coming? Why?
You could probably volunteer to pay more taxes if you are so inclined.
Those questions are irrelevant to my point Arthur. Even if I gave up my entire salary in taxes, I wouldn't be able to afford a full time teacher for my kids - plus all the other public services I take advantage of: public libraries, public transportation, interstate highways, fire departments, police, public defenders (not that I've ever needed one but I'm glad there is such a thing) etc. etc.
While you might have some legitimate complaints about the quality of public education, the reality is that no private entity could do as much for us as cheaply as the government does.
I would bet that most if not all of those union protesters are better off then the average citizen in Illinois.
Should every American need to make a sacrifice so union thugs can maintain their lifestyle?
Teachers are union thugs? LOL!
I've already stated that I'm happy to pay taxes so that teachers (and firefighters, and policemen, and soldiers) are paid well for what they do. You pay peanuts, you get monkeys. I don't want monkeys teaching my kids and protecting my neighborhood - I want highly qualified and educated people to do it.
The government is in the best position to provide these services at the lowest cost to the majority.
If you disagree, why don't all you libertarians go and start a laissez faire state where you pay a private entity for every single service you use.
Come back and tell me how it works out.
"I've already stated that I'm happy to pay taxes so that teachers (and firefighters, and policemen, and soldiers) are paid well for what they do."
This coming from the guy who wants to cut defense spending, the military salutes you!
Wanting to cut the military budget is not the same as wanting to see soldiers get paid less or go without body armor.
It's just like a business: don't spend your money on stupid things.
Not the teachers I worded that wrong. I am talking about the people who leach off the backs of the teachers. The Union Thugs.
As I stated earlier the in the thread I worded that wrong the thugs are not the teachers they would be the UNION thugs.
You know the guys who do nothing but leach off of the backs of their members.
You seem to know as little about teaching - as you do about unions.
My father taught HS electronincs for 20 years. I belong to a union. So I am qualiried to say a little about both. Teachers work incredibly hard - can any parent with 2 or 3 at home imagine supervising more than a dozen - and get constructive teaching done? And the work the students do is reviewd and corrected and graded outside the regular school day.
Unions ARE the memebers. There are no external 'thugs'. We elect our reps in my association ALWAYS from the working ranks. I have plenty of criticism when they screw up, but I have no one to blame but myself because I elected them - I can call and write and be involved - the union is ME!
At times they are to the children. You will learn what I teach!
I assume you agree that the teachers are exercising their right to free speech the same as the Tea Partiers?
It strikes me as an oversimplification to blame only the teachers and school board bureaucracy for the problems in urban schools. There are many reasons for high dropout rates and low achievement in reading, writing, math and other basics. Even the very best and most highly motivated teachers have a hard time achieving results in an environment characterized by unemployment, impoverished, single-parent families, drugs and crime. The inner cities are suffering a breakdown in many respects of which public education is only one.
I don't think you need a private teacher to give you the service that the public school system provides, you can probably hire any crack head in your city to provide the same service for a couple of rocks a day.
What crazy world are you living in? Kids today can't hold a candle to graduates a decade ago, much less those of us who graduated further back than that.
http://literaryculture.suite101.com/art … ding_rates
I'd like to make this point specifically:
It's really scary when you have adults who have been through graduate school and they're posting a 20% decline in reading proficiency. So much for public education.
I'm not talking about the quality of public education as much as I'm talking about the overall value of what we get for our tax dollars. I agree that public education is going downhill in many ways (although the metrics can be a little misleading).
I actually have a few problems with the whole theory of public education in general and the fact that it is simply indoctrination into the industrialized herd/worker mentality.
If I had my way I'd homeschool my kids or hire a private tutor. But, as I've pointed out, there's no way I could afford that.
So I take what I can get. I can do what my parents did, and fill in the gaps for my kids, teach them the things they won't learn in public school.
Will, you really need to read up on economics. Classical economics not that Keynesian nonsense. Most people would rather homeschool or tutor their kids but they can't. Why? Because having a "free" public option in education means that normal economic forces are not allowed to work. In a normal market, prices tend to fall over time. One of the things that keeps prices from falling is a subsidy. Public education is a subsidy of the educational market.
That's one of the reasons why while we spend more per student we're getting less and less quality. Google "Theory of Bureaucratic Displacement" and Dr. Max Gammon. I'm curious to know if you really know what your kids are being taught in school and if you need to "fill in the gaps" or re-educate your kids entirely.
Jeez, its like Fahrenheit 451.
The only way that can be fixed is by having kids stop spending so much time on the TV and video games, which requires responsible parents with the time to actually be there to take care of their kids, which in turn requires the parents to not have to both work long hours to be able to live well, which requires a good economy which is helped by having well educated adults going into the work force and getting good paying jobs and contributing to the entire system, which requires that those children to get a good education and good job by going to college and getting a degree, but to go to college these children need to do well in school and have parents that have the money and time to help them get their. It seems to be an endless cycle.
Looking back at this it seems to be a jumbled mess, I hope you can understand what I'm trying to say.
The solution is rather simple. It takes parents being that parent. In the end we pay these people, they should be offering us a service second to none. If they can't do that, then we should have the freedom to choose what's best for ourselves.
I'm sorry, but can you clarify that a little? What do you mean, "It takes parents being that parent"?
Being the parent that speaks up at PTA meetings and school board meetings. Far too often people let this stuff happen on autopilot. Perhaps that is to be expected as parents are hard at work providing for their families, but it's difficult to keep groups like school boards focused on the work they are supposed to be doing and less on the ivory tower nonsense that is creating a situation in which our future is less educated than our past.
I love it. But they are better at computer games, we didn't have them.
Try paying two care-givers, and helping to support family. That's just for starters. If my taxes go up it hurts many.
I agree somewhat with William. I don't really have a big problem with paying taxes for services. What I hate is paying taxes that go for stupid grants like studying the sexual habits of South American tree frogs!
We all can agree with that, but the big budget items are two wars, Medicare due to skyrocketing health care costs and the huge ongoing military budget which continues to rise, thanks to the military-industrial complex, even though the Cold War ended 20 years ago. Corruption is also a significant factor in some urban school districts. A financial administrator appointed for the Detroit public schools has exposed outright theft and waste of millions of dollars by corrupt school administration officials.
http://kiplinger.com/infographics/balan … t/map.html
19% of the government's budget is spent on the military.
Healthcare is 23%.
Pensions are 22%
Discretionary spending - which includes education - is only 16%.
If we could successfully cut major costs, or even just minor cuts, out of defense, healthcare, or pensions we could provide much more money to public education.
I just want to add that education is only a very small part of that 16%. Discretionary spending includes the space program, national parks, environmental protection, disaster relief, homeland security, medical research, foreign aid, etc. etc. etc.
Otherwise, right on.
I'm in shock, DETROIT! That city is almost 100% Democratic, it must be a mistake.
Gee... people who suck money from the public via Government Jobs want to raise taxes so their jobs are secure, but people who don't suck money from Government Jobs get to foot the bill.
That makes sense. 50% of the public now relies on Government for most of their income. By 2020 it's projected to be 66%.
America is being destroyed by Government. In the not to distant future it's not inconceivable that the private sector will disappear all together. Complete collapse of the country.
The Government can not produce anything but despair and destruction.
None of the pro government people really want to work... they just want handouts and expect other people to pay their way.
That system doesn't work... and results in extreme poverty.
As noted there is nothing stopping these Government Employees from taking voluntary pay cuts or donating a larger portion of their income to the Government. All they have to do is write the check and Uncle Sam will cash it.
And the media always picks up on anything to do with Teachers and Schools... because that's the easiest way to control the population. Always use children as hostages to try and get their way. What a load of crap.
There are thousands of cuts that can be made before education.
"None of the pro government people really want to work... they just want handouts and expect other people to pay their way."
Are you including me in this ridiculous blanket statement?
Don't you get it, they want to destroy America. Then everyone will depend on gov't (them) for any and everything.maybe they will have us become a colony for another country.
I don't know if I'd go as far as to call teachers ticks on the dog. District administrators and union reps, sure, a frighteningly large number of them are. But I know a crap ton of teachers and they are good, hard-working people stuck in overflowing classrooms following ever-changing and increasingly moronic guidelines that grow more and more distant from anything resembling effective pedagogy as each school year goes by.
There's so much social programming and crap going on now, so much politics, nobody above the classroom cares about the 3 Rs, and the teachers don't have time to teach those because they're too busy meeting arbitrary requirements that are being administered by the large bureaucratic mass hovering politically above them. The money goes to feeding that fat mass and developing new programs and enforcing them. It costs very little to teach math, reading and writing. PE is cheap too, a soccer ball and four orange cones will get it done. Get those little fat f-ers outside and make them run and stop testing their fitness levels every two weeks to appease the statisticians on the payroll trying to justify their jobs.
I'm a retired teacher, and you're exactly right! Every year, we had less time to actually TEACH because we were bogged down in red tape. Now we have to teach the kids values and we have to make sure they feel good about themselves. My question was always, "Whose values do we teach? How do we decide?"
And BTW, there are no teacher unions around here.
By your logic, I am older than you so I'm better educated, so you'd better accept that I know better than you do and not argue with me over politics
Not really, you weren't educated in a US public school. Be thankful. I know you think you know better than I do, but not really. Still the great debate goes on and on and on....
I think we can all agree this is a tough economy right now. There are many people who would be happy with any employment.
Then there are people who have pension plans and paid health care, vacations, sick days, personal days, etc. etc. etc.
All paid for with tax dollars. Then to have the audacity to ask those that have their heads above water to sacrifice more of their income to sustain a spoiled aristocracy of government workers.
When you see a guy treading water do you throw him a floatation device or an anchor?
Once again thank you for exposing your superior attitude to your fellow Americans!
The good news, if you can call it that, is that the public education system is unsustainable. The fact that these protests are occurring is the first signs that they system is cracking up. It's funny how many times the "public option" in any field of endeavor tends to not only be worse than the "private option" but is almost always unsustainable.
Harvey, the only quibble I have with your characterization of Detroit is the use of the word Democratic. Truth be told the city has been in decline, like many in the US, due to Progressive policies. Remember Republicans can be Progressives too, just ask W and John McCain, or Arlen Specter for that matter.
Funny thing is that we probably would have been staunch Democrats in the years after the Civil War. At least until William Jennings Bryan came to power and shifted the Democratic Party to a more Progressive stance in the 1890's. Come to think of it, that's about the time we stopped having the Hamiltonian vs Jeffersonian discussions and started debated on which form of Hamiltonian centralization we should use.
A better examle of a Republican Progressive would have been Teddy Roosevelt.
I couldn't say Progressives in Detroit because the voters would not have understood. I truly did not understand what a Progressive is, until Obama was elected. They voted blindly for Democrat's.
Teachers have it so bad. A friend of mine taught H.S. and had an ending salary of $125,000. His miserable pension is only 80%.
by dragonrider32 8 years ago
1. There is no way on earth that all the kids in public schools now could be placed in private schools/homes. There are no where near enough places for them. If you don't provide for all of them...what are you setting the American future up for? Disaster.2. Private schools have waiting lists. If a...
by Georgiakevin 9 years ago
When "No Child Will Be Left behind " began I was invited to several meetings. The main speakers said that education should be like private industry. It was also said that Japan & Germany were leaving us far behind. We were told that educators focus should be on getting all children in...
by preacherdon 7 years ago
With the entertainment and sport industries making multimillions of dollars each year and the education industry losing funding and shutting down programs and laying off teachers, should the education of our children be privatized? City budgets are no longer able to provide adequate funding for...
by stunnercold 7 years ago
Is the public education system in the US really broken?Given that we're going broke, I suppose its going to get tougher to maintain standards.
by Krystal 6 years ago
If you could change 3-5 things about America's public education system, what would they be and why?
by Mohan Kumar 6 years ago
Isn't teaching for excellence better than teaching for competence?Is the target driven culture and the quest for getting everyone to pass assessments pushing teachers to teach just for competence? Is their enough passion to teach excellence?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|