Should schools teach one religion, or all religion, or no religion at all?
I think they should teach people about different religions, but allow children to make their own mind up which religion to follow.
I think religious studies should be part of every middle school and high school curriculum. Most people are believers, and being familiar with the major religions of the world is part of what it means to be an educated person.
But it violates church and state.
In a religious school it's okay.
Not in public school when you can't even have a Christmas Tree.
Lor since when does teaching the subject of religion violate the separation of church and state. In a multicultural world children need to get a comprehension of other ethnic groups and beliefs otherwise they'll grow up in ignorant bigotry.
You can not teach religion in a public school
How old are you.
Public school public funding.
There is a separation of church doctrine nd teaching it in a public school.
I went to catholic school. I suggest you check the constitution .
Amber Vyn, you are correct in your discussion. It is very important that education of the major religions should be provided to the students as a part of history. Separation of church and state does not apply to history studies.
Lor, you are confusing school prayer and the Church evangelical teaching of Christianity with the factual, historical comparitive teaching of religion designed to engender kids with an understanding of the world.
In no way shape or form should ANY religion be taught in any school that teaches children. The subject is infinitely complex, totally un-provable and eventually leads to wars between opposing beliefs.
I completely agree. I don't feel it is the schools job to teach religion, that is the family's job and the church's job.
Here in the USA schools can barely manage to teach the basics well. They sure shouldn't be teaching an opinion based subject. If religion started being taught in school I would pull my children out and homeschool. There are thousands of Gods. They don't have time to teach all of them. So they should be teaching about none of them.
But shouldn't children be taught about history, and their culture? Whether or not you think it is a good thing, religion has played a major part in historical events, and an important cultural reference.
Do you think they should only be taught American history? You're right religion has played a major role in almost every country. Shall we teach the children how many lives have been claimed by religions as well? Afterall it is history.
No of course I don't think they should only be taught American history, and yes I think children should learn about wars etc caused by religion (I'm not American by the way)
The problem is they don't have the time nor training to teach about thousands of religions. Could you imagie having to pick and choose which religious topics should be taught? Just leave them out of schools, in my opinion.
It simply is not possible to convey a true sense of history devoid of the role that religion has played in our past and present.
It would be equally foolish to simply passively mention the fact that religion has played a role across several civilizations and time periods without providing some context to the issue.
Although it would be wrong for a secular public school to ever advocate for a specific religion or particular social movement; it would also be wrong not to present the impact that religion has had on our historical past and our present.
To provide that contextual basis for analysis and thought is not an attempt to indoctrinate a child into a specific ideology. It is merely a way to expand their own sphere of focus and analysis. It helps to extend the understanding that they have of their world.
I would have no problem with religion being presented in that fashion. Presented any other way, either by being actively hostile against religion or openly promoting it, would be troublesome.
This opinion is entirely focused on secular public schools. Obviously, private religious institutions have every right to apply an ideologically biased point of view in their curriculum.
I think there should be a course that explains the top five or seven religions most believed in the world. Let the children know what their parents believe and those around them. The problem would be reducing bias.
I took a world religions class in high school and I loved it. So, I think it's a valid field of study. However, I am thinking of it in terms of historical mythology, not the actual belief in, or practice of, any specific religion. But its very difficult to teach modern religions as mythology because so many people would get offended. Until we can be mature about the subject, it probably shouldn't be there at all.
There are some really diverse answers here, and strong opinions. I feel that if religion is taught in schools, it should be done so objectively, without bias to any one particular religion. There is a lot to learn about politics in the history of religion, and the past has had such a great impact on the present it is impossible to ignore it. Children need to be taught to respect each other regardless of their differences, religious or otherwise.
Thank you for sharing your feelings on this issue.
In my idea, it is good to teach them only one religion which is base of all religions and that is love and humanity. we should teach them that base of all religions wants to tell us to be good only, by good and positive thinking, good and positive talking, good and positive hearing. it means just to be a good human being and respect all religions. that is why we are here and after all, God is the only one. the creator of all the universe which has connected everything in this universe.
Have a good day!
I think schools should teach about different religions and their teachings which are basically same. But they should not taught them that this religion is good and this is better. They should taught them about religions but along with a teaching that do not follow one strictly. Follow your religion and respect others religion.
I think they ought to teach tolerance.
Can we really practice what we are taught if we are ignorant.
I don't care about any ones religion as long as they don't push it to the point where there is a fight in class.
You may not agree,
But if our kids aren't taught about all religions, then there will be a biased approach to anything out side what they get from home.
Comparative religion was the best class I took in college.
And there were arguments but I just kind of sat in the back and listened,
Why do you think we are in the wars we are in now! Radical Religious sects.
Even that needs to be taught though I am not sure how.
Religion though is only taught in Religious schools.
You can't teach religion in a public school.
Religions should be taught to students in public schools as an academic subject. They have been too crucial a part of the human experience to ignore. No particular religion, however, should be taught as the truth. Students can decide for themselves which, if any, they accept.
Private schools, of course, are a different matter. If parents want to spend their money on classes that teach their kids a particular religious belief as truth, then I guess that they have that right. But if these schools want their degrees to be taken seriously by colleges or employers, then they need to fulfill the academic guidelines for other subjects, and that includes science.
Scottish schools teach religious studies where they look at the basics of religion and history.
I believe that only with education of all types of religion can an individual choose what direction to take. After all that is why schools provide lessons in a number of subjects, to enable the students to choose their career path.
One religion does not fit all; if it did there would be only one.
I don't really know of any schools that teach one religion except for private schools such as Catholic School. But it is popular in history-such as the Roman Crusade. So if it is something like that that would be fine. My daughter is taking a sociology course in college and she is learning about different cultures such as the Mormons and Amish. But to have a course on religion in a public High School only no.
by Mark 9 years ago
This is probably going to be a very touchy subject, but I am curious to see the responses. There are many who want the creation story and God taught in school. I am curious, why does this need to be taught in academia? Are these topics not covered in Church or Sunday School anymore? Besides, who...
by TheBlondie 10 years ago
Religious people often think the teaching of evolution should be banned, and vice-versa for non-religious people. What id your opinion? Should evolution, creationism, or neither be taught? Why?
by orlansison 7 years ago
Is it right to debate with a priest to stand up for your faith and relationship to the Lord?I am a teacher, a Baptist in religious affiliation. And I was hired in a sectarian private school which is a Catholic school. Because I was not asked a direct question of what my religion is I did not bother...
by Beata Stasak 9 years ago
How do you think we should teach history to prevent more killing in the future?Memory alone does not prevent more killing. Getting the numbers right is not enough. History is not enough, but it is all we have. Let us be aware that historians have barely begun to understand the events of the past...
by Dan Reed 7 years ago
What if you could have chosen your religion?Most people are told what they will believe from birth. What would happen if children were taught various religions and arguments against then allowed to chose for themselves once they have had a bit of life experience.
by crankalicious 9 years ago
Is religion taught from birth a form of brainwashing?If you teach a child from birth a particular religion, is this not brainwashing? Would that child discover that religion on their own if it's something they weren't taught?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|