Martial arts took me in many directions, during my life time. That of a brash young man, with no self control. One in which I believed martial arts were only about self defense and fighting and one in which I believed was about defending the weak. While it is good to defend the defenseless, violence is never the solution.
It took many years for me to finally realize what martial arts were about. Temperance, stillness and remorse, to name a few. I believe the role of a true master is to guide One's pupils to a working synthesis, within themselve's and with world at large. Life is a thorny path and it has many crossroads, the path choose affects who we become and yet can destroy we are. I like painting and what not, bevause that is who I am. A fighter is a fighter and will never find peace, at least not until they through down the armor of dellusion.
To find stilness from within is tricky, to find it from outside one's self, is impossible. To be humble is a virtue, to be violent is nature. We struggle with this nature and swim against the tide. We fight who we are, yet we think we know ourselve's. To truly master one's own mind, is like fighting a bull.
Remorse? Can you expand on that please?
I am also not sure what you mean by violent is nature?
We are a war like species... Simple but true. No?
No, we are a compassionate and altruistic species. Religions have stomped that into the ground in order to control us, claiming we are sinful, evil and as you say, war like.
I think with the billions of individuals out there it is impossible to pigeon hole people into one classification. There are those who are war like and there are those who want no confrontation combined with a whole bunch of people in between. And while yes I agree that religion has been a tool for many people to control and manipulate others it is the people who have used it for their own selfish reasons that have done the damage. If it wasn't religion, they would have just used some political propaganda.
No, humans are not homogenous. I don't know why you keep using generalizations to define people.
For you perhaps that is true. For many others No
It has always been my understanding that martial arts physical training was for totally defensive purposes to defend one's self, one's property or others who are weak and defenceless. phsycologically, it teaches self-control, provides balance and inner peace and a connection to one's inner self.
Although martial arts teaches techniques to quickly instantaneously kill, this is not what it is meant for or about.
It is my understanding that before the refinement of martial theory and what not, land changed hands more so than today. In todays world a martial artist may use their teachings for glory or self defense. It is also a form of meditation meant to center the individual. For martial arts are about the opposite of violence.
Humans ARE a war-like species. No doubt about it. I'm not sure what planet the rest of you are on.
Are you war like? How about your neighbors or friends and family. Who do you know that is war like?
C'mon all you believers, tell us who exactly you know that is war like? Anyone?
Sure I am. If someone was going to hurt my family or take my possesions, I would knock them on thier a**. Wouldn't you?
Sorry, but that has nothing to do with being war like. You are simply defending yourself.
Does that happen all the time, btw... someone hurting your family and taking your possessions? Does it happen so often to you that you now consider humans war like?
Ok. Humans aren't warlike. You are correct.
This has been proven repeatedly throughout the history of mankind.
The wars of history are based on very bad ideologies and not human traits of compassion and altruism. Bad ideologies making good people do bad things.
It's human nature to be competitive, which leads to being war-like.
I agree that it's also human nature to be altruistic. But the people in power are more often than not jerk-faces,and most people are followers. So there you have it.
Not true. One has nothing to do with the other.
Being a jerk in power and being war like are two different things.
We're at war now, are we not? History can attest to the violence of men. Suppose I were to mention the christian Crusaides and Islam's war on the infidels. How can one say we are not war like? we are after all, on occasion prone to violence and then some.
Notice you said "Christian Crusades and Islams war on infidels"
Bad ideologies making good people do bad things.
That would be assuming genetics is a given and that we belong to the evolution of that particular DNA strand? Perhaps survival of the fittest eliminated the war gene in most of its newer hosts. Most human beings in my view are far from warlike.
I can only speak from my own experience of Martial arts. I am a muay thai enthusiast and have trained in Thailand twice but have also cross trained a little bit in other martial arts which exposed me to Bruce Lee and his own system and philosophy for martial arts,Jeet Kune Do.For me personally martial arts have only been a positive thing in my life and have also taught me a few things about myself too and helped me too confront a few inner fears.
Bruce Lee did study philosophy at University and applied philosophy (seeking the truth)to traditional martial arts looking to strip them down to their essence,I think the same can be applied to religion too and most things in life. Truth is what matters most to me and the truth can often set you free although it can often be painful as well.
The truth and essence of Human nature has yet to be fully revealed I personally believe as people are kind and altruistic but are also capable of inflicting terrible atrocities and violence if beliefs, opinions and values differ to others.
Very true, and also, is it not the seeker that creates truth through action? To see things and leave them as they are, is trapping one's self to the past. Men's propensity towards violence, which does not pertain to all men, is the result of historical conditioning. Example; My grandfather was a fighter, so therefor, I shall do the same.
It could also be said that the student, is very much the image of his teacher. A good teacher, teaches his student in both, non violence and the knowledge of when violence is acceptable. For myself, it must be justifiable to inflict harm on another. I prefer to say that it must be alright with God first, or whatever you should choose to call it.
Perhaps if we let go of beliefs, opinions and values, or at least question them we might just find more of what is true.
I know of no two people who have the exact same beliefs.
by ronin1 12 years ago
Would anyone like to ask questions of martial arts, self defense or self defense products?I would like to ask people to contact me at email@example.com with any questions pertaining to martial arts, self defense or self defense products and I'll be happy to write an article at...
by Alem Belton 9 years ago
What would happen if you killed someone who knew Martial Arts?I just had a thought. If you were fighting someone who knows Martial Arts would you attempt to kill them if you had the chance? And if so do you think you would be found innocent by self defense? Think about it for a...
by Olly 8 years ago
What has been your favourite Martial Arts film you've ever seen?There have been so many great ones over the past 30-40 years and wanted to see what the community thinks their favourite one is. Who knows, it may help us all discover new ones to see. To start the ball rolling mine would be Drunken...
by PhoenixV 9 years ago
What Are The Best Types Of Self Defense To Learn?What is the best type of Self Defense to study?
by Amber Korn 13 years ago
I have been in Martial Arts most of my life, I have trained in several diffrent syles. Recently I was asked to go to the abused women shelter to train women in self-defense. I was actually appalled at the situation I was walking into. The person that had previously been...
by Marlene Bertrand 5 years ago
Are martial arts too spiritual for Christians to participate?Recently, I asked a question about yoga being anti-Christian and the answers were interesting. So, I started wondering if people used the same thought process when analyzing martial arts, which has origins associated with Hindu-Buddhist...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|