I was over there on Bubblews playing around, which I hardly ever do anymore, and when I, strangely, tried to navigate to Arvind's page, I couldn't. I went to my bookmarks and clicked on Bubblews and got a message that the site has shut down. Simply, it stated, they couldn't sustain the site because of changing trends in ad served sites, or something along those lines. You probably can see the message if you try to go there.
In it's early phases, a writer could earn a good deal of money there. As many realized, they couldn't sustain the site because you can't pay people what they were paying early on (the money just wasn't there to give) and, evidently, even when they lowered the pay they didn't make enough money. Many realized this would happen, but I had some fun there for a couple years. This last year there was nothing but trickles of income and not much participation on the site and I'd mostly given up but popped in once in awhile.
Not only is the site shut down without notice, but posts are now inaccessible. You get a 404 if you try to access one of your articles. I'm sure there are many writers with material on the site that they never backed up, and now can never recover. IMO, Bubblews was classless to the very end.
So, it got shut down finally. I am a member there, but not active. I posted some 50 posts and then stopped visiting it. The site seems full of personal gossip posting daily routine activities. Nothing else. So, I lost interest in the site. There was 5 dollars in my account. It is good that they closed.
Thanks NateB11 . . . though I used only because I may of wanted to write something short not QAP quality I had a friend network . . . though used hardly this past year or so. I will spread the word at FB to them
Bubblews did have value as a friend network - a more interesting alternative to Facebook where you could exchange opinions and life stories. That's what I used it for after the bubble burst and the money stopped. I hadn't been there for ages though.
The annoying thing for me was that I was very close to the $50 threshold, but it had been stalled at that level for months so it's unlikely I would ever have made payout.
Agreed, payouts were always a big complaint. The bubble burst somewhat quickly for me and those I know at FB. Most are former hubbers some with some activity here. The majority sought blogs in the wave of departure nearer when the ZzZ was introduced.
No problem, Tim. Yeah, there was a good social aspect to the site and was a good platform for rants and short posts for just expressing whatever you wanted.
It was fun in those good times Nate. The most money I have earned anywhere on the internet - that's for sure.
I know what you mean, Mark. Those early times were a lot of fun.
It's interesting, at the time I actually made a payout regularly there, I really needed the money. The timing was amazing.
I was just in Paypal adding up my Bubblews cash outs and I made near to $2,000 between 2011-2013.
I made a nice amount of money there in the beginning. I never wrote anything long or serious, and it was kind of relaxing, just to write little, mindless blurbs. I guess we knew it couldn't last, but it was fun while it did.
Hi, Jean. I know what you mean. I was always relaxed on that site, I never wrote anything too serious either, mainly joked around or vented, sometimes topical. My account was the closest to a personal blog as I've ever gotten. It was fun, the pay was good at one time and, like you said, we knew it wouldn't last.
This does not surprise me at all. For the last couple of weeks that I wasted my time over there, I was lucky to be able to log on more than three times a week. The site was always down. Standby for a flood of refugees from Bubblews with low to no quality blog type Hubs signing up.
Many of us had a strong feeling that it was a matter of time. Made a bit of money while the going was good, until they cunningly 'blacked' a good number of us out for stupid reasons.
Good thing I had backed up my content on Bubblews. I can always expand on many of them and post them on my blogs.
So, I say good riddance to bad rubbish!
That's a good question. I suspect many of them were never indexed in the first place though!
I made a big fat hairy deal $28.56 from Bubblews (this was when their payout threshold was only $25).... and I had to jump thru so many friggin hoops to get that $28.56 that once it hit my PayPal I said "F*** that site. I'm out!" ... I deleted all of my posts a short time later. So I guess you could say I saw the iceberg coming and jumped off that Titanic early.
I am also surprised that the site lasted this long. Checked the site on Semrush and it appears it was on the rise in rankings -
Bet anyone can rank for those keywords
The main site may be gone but somebody must still be watching Bubblews' Facebook page... Last night I commented there that it was "a total dick move" to shut the site down with no warning and take everyone's posts with it... My comment was deleted just a few minutes later.
I guess the silver lining is the people met there. You really could get to know them.
I wrote all my posts in Word, and kept the images in a dedicated folder, so eventually all that material will be fodder for other outlets.
Live and learn. It was fun in the early days.
I'm not surprised as I read the rumblings over the last few days. However my big complaint is that
(a) my bank account stood at $46.95 for several months, no matter what I did - just short of the $50 payout. I abandoned it for about six months, but recently returned in an all-out effort to reach the payout level. I don't like being taken for a ride.
(b) I would have liked to have been given an opportunity to back up some of my posts, like Squidoo's warning. Do any of you think it will ever be possible to get Arvind to facilitate us doing a swift back-up? I mean, would the whole site have been deleted, or merely held in limbo and still be acccessible by anyone in authority to release our work to us?
A lot of the posts on Bubblews were quite short, I don't think it was ever meant to be a "writer's site" per se. I have a feeling we may never see our posts again. I never wrote anything serious on there, so it doesn't matter to me.
I do understand how frustrating it is when your work is caught in limbo. I had written pieces on Infobarrel that took me months to have taken down, so I could move them to other places. They ignored me until someone from there wrote me a snarky message on my Google + A/C, and said I was giving IB a bad name. I gave them many chances to answer me or allow me to delete the pieces I wanted back. Finally they deleted my A/C, and I back up any serious things I write. They seem to be trying to bring Infobarrel back now, I've had a few emails in the last few days.
It's important to read all the rules and question them before you write on any site. Many of them own your writing once you publish it there. Best Wishes.
I agree with you about Bubblews. I never wrote anything serious there, it was definitely not a writers site; it was a social site. Probably a month ago I could tell the site would soon shut down and so I copied a poem I wrote on there that I liked-- and that I intend to move to one of my blogs (for fun, I know poems don't make money)-- and I pasted the poem to notepad.
I don't think anyone will see their posts from Bubblews again. Not saying that that's fair, just saying it's probably the case.
I wonder how many "what I ate for breakfast" posts have been lost to the ages.....
Haha! Yeah, and how many "good mornings" and "good nights" and an assortment of cliches all sounding much like every other post on the site. No doubt.
I'm guilty of more than a few "good morning" posts on bubblews... It's funny how those got more responses than when I would write something more "thoughtful" like a movie review or my bubbles about my hometown.
And there were always so many posts like, "I got up this morning, and wanted to write ten Bubbles. Then I went back to sleep." I did make the $50 payout a few times, but it was taking longer, and seemed as though groups of people made pacts to "like" each other's Bubbles, no matter how stupid. I left with almost $40.00 there, but couldn't stand it anymore.
by Teresa Schultz 6 years ago
Do you think HubPages would warn us in advance if they shut the site down?I suspect that, sometimes at least, many of us write directly onto the page at HubPages, without having first written offline and saving written work to our own pc. This question is also a warning to hubbers to do just that -...
by Will Apse 5 years ago
It is hard to see that Bubblews threads have a place in the Hubpages section of the forums.Could another place be found for them?
by Brie Hoffman 15 months ago
There is a new social media site where you can post articles and photo's called steemit.com and you can make a good amount of money on it.
by MissMelissaK 6 years ago
Have you ever lost it at church, as in you just couldn't stop crying?Today's sermon touched a nerve in me today. It was about fathers and how important they are in the spiritual development of their children and how they help to shape their children's lives. I was never particularly...
by Paul Goodman 3 years ago
No real surprises, I guess. Arvind, CEO of Bubblews, confirmed today what many of us have said in the past:Extract from Arvind talking to Bubblews users:"I have already explained that the value in your bank was not tied to our advertising revenue. I'm not going to rehash that, or why it...
by PoeticPhilosophy 4 years ago
I saw alot of people posting about Bubblews and about there success, I'm a guy who takes it easy and haven't even quite been on here for 2 months yet so It didn't feel right at the time. But today I felt like I wanted to post different things that I would prefer to post on a different site so I...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|