Suzie HQ profile image 96

Should HP auto select Best Answer to Questions you ask?


When Best Answer has not been awarded by the author of the question, in a reasonable time frame ( say 3 weeks ), do you think HP should auto select it?

sort by best latest

Glimmer Twin Fan profile image95

Glimmer Twin Fan says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi Glimmer Twin Fan,

    Thanks for your comments! I've also answered questions that have never had a best answer selected and it was months ago. Maybe automated would be difficult. Glad the Q served as a reminder for you! Appreciate your interest!

BLACKANDGOLDJACK profile image85

BLACKANDGOLDJACK says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi BLACKANDGOLDJAKE,

    Good point, I also thought the old system was good to see how other's enjoyed or disliked comments. It was an indicator that could help choosing for many. Appreciate your thoughts, thanks!!

jimmythejock profile image82

James Paterson (jimmythejock) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • ChristinS profile image

    Christin Sander (ChristinS) 4 years ago

    I agree with you Jimmy. I rarely if ever pick a "best" answer, because I feel it closes the door on a conversation. Also, what if I like more than one and benefit why should I choose?


  • See all 2 comments
chef-de-jour profile image90

Andrew Spacey (chef-de-jour) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi chef!

    Thanks for jumping in, appreciate it! You make very valid points as always. At times it is challenging choosing an answer, I agree and there are times when Q's spark debate which is good done in a reasonable manner. Thanks for your input!

Sherry Hewins profile image94

Sherry Hewins says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi Sherry,

    Thanks for commenting. I know it was a problem people hopping about just randomly voting down answers which is not nice for anyone to see. Appreciate your thoughts!

calculus-geometry profile image87

TR Smith (calculus-geometry) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi calculus-geometry,

    Agree that it should be the humans that make the decision, it should be your choice. More in the event of Questions being left idle and not closed after a time frame. Appreciate your comments!

Nesbyte profile image85

Nesbyte says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi Nesbyte,

    Thanks for your input! It can be hard as you say, I know I have had that problem. Maybe some techie in HP could work something out! Just find a bit annoying at times when I see last answered 5 months ago and Q has been answered! Thanks!!

fpherj48 profile image80

Paula (fpherj48) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • Suzie HQ profile image

    Suzanne Ridgeway (Suzie HQ) 4 years ago

    Hi fpherj48,

    Nice to see you! As you say, a month maybe better or a bit longer even. Maybe a prompt sent to hubbers after a time frame would help them make a decision rather than leave to HP. Good thoughts and views, appreciate your interest! :-)

working