PHOENIX (AP) -Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer on Monday vetoed a bill that would have required President Barack Obama and other presidential candidates to prove their U.S. citizenship before their names could appear on the state's ballot. The bill would have made Arizona the first state to pass such a requirement. Opponents had warned the bill would give another black eye to Arizona after last year's controversy over the state's illegal immigration enforcement law.
Brewer said in her veto letter that she was troubled that the bill empowered Arizona's secretary of state to judge the qualifications of all candidates when they file to run for office. "I do not support designating one person as the gatekeeper to the ballot for a candidate, which could lead to arbitrary or politically motivated decisions," said Brewer, who was secretary of state until she became governor in 2009. "
In addition, I never imagined being presented with a bill that could require candidates for president of the greatest and most powerful nation on Earth to submit their 'early baptismal circumcision certificates' among other records to the Arizona secretary of state..."
They aren't asking for circumcision records, just a birth certificate. It's not too much to ask, especially to be the leaders of our country. Just mho.
He's posted his BC. There is no doubt among sane people. The research turned up 2 birth announcements in local papers which they obtained from public records at the hospital. Back then, birth announcements & obituaries were published as news.
You have to twist reality completely out of shape to conclude with no evidence that a woman late in the 3rd trimester would go to a 3rd world country and then hurry back to the US to plant false birth announcements to ensure her son could become POTUS.
NONE of the birther stories has any proof that puts Obama's mother in Kenya. It's rumormongering.
IMO most birthers are racists whose head exploded (figuratively speaking) when a black man was elected. They have been in total denial since and the birther conspiracy is all a weak excuse.
Exactly. I mean it is ok to say, "hey I don't like the idea of a black guy being president..." I could respect that more than all this birther horseshit.
It wouldn't make much difference unfortunately, many of these conspiracy theorists and Obama haters are simply stupid to a degree that defies description, so they would just come up with a heap of horse droppings about his wife, his kids, or even his dog.
The loonies may sink America yet, which seems to be in keeping with their general thrust towards "end times"
man.... asking people to verify that they meet the qualifications of the job they wish to acquire?
... i wish no one would ask to see my teacher's license before I get a job --- That would save me a lot of money in grad school!
But wouldn't you be a bit peed off if you were far and away the best candidate for the job but it turned out there was doubt about you being born in the US and the job went to some klutz who could barely write his own name?
providing qualifications for a job is in no way "crazy".
Agreed, how do I earn a US birth certificate then?
All my other qualifications have been earned, no accidents of birth.
Evan - where does it mention 'birth certificate' in the Constitution?
Pretty: I didn't mention Birth certificates, Doug didn't mention birth certificates, and neither did the OP.
So... his point there completely backfired on him.
Yeah, I get that. I thought he was joking anyway. It struck me as funny because it's a common comeback among conservatives here, but they're serious.
I was joking. The point behind the jest was that it's ridiculous for states to add constitutional requirements beyond what's in the Constitution.
What's particularly notable is that a bat-shit crazy conservative governor is drawing a line against the teabaggers.
why is it strange to have a state ask for more than what the Federal Constitution requires? They're different political entities.
The UN makes laws, but we have laws in addition to them! Same thing!
Evan - The governor saw what you didn't. It's a bad idea for 50 states to have 50 different standards for qualifying for federal office.
It's a REALLY bad idea to allow one person in the state arbitrarily decide if the leading candidate from the opposition doesn't qualify. And I would feel exactly the same way if it was in a state which leans democratic. The whole concept of free and fair elections demands it.
wait wait wait.
Listen, this argument is running in circles.
The CONSTITUTION has a set requirement, outlined in Article 3.
*Maybe I'm missing something*, but from what you've posted in the OP, ALL that Arizona is doing is requiring people to prove that they meet the requirements.
I have NO problem with that. Whatsoever.
If Arizona were to add "and he needs to have brown hair", THEN we'd have a problem. This would have to be changed via an amendment to the Constitution.
I think we're agreeing, but some how disagreeing.
where does it say "birth certificate" in your OP?
Anyway, this is the requirement to be president:
"No person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any Person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty-five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States."
So... you have to prove you're 35 YO, living here for 14 years, and that you were a natural born citizen.
I don't care what documentation is required, but those are the requirements.
But note "at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution,"
So nobody alive is qualified!
I could argue that it is the sloppiest bit of legalese I've seen in a long time.
The problem with that is that you ignored the "or."
You have to be a natural born citizen, or a citizen at the time of the adoption of the Constitution. They had to put that second clause in there, otherwise none of the founders, not even George Washington, would have been qualified to be president, and they'd have had to wait at least 35 years for a natural born citizen to be old enough.
Conjunctions are important.
Also... where did I mention birth certificates?
I would've thought Brewer, of all people, would keep enough guts to realize that if the Federal Government now under the rule of an enigmatic usurper hasn't got the guts to defend the Constitution, then the States should set an example. But I guess she's scared. Reckon the strong-arm tactics of Eric Holder under Obama is enough to scare anybody. He and his ilk have broken the barrier between common patriotic sense and craziness already, 10 times over.
yeah, i'm curious why "proving you meet the qualifications for the job" could be considered "crazy".
That's... a relief!
To be a teacher, I have to know Japanese, have a Grad degree, have a license, and have passed numerous tests....
... but I don't have to prove it!
Coulda saved myself about $80k!! damn!!
I am curious Evan why what he has provided doesn't meet muster with the whack-fringe? That is likewise a head-scratcher.
IT DOESN'T SAY THAT OBAMA HASN'T PROVIDED ENOUGH PROOF!!!
IT JUST SAYS THAT ARIZONA WANTS TO MAKE IT LAW THAT YOU HAVE TO PROVE IT!!!
THEY'RE PASSING A LAW THAT REQUIRES THE PRESIDENT-TO-BE TO PROVE THAT S/HE MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS!! THAT'S NOT A CRAZY THING TO DO!!!
Ms. Brewer is about as nuts as they come Sister Brenda. Have you not noticed that your political "movement" is coming undone at the seams?
Possibly, it is, I dunno.
If it is, it's only because they keep letting Obama play card after card and are too afraid to call his bluff.
As soon as we get a real statesman in the White House, that should change everything for the better. I'm very hopeful!
And that real statesman is Donald Trump? or a Mormon - how do either one of these individuals set with your core religious beliefs? A billionaire with an extremely sketchy personal and business history isn't going to survive the scrutiny. The Tea Party is played-out. It started out with noble goals but quickly became the whore of the corporate elite.
I dunno about "played out".....but I do think the Tea Party is fast becoming something it was never meant to be----a political Party. We don't need another Party. What we need is a reformation of the Democratic Party, starting with throwing out Obama and his minions.
I didn't say anything about Trump or anyone else. I said we need a Statesman. I've got no idea who that would be.
I don't think the Democratic Party wants or needs reformation from Republicans.
The GOP, on the other hand, is sadly in need of reformation.
The 2010 election notwithstanding, the party is in disarray and having a severe identity crisis.
If the Tea Party doesn't want to be a third party, then they need to get their story straight with the GOP leadership.
“Birther” is a “code word.” Its politics predate the ‘neocon.’ They go right back to the eugenics movement, the real birthplace of “conservatism.” They go right back to Nazi Germany and the belief that those of Northern European ancestry are the only real humans.
Everyone else is an “ape” of sorts.
The email with the photo you see above is only one of dozens I receive each week. I check where they come from. Most that I receive originate from Republican political groups or veterans organizations. No attempt is made to hide it.
The “political art” traces back to groups tied to the Heritage Organization and American Enterprise Institute.
--Gordon Duff. He's talking about the e-mail from that woman in Orange County, of Obama's parents being monkeys. She made Olbermann's "worst person in the world", on FOK TV.
And there's that Nazi reference again...
I think these Obama conspiracy theorists should google the name Shicklegruber. Maybe tell us the results of that research, since they are SO diligent, and want to "find the truth"
Well, McCain was born in Panama....
How come no outburst about him not being born here?
Because in spite of being born in Panama, McCain's parents were both US citizens, and one of them was an active duty serviceman. He's legally a natural-born US citizen. And there was no outburst because when this was explained to the folks who brought it up during the '08 campaign, those folks said, "Oh. Well, okay then." and they let it go, because unlike the birthers, they were able to do things like process information and think critically.
early baptismal circumcision records?
I thought only Jews made a religious ceremony out of snipping.
Aren't most circumcisions done in the hospital???
Also, by even mentioning "circumcision" Gov. Brewer is presupposing all candidates would be male.
I doubt even extreme birther Sarah Palin would agree to provide her circumcision certificate!
Good, respectable move by Brewer. You have to be an American citizen to get the job anyway. Why embarrass the entire state by passing a law to show support for the birfer conspiracy theory?
wow! this is too funny. thank god some people have common sense still.
by rhamson2 days ago
In an effort to start a conversation towards a more productive change in the politics and direction of the country does it not make sense at this time that these three areas are at the crux of the failure of this...
by Grace Marguerite Williams3 months ago
PresidentLove or hate Hillary Clinton, she is leading significantly in the polls for Democratic presidential candidate. She has the political smarts & experience to led this country. She also have...
by Susan Reid4 years ago
I saw this Dr. John Whitley on Anderson Cooper tonight. I will have to find that clip. Anderson chewed him up good and spat him out.But the real question is -- do they honestly have nothing better to offer the citizens...
by ptosis4 years ago
Did governor Jan Brewer do a disservice to Arizona by pissing of the President?Obama is in Phoenix to visit Intel's Ocotillo campus.
by Brenda Durham3 years ago
by Holle Abee5 years ago
The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Arizona cannot require proof of citizenship for voter registration. HUH???? Sorry, I'm all for legal immigration, but voting is a right reserved for U.S. citizens - not for...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.