One or two of my hubs have fallen victim to the "does not meet quality standards" empty bubble.
In one case, I imagine it is because the hub falls under the "purely personal" category, better suited to a blog. That's fine. I can move it. (It's an older hub anyway, and was written in answer to another hubber's challenge to other hubbers in general.)
However, on the hub viewing page, I have the option of selecting "delete" or "edit." Once in edit mode, I have the option to "unpublish."
What is the difference, vis-a-vis "duplicate content." If I simply unpublish it here, then re-post on my blog, will the fact that it technically still "exists" on this site trip that finicky duplicate content bot?
If I have no intention of re-publishing it here, would it be preferable to simply delete that hub? (If I left it to languish in unpublished mode, it would at that point be purely for my own reference as part of a complete record of all things I have written here--since I have not always written first in MSWord then transferred my articles--many are written directly into the edit capsules, so there would be no copy in my computer.)
Thanks for any suggestions/advice.
Sincerely, a 3-year-"veteran" hubber still learning the ropes!
I feel your frustration. Last night was the first hub I've written since my eye surgeries back in July and August.
When I was finished writing the hub I noticed HP tips and criticism for my hub before it was published.
So I adhered and eventually published my hub.
One criticism was I used one text capsule. So what? A lot of hubbers use one text capsule. Why my hub was chosen to criticize was puzzling.
Stay tough. You are an excellent writer.
I would simply edit and upgrade it here and try to improve the quality. If you are set on removing and printing it elsewhere then I would copy and paste it to someplace like Word to save it; and delete it (after I am sure that it is copied) on HP to remove all records such as the Hub and URL to avoid all problems.
Thanks, The Examiner-1,
I don't think it will 'upgrade' suitably--it IS "purely personal," (an article on "How I Came to be Me")..written before I was fully familiar with the type of writing HP prefers...no photos are available for the main points, either...so I think it is best deleted.. thanks for your input.
When you delete a hub you are removing it from the HP directory and making the URL available. Google also will eventually remove the URL once their crawlers cannot access that page.
When you unpublish a hub the URL is still yours; it still remains in the HP directory and Google bots are able to access the page.
When moving articles from HP to another site the best option is to delete. Unpublishing the hub works better if you have extensive work to do on the hub and/or if you want Google to re-crawl (anew).
Thank you so much, Cardisa, for that comprehensive explanation.
That tells me that with this particular hub, I need to simply delete it, as there is no way to re-work it.
However, with hubs I do wish to re-work, even extensively, I will simply wait until I have time to do it all at one sitting, so as not to lose my original authorship date.
Cardisa, the hubs are not in the directory or available to bots from my knowledge?
They are invisible to all but the writer.
The unpublished hubs are still visible to bots but they are not crawled. They have a "no -crawl" tag on them. (my own words, forgot the proper term). Staff explained it to me before, I hope I explained it well. The unpublished hub is similar to the unfeatured where the tag tells Google not to crawl but deleted hub is no longer there at all.
Ok thanks. Robots.txt?
Interesting. I might go delete some...
I heard that if you unpublish a Hub - I believe it was for a week - it is deleted. Do you know if that is true?
I have never heard of that Examiner so I can't say whether or not it's true.
Are you positive this is the case, Cardisa? I have the feeling people have tried giving me a link to an unpublished Hub before, and I couldn't use it.
Marisa, the outside world do not have access to this hub. It's now similar to saving a draft but it remains in the system indefinitely. The URL does not become available either. It's not in the main directly but still is in the pool of occupied URLs, which means it's still in the back end of the site. It now has a no-index tag on it so it won't be crawled or indexed by Google.
The deleted hub's URL now becomes available after 24 hours. It is totally removed from the site's pool of URLs and vanishes completely from anywhere on the site as opposed to the unpublished hub which is saved somewhere.
I was trying to explain the difference so Ms. Lizzy could understand and choose the best option.
Yes, and both Wry and I are questioning your explanation because we're both pretty sure it's not correct.
You are right, an unpublished Hub retained its URL, so Google's bots can still see a URL exists. However the bots can't crawl the content, whether there's a no-index tag on it or not. So there is never any possibility of duplicate content problems with an unpublished Hub.
The no-index tag you're talking about is not to prevent crawling of the content (which isn't necessary, because the content isn't visible). It is to prevent 404 errors - it's telling Google, "we've unpublished this URL deliberately, it's not a careless mistake on our part".
lol.. I never mentioned anything about duplicate content with unpublished hubs.
You are saying exactly what I said that Google bots can still see the hub. About the reason for the hub not being crawled...well I may have misunderstood that part. But I don't see the difference in both our explanations.
Maybe instead of deleting them, those articles might be better suited for a different type of web site.
That's what I said--but the issue was between outright 'delete' and simply 'unpublish.'
That's a good question Dzymslizzy, I think your concern is that if you unpublish it, and post it on your blog, Google will recognize it as duplicate content and penalize its traffic. At the same time, one must wonder, what happens if you delete it, and somebody copied your article, and then you have lost that important time stamp that proves you wrote the article first? I am planning to move some of my hubs too into my website or blog, but am also afraid of these issues.
There is that, alexadry, but it is not a money-maker anyway...and I don't run adsense on my blog, so that's kind of a non-issue.
As far as any plagiarism concerns, I don't think an autobiographical piece is too likely to fall victim--it's neither 'educational' nor of universal appeal.
If you unpublish, it becomes invisible - only you can see it. So to the outside world, it's deleted.
Hi Kenneth. I wrote all my hubs with one text capsule. Hubbers and then HubPages strongly advised me to do several capsules so that photos can go within the text. It is difficult to get hubs approved without this layout. It does look better, I will admit. Good luck and keep well.
Without multiple text capsules, it is virtually impossible to align a photo exactly with the text it should accompany.
Kenneth, text capsules can be used purely to do this, and you do not need to put a heading in the box for each and every capsule. In this way, after the hub is published, the reader has no idea you've made any kind of separation, the text just flows--but the photos stay right where they should be.
Hi Mlislizy the one thing I know is to wait a week before publishing it elsewhere. I think after you unpublish it gets deleted. Good luck
I always make copies of every hub I write and then categorize them. I never unpublish, but always delete. If I decide to bring the hub or parts of it back later, I can always do that. On the other hand, if I simply want to use the hub elsewhere I can...after it has been removed from the indexes.
If you just unpublish a hub it just stays on your account indefinitely. I had one like that. I eventually edited it and published it again.
I would make sure to max out all of the goals in the Hub Helper at the top right hand side of your screen when creating a Hub. I now have over 200 Hubs, all Featured. Check me out if you need some help!
It's funny. After five years, I sometimes feel like "a veteran just learning the ropes" as well. I know some others have said differently but if it helps at all, I rarely ever delete. I mainly unpublish and I might have several hubs at a time that are in unpublished status. If you do choose to delete, I would suggest that you definitely cut and paste into MsWord and save on your computer first. Then you can edit and cut and paste back to your other blog or just keep on your computer for as long as you like.
I'll leave it to the others to advise you about the duplicate content because I am not really sure about it but I would think that once you repost it on your external blog, you should indeed go ahead and delete it from HubPages instead of just keeping it unpublished. Then you've got it existing in just one place for sure.
Good luck with all the articles you're planning to re-work and/or relocate.
I just checked. I logged out and tried following this link to one of my unpublished Hubs:
If it just had a "no crawl" or "no index" tab, I'd be able to paste that link in my browser and I'd be able to look at the Hub. Instead, I get a "That Hub is no longer published" message.
If I can't paste the link into a browser then no one else can see it either, including robots.
by Misha 8 years ago
I got a poorly worded to the point of being offensive email from the team about one of my hubs that got unpublished. I replied with a request for clarification. Almost 24 hours passed since. I am wondering, how long I have to wait for the response?Now, I keep quiet about one of my workers waiting...
by Kate Swanson 8 years ago
It seems the News Capsule is now out of favour.That's a bummer, because over the last couple of years, it's been recommended as a great thing to add your Hubs to keep the content "fresh".As a result, I (and many other Hubbers) have a News capsule on every @##$%^& Hub. That means...
by Agnes Elmira Kepler 4 years ago
Hi friends.this is my first time reaching out to the community for help. I just graduated form Writer's Boot Camp and need to finish 5 more hubs before applying for the earning programs. But this is not the subject of my inquiry today.I started my account 5 years ago when I knew absolutely nothing...
by Person of Interest 5 years ago
http://hubpages.com/my/hubs/stats?categ … ule=AmazonFolks, we really need to make a concerted effort to delete (or at least not display) those Amazon capsules we know to be in violation of QAP.The above link will hopefully help.
by Ponx 9 years ago
Hi everyone, I joined HubPages 2 weeks back and I have been trying to write at least 2 hubs per week (even with my job at hand)....I feel that the HubPages members are very helpful and are more than eager to help out new hubbers...please do read some of my hubs and leave a few...
by Liz Elias 7 years ago
Okay, to start with, the features in the capsules we have are already pretty awesome, and my hat is off to the programmers for coming up with all these utilities.There is one additional feature that would be on my wish list, and that would be the option to "drag and drop" photo and map...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|