I don't know if "vetting" is even the right word here, but I think we need some sort of approval process for new hubbers. Though I've only been here a few months, it feels like there has been a real increase in empty, self-promoting, spam hubs. People join, and post a big ad about themselves or their services... that sort of thing. Or people who don't understand the point and post 3 sentences about what they did today.
There are a lot of great informative hubs in here, but a casual visitor is going to be turned off when they see some of the nonsense being published. This goes for hubs as well as requests.
The flagging idea works, provided enough people are using it (I flag bad hubs as I see them, anyone else?). Perhaps new hubbers should have their first 3 or 4 hubs approved by an editor before posting. That might help eliminate people who don't actually have anything to say.
Just a thought.
I so hate that.
There's place for that sort of thing. Like their own blog, forums or they can just annoy their closest friends by emailing them.
I agree with you, darkside. HubPages strikes me more as a place to share what you know or can do and teach with the world, not as a place to leave a journal.
I believe there should be a requirement before you are able to post a request, specifically regarding a possible approval process over requests. I pull a number of ideas from the requests option, but often I see requests which are poorly thought out or poorly worded, and have to pass over them to find viable requests.
I agree, I have the same feeling too of an increase in spam . I denied one comment that I thought was spam and then got a thumbs down on the hub - gee I wonder who that was from!
How do you report a suspect?
I think you may have a point. I'm sure HP don't want to turn into the thought police, but there are several writing sites which do already insist you go through a vetting process before you get started.
It's absolutely vital that HP keeps up the quality, if it's going to preserve its reputation. I haven't come across too many awful Hubs, but some of the Requests are truly ridiculous and simply invite people to post something sub-standard.
Personally, I'm not quite sure what flagging is all about. I've had one "thumbs down" for one hub and I don't know why. Is flagging different from thumbs? Does anything happen if you flag?
Flagging is a specific way to let the admin folks know there is a bad hub out there. When you click the "flag this hub" link (next to the thumbs up/down buttons, I think) you are given a choice of what the problem is with the hub so that it can be reviewed.
If you Flag, then administration lopks closely at the Hub to see what is worng with it. It may be removed, or not.
Another measure that would help is to have a minimum word count for Hubs. That would prevent people posting short answers.
It's enormously helpful if people flag hubs. They will get reviewed by one of us.
In this case the spammer doesnt have any hubs - all hes done is become fans of lots of people and posted comments.
I agree that there does seem to be more junk requests and junk answers than previously, but maybe that's just because there's more of everything - the price of expansion.
I worry a bit about the thumbs down option. A hub that is controversial or challenging will sometimes attract an anonymous thumbs down from someone who doesn't even comment. I don't see how that benefits anyone.
Thanks for the clarification about thumbs down vs flagging. I thought they had to be different. I got a thumbs down for one of my hubs, and I didn't get any messages from HP or have any action taken.
Actually I feel it was a good thing, because it made me have a look at the hub and realise I hadn't done a thorough job. I've revised it now - just wish there was a way to get whoever "thumbed" it to look at it again and (hopefully) change their mind!
Maybe the "flagging" option needs to be a bit more obvious, then more people would use it?
Not sure if that's a good idea or not. It might be better than only a few "serious" hubbers really know what it's for, or it could be misused and become useless.
I run a large social network, and there is a little icon to flag something as inappropriate (for photos, blogs, messages). Well, people are constantly using it, likely thinking that it's like a bookmark or something. I get flag reports every day with dozens of perfectly fine entries. People even flag their own posts. I can see that kind of problem happening here too.
Just a thought.
Aside from straight out spam and duplicate content how can you judge quality? Everyone is going to have a different opinion on what makes a good hub. Word count wouldn't work either because a good hub could just have videos and/or pictures.
I think HP already has a pretty good algorithm with quality hubs having a higher score and rising above average hubs.
The problem with flagging as opposed to vetting is that the content is already there, and being read, before it is removed. In the case of sexually explicit material, that isn't good. Children can be reading this.
I suggest either a filtering system or vetting of some kind before a hub can even hit the site. I know that would involve a lot of work, but there has to be something that can be done. I had to flag several sexually explicit hubs today, but they are still there for all to see. The flagging process just takes too long to be effective. And these spammers are smart. They post at the heaviest traffic times to get the most exposure.
by Dorsi Diaz 9 years ago
I was just wondering, if you read a well written hub but it was something controversial that had a different opinion than you had, would you rate it thumbs down because of that or would you rate it on the hub itself ( written well, lots of information, good layout?)Just wondering because I write...
by Dennis L. Page 5 years ago
Do you give other hubs a "thumbs down" vote?I've never voted a "thumbs down" on any hub, regardless of errors or the tone and nature of an article. If a hub is filled with errors or it is politically charged and I disagree, I may respond, but I do not vote it down. Am I shirking...
by Satori 10 years ago
Often, we'll be reading Hubs to find a specific answer or solution to something in our lives. And often, we'll get to the end and be "too busy" to rate it. This is understandable; I do it too. Even though I know that by giving a Hub a Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down, I will be...
by Dolores Monet 8 years ago
Is there any way to tell if a particular hub has received any thumbs up or thumbs down, and if so, how many? I've been here long enough, I should know these things. But I don't.
by ProCW 10 years ago
I recently wrote a hub on this and have gotten some good responses from it. I was wondering, does anyone have any sort of method that they use for writing comments for hubs? Do you just write comments on hubs that you like? Do you comment on all the hubs that you read? Do you also give a...
by Tina 9 years ago
So I will post a few links to my hubs for you to look over. (Please??) Would like some commentary on my writng style and if the hub is interesting enough. Seems as though I have an acceptable hub score but not a lot of fans.Please tell me what you feel.. I won't cry .. much ...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|