jump to last post 1-11 of 11 discussions (13 posts)

Writing Comments for Hubs & Thumbs Up

  1. ProCW profile image81
    ProCWposted 9 years ago

    I recently wrote a hub on this and have gotten some good responses from it. I was wondering, does anyone have any sort of method that they use for writing comments for hubs? Do you just write comments on hubs that you like? Do you comment on all the hubs that you read? Do you also give a "Thumbs Up" for all the hubs that you like? Just wondering. Let us all know. We can all help each other... right? smile

    Happy Hubbing

    1. drummer boy profile image59
      drummer boyposted 9 years agoin reply to this

      I like to leave feedback on all of the hubs I read unless everyone else has already covered it.  I like to let people know I stopped by, I also give them a thumbs up if it was good.

  2. marisuewrites profile image57
    marisuewritesposted 9 years ago

    If I read, I comment; If I comment - I try to be positive or give at least some positive words, then an opinion; If I feel really moved, I do a thumbs up.  My thought process is this;  All hubs are work; I try to recognize that.  Complicated subjects or feelings and sincere writing is more work.  Thumbs up goes to the one who really moved me or put in a lot of work.  I don't have to agree to be moved, and I don't have to agree to make a comment.
    That's just the way I do it.  I don't think all comments have to be agreement, but criticism can still be positively stated.

  3. Stacie Naczelnik profile image74
    Stacie Naczelnikposted 9 years ago

    I only comment if I really feel I have something relevant to say.  I try to avoid the "nice hub" comments, and make them worthwhile.

    I do give a thumbs up to everything I like, whether I comment or not.  I don't thumb either way if I'm "eh" about a hub.  I rarely thumbs down.  Very rarely.  But have on occasion, and only when I felt really moved to do it.

  4. Dorsi profile image91
    Dorsiposted 9 years ago

    I usually leave comments, not always, and I always rate the hubs. I don't think I've given any thumbs down to any hubs.

  5. crashcromwell profile image76
    crashcromwellposted 9 years ago

    I didn't notice the thumbs up and down buttons for a long time, so I didn't do it. Now I have to remind myself to do it when I find a hub I like. I tend to think that every hub has some redeeming value, so I tend to not give a thumbs down. I also only comment if I have something good to say. I used to review musicians and had the same policy. If I thought a band was worth seeing, I would write a positive review. Only once did I slam a band, and that was after they harassed me over and over to write a review, so I gave them what they deserved.

    Jim Henry

  6. robie2 profile image97
    robie2posted 9 years ago

    I usually give a thumbs up to any hub I like.  I comment when I have something to say and that could have nothing to do with whether I like the hub or not.--that is to say whether the hub is well written, informative or whether or not I agree with the points the author is making.  If I  have something to say I comment, if not I don't.....must say some of the comments threads get very interesting and very heated too LOL-- oh yeah, and once in awhile I'll see a google ad that interests me and click on it, go to another site and leave the hub behind. I have the attention span of a flea sometimes:-)

    1. ProCW profile image81
      ProCWposted 9 years agoin reply to this

      flea-like attention spans are very well liked here! haha

  7. stephhicks68 profile image86
    stephhicks68posted 9 years ago

    I give comments to about 85% of the hubs I read.  I am trying to get better about thumbs up for good hubs I read too.  Rarely do I simply give a thumbs up without a comment.  I have yet to give a thumbs down.  But if I read a really bad one that deserved it (or spam, etc.) I would do it.

  8. SweetiePie profile image82
    SweetiePieposted 9 years ago

    I try to comment on a few hubs every day.  Sometimes all I may say is good hub, but I truly mean it when I say that.  I think of myself as a cheerleader in that small sense, plus it is something fun to do when I am at work and things are slow.

  9. ripplemaker profile image85
    ripplemakerposted 9 years ago

    I write a comment (esp. a positive one) when I like the hub ,or if I find it interesting and add some thoughts on the matter.  That goes for the thumbs up too.  I rarely give a thumbs down.  I just find myself moving on to another hub.  smile

  10. Bob Ewing profile image51
    Bob Ewingposted 9 years ago

    I comment when the hub interests me enough that I just have to say something and give a thumbs up when the hub is informative. I rarely do thumbs down, have once, maybe twice, but usually just move on.

  11. ProCW profile image81
    ProCWposted 9 years ago

    So far there are lots of different "methods" behind it. Who else does their commenting and thumbing differently?