This is a suggestion for an additional feature to the option to order comments by either oldest or most recent as first-appearing.
The current tool is useful for hubs with many comments, as I means people do not have to scroll through 50 or more comments to read the most recent.
However, it would be an excellent addition, if in addition to being able to put the most recent comments at the top, if doing so would also move the comment box to the top of the stack.
Even though you can read the newest comments, it is still necessary to scroll through all of them to get to the box to type your own. It is a small problem, I suppose, for those wishing to comment.
However, for the author, in trying to reply to a comment, it necessitates scrolling back and forth to pick up all of the commenter's points, and reply to each. If there are several new comments, this quickly becomes tiresome.
Can we please let the comment-typing box 'float' along with the comment order selection?
Newest first = comment box at top; Oldest first = comment box at bottom (as it currently is).
Thanks for considering this idea.
If you are talking about the stats page they move around according to scores, to see newest first, go to profile. Newest is top Hub.
You can order them either way. For each hub you can choose to have comments ascending, or descending
In each hub..choose to edit your comments capsule, and you will be able to set your preferences there
You can do this in your global settings also
Yes you can Deborah, but it doesn't make any difference to the comment box for writing a new comment. It always appears at the bottom first so you have to scroll all the way to the bottom to lleave a comment. This is ok is there are only a few comments but if it's say one of billybuc's hubs (though his have descending comments) there may be 100 comments to scroll through.
It doesn't matter whether the comment box is at top or bottom for your commenting purpose.. If you are to post a reply to anybody, you will simply click reply button and the box appears in front of you. If you post a fresh comment, simply scroll down which will not take any time at all. It only takes some seconds for you. So no difference whether it is at top or bottom.
how come some hubs i read have 3 comment capsules? Anyone can explain to me?
I agree MsLizzy. I was thinking this myself that if the comment box was at the top as well as the newest comment Iwould change my settings to that. As it is I feel it a waste of time if people have to scroll all the way down to comment anyway. The way it is if set to have newest comment at the top it is a disincentive to bother even leaving a comment.
I just checked my hub again.
While on my hub when I reload the page, it brings me right to the comment box
Yes you are right Deborah. I checked your hubs and you have descending comments. That's not a problem especially on an old hub in which case most people want to read the most recent comments then leave their own directly under the most recent comment. I think MsLizzy's was just suggesting it would be easier, if you elected to have the latest comment at the top of comments, if the new comment box was directly above it. You can always use the side bar to scroll back and forth but we are always looking for easier and quicker ways to do things. One solution of course for the hub author is to go to your accounts page/comments and reply to all the comments there.
Old hubs ? I have about 15-20 new ones
Yes, I understand what the other person was saying
As I explained, you can elect to have them at the top if you wish, that's already in place
In the meantime, I explained how to get to the box to make a comment, by the pull down scroll, and by reloading it, if you don't mind.
When you reload , it brings the comment box to you
With the pull down scroll, it takes a second to get to the comment box, if you wish to do it that way. Or everyone can wait till they implement the suggestion.
I personally don't feel that everything we do has to be automated, especially when it takes so little effort.
Whether your comments are ascending or descending, all the other comments can be read first, if anyone wishes to read them
I must be missing the meaning of the question. When I first started, I had my hubs ordered with the most recent comment at the top. Then after a few weeks I changed it so the hubs were ordered with the oldest at the top. The click string to do so is: Hubs Tab-->Comments-->Global Settings. If you're talking about the settings for hubs other than your own, the setting is driven by the hub writer.
I would like to see the "Leave a Comment" box right up at the top, regardless of whether the comments are ascending or descending. Sometimes, I like to read all the comments and sometimes I don't.
On some hubs, there is an option to "Go to Last Comment", which takes you to the bottom where the comment box is.
I agree Phyllis, that was what DzyMsLizzy was suggesting and I seconded, but it seems others are having trouble with the original suggestion. Does the "go to last comment" option only appear on a hub that has a lot of comments? I know it isn't on all hubs.
I don't know why the "go to last comment" does not appear on all hubs, Jodah. I see it on hubs with over 100 and on hubs with less than 10 comments. I am really curious why it does not always show up.
I don't have a problem with the question, please stop generalizing, I was simply explaining the FACTS
Yes, thank you, Phyllis Doyle, that is what I was saying. Have the box where you type in the comment appear at the top. And I agree with your additional suggestion of having it appear there, anyway, regardless of the order of the comments themselves.
I see. I originally answered from the feed page and the post was truncated. You do have a point, DzyMsLizzy. Though I'm okay with scrolling through the messages to get to the comment box, I can see where others may not wish to. By scrolling through the comments on any post, I am able to get an idea of what's been said recently and tailor my response as such. I don't always scan the comments though on the way down.
And as I explained, you don't have to scroll through them all. All you do is either reload page, and the comment box will come to you, or grab the pull down scroll to the right of your computer
I have over 800 comments on one hub, but I can instantly get to the box.
I can't post a link to my hub here, but my hub about Paul and the number 666 which is spotlighted, is the one with over 800 comments,
Try pulling down the side scroll, and see how fast it is
Why? We have the option to go to the last comment immediately by clicking the button when you reach the comments section. You can use this button. But some of us may like to see what others have commented before commenting.
As an author, the author may like to have his preference. But, one must view from both points- as an author and also as a viewer. So, as far as I think, the present one is good for all community.
That's what I am saying. It's already easy to do, so why do we need it automated ?
The examples I gave are just as easy as yours, which is a third way
Thanks for suggesting it
I just checked, and there is no such button that appears on my pages. I don't know if that has to do with the browser, or what, but I don't have a 'go to bottom' button.
That button only seems to appear on some hubs and not others MsLizzy. No idea why.
I don't know if anyone has mentioned this yet:
I have a function on my 'mouse' that if I 'click' on the Scroll Wheel a directional arrow button appears!
You then just move the Mouse in the direction you want to scroll. Up Down or Sideways!
The further away from the button you move the mouse the faster the Screen moves!
It takes a bit of getting used to but it is great for faster scrolling! and you don't get RSI in your fingers moving the Scroll wheel
It's not on my mouse, but after I updated Firefox, I found this
Interesting. I just tried that, and it did work. I had no idea the scroll wheel could be 'clicked.' Thanks, agvulpes!
Good advice for those using a pc, but for those of us with just a laptop/notebook or tablet that's not an option.
You can also hit END PAGE to get to the bottom of comments, if you have such a key on your computer or laptop.
YES! Please move the comment box to the top when they are set to newest first.
1. Many readers may not be prepared to read or scroll through 200 comments before leaving a comment so they don't bother.
2. When I want to reply to the latest comment, by the time I get to the bottom of the page I have forgotten their name and what the comment was in detail. So I often have to use notepad to copy the reader's name plus the entire comment before writing my reply way down at the bottom of the page.
Putting the comments box at the top, above the last comment would encourage more comments and make replying much easier.
People want a “go to last comment” button, and by the time you do that, you could have just as easily used the ways, I listed here
It couldn’t get any easier than it already is
IF people are using their mouse wheel to scroll, it will take a minute, but not if you use the pull down scroll
There are 2 possible settings for the comments capsule:
(1) to have the comments listed with the most recent comment at the bottom, which is the default setting. This thread is not about this first option. This thread has nothing to do with scrolling down to the most recent comment at the bottom of the list . It is about the 2nd option which is:
2) to have the comments listed with the most recent comment at the top of the comments list.
Most prominent hubbers have chosen the second option (most recent comment at the top).
Lizzy, and many of us who have set our comments capsule to this second option are asking for the comments box to also be placed at the top for the reasons given earlier which are: Putting the comments capsule at the top, above the most recent comment (which is at the top) would encourage more comments, more discussion, and make replying to comments far less inconvenient.
To find out how to change your comments settings for the most recent comments to show at the top, go to:
scroll down to
"Display most recent comments first"
Here is a reference to a two-year old response from staff on the same issue.
The question is, have HP staff seen this forum thread and is the answer still the same as 2 years ago?
by GoogleCashMoney 9 years ago
Dear Hubbers,I have publish around 11 Hubs and my Hublinks are as follows:<snipped link><snip> <snip><snip><snippety snip> <snip><snip> <snip><snip><snip><snip--DO NOT START POSTS FOR THE PURPOSE OF LINKING> I have receive lots...
by Andrew 10 years ago
I still think comments should be comments, not discussions, that is the purpose of a forum. Maybe it would be a good idea that every author has a forum automatically made in a widget on there profile page and the topics are always the title of the Hub. That way you can discuss it and always edit...
by Anti-Valentine 6 years ago
There are two issues that have led me to make this suggestion. One is that I recently received an email from a person who claimed he couldn't find the comment box on one of my hubs. The other issue is that some claim that scrolling all the way down the page to the comment box at the bottom might...
by Isabella Snow 9 months ago
This has been discussed a number of times, but I think it's time to bring it up again because lately I've been denying loads of comments that I view as spam. And, just now, I've been told by someone whose comments Ive denied that "hubs are here for comments". No, they aren't. If they...
by Whitney 8 years ago
What are the potentially cons of not using a comment box?I'm tired of answering the same questions over and over again. I'm tired of getting rude comments. I'm tired of dealing with it basically. I want to help people, but answering the same question over and over again or having to defend myself...
by Tessa Schlesinger 9 months ago
I was quite stunned a week or more ago when someone made a statement on one of my hubs that she had commented twice and I had snubbed her by not replying. Her comment had been particularly flattering, and probably because I've spent a lifetime being flattered by others only to find that they wanted...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|