It seems like HP is having more issues the more they try to make improvements.
I can't trust my stats, the revenue I receive, etc.
So can someone tell me what is working?
Google's systematic devaluation of content farms. It's been working steadily for a few years now, which is what's happening here.
Let's look at what is working on the internet overall. This is an article I found interesting; it sort of gives a rundown on what Google might like:
http://www.marketingprofs.com/articles/ … ill-eat-up
Since no one is privy to the exact nature of Google's algorithms for ranking content, the article could be way off base. But it's probably not, even though it was posted in 2013.
The biggest problem for us is that, for whatever reason, Google isn't buying into our sub-domains. Even if I have a niche HP sub-domain that fits into one of the categories in the article linked here, Google is going to penalize it because it's on HubPages.
Why does it do that? Probably because it sees other content on HubPages that doesn't fit into the categories, it finds poorly written and unedited content and it has a slanted view of what HubPages is, as Relache stated: a "content farm". Somewhere in the algorithm it says: "Hey, there are people on HubPages writing for our advertising dollars who aren't qualified to be doing so. We better penalize the entire site and all of its authors."
Is it fair? Yes and no. My sub-domains should have nothing to do with any of your sub-domains, unless we are writing about the same things and we are linked up by HP. What's linking to me on HP and who is getting incoming links from my sub-domain? That's food for thought, eh?
But my sub-domain is no different, really, than having my own site. I'm the only one writing the articles on it. I have control over who comments on it or edits my work. HP is just a platform I'm utilizing to provide informational and entertaining content. Right?
Not necessarily. Some of us are using HP as a platform to gain backlinks or for selling a product with thin content as the hook. Some of us haven't a grasp of the English language or any concept of formatting an article properly but still we are undeterred from posting on the site.
But allow me to let you in on a little secret. I've needed information from the web and typed something into the Google search box to find it. The best information I found, and it isn't all that rare, was a HubPages article on an authoritative niche site.
Put that in your algorithm, Google!
Thanks for sharing the article and great points you make. It does seem sad to me that everyone is penalized for the low quality content of others, but hopefully all the things HP is implementing now will help improve that over time. I'm eternally optimistic I suppose .
Awesome. I understand the jest of sub-domains related to domains. I was able to understand that analogously with a WordPress blog being used as a sub-domain for one's website. Connections are made especially with multiplicity of more than one such as more than one Hubber.
The article you shared has immense value for me of least seeking to be a better hubber and success with hubs. Thank You so very much Jason! :-)
Jason: This was beautifully stated. I hope the team takes the time to read it, because you are spot on with these comments.
I have believed for some time now that the team made a huge mistake long ago simply by allowing anybody and everybody to write here without first making them go through a vetting process.
Now that quality has become a huge issue, they are working hard to catch up, but they do not have enough people on board to do the work quickly enough, and they have neglected to start at the beginning. This means that all writers who came here early in the game and did not have the skill or desire to do things the right way (as per today's Google guidelines) are still here!
Furthermore, Paul has clearly stated that people still slip through the QAP process, which tells me it is flawed.
They then compounded their error by taking in so m any of the Squidoo people, most of whom had far too many ads on their articles, and allowing them a "grace period" to make corrections, thus allowing Google to "see" their work before those who wanted to do so could make corrections.
You can hardly blame Google for looking down on this site when things are in such a mess. They are not going to take the time to sort the good from the bad. That's HP's job.
Whether they can find a fix before Google really lowers the boom, I don't know.
What I do know is those who still remain here must make every effort to continue producing good content so that we can sort of even the scales.
Another problem is the fact that there are so many tech problems these days which are frustrating the writers who remain here.
We have lost tens of thousands of writers in recent years, many of whom were excellent. We cannot afford to lose more.
Paul needs to hire more people and task them with the job of cleaning up the spammers and poor English writers. If he continues to insist on seeking to enhance views by only centering on the already good articles, after awhile, it won't matter because Google will penalize the entire site.
I hope he is listening to both of us!
The revenue received has never been anything other than correct according to anyone I have heard from. Often unimpressive, but paid out in full and on time.
Strange though it may seem, HubPages stats are not related to the revenue we receive. I've never been able to understand why that should be the case but it's what we've been told several times.
I have no reason to doubt the accuracy of revenue.
I'm seeing my summer topics that did well for years on Squidoo, now starting to surge in traffic on HubPages. Still not as many visitors as in the past, but definitely am improvement over a few months ago.
Time to dust off the summer hubs that had been unfeatured for traffic back in April. Nuisance, but has to be done.
There has a lot been said here already, but I do not think we are ever going to get rid of the label "content farm" make no difference how good our articles are. Once google has something in their sights they never let go:(
by Sondra Rochelle 2 years ago
Janderson posted something really important yesterday which I think everybody here needs to read http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/132621#post2759379.If he is correct in his assumptions (which it appears he might be), it is time for all of us to start making copies of all of our hubs (if we are...
by sunforged 7 years ago
With all the hub-bub about traffic drops across the hub domain and the uncertainty about how that may effect hub publishers in the future, How are you reacting?Did you have an exit plan?Personally, whenever I wrote here with a hubber/writer audience in mind, Ive always harped on the importance...
by Gary Anderson 4 years ago
You know, when you have people like demand media paying people to crank out thousands of articles with no blood sweat and tears, and then my traffic from US google goes down the day content farms are smacked by the google algo, it makes one wonder. No one is paid here for most hubs. No one gets...
by Eric Dockett 2 years ago
In the blog post about moving away from subdomains Paul referenced comparing HubPages to competitors several times. To me, this indicates HP has identified certain sites as typical of the kind of site HP is attempting to morph into. I ask because I think it would be helpful to have some idea of...
by Pandoras Box 7 years ago
"Regardless of the changes Google makes, we will continue to strive to create the most rewarding place to publish online and continue to innovate for our fantastic community," Edmondson said in a statement, adding that had the algorithm worked as Google wanted it to, he would have...
by ishwarya_p 7 years ago
I am building backlinks to my hubs, already reached 35 backlinks which are all been indexed by Google, still no SERP boost. Typically how long it will take to see effects and boost in SERP?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|