Just curious, why would a hubber not provide a place for comments? Do they not what to hear from the peanut gallery?
I read a hub, thought it was good, wanted to comment, not there. Found it odd.
I find lots of religious hubs without comment boxes and I think its due to abusive hate comments, but its strange not to see them on some great hubs out there
Some people might just accidentally close the capsule? I did that once on accident and did not realize it until a day later.
I thought about them being left out by accident and that certainly could be one reason. As for the religous ones, and the political ones for that matter, if you are going to say something someone is going to disagree. At least let people spout their opinion and then rebut them.
There seems to be many reasons, but if it is a great hub, I give them a comment by messageing anyway.
Or you can delete a comment that is too confrontational. The way I see is the hub is my voice, and forum is available for the more frictive disagreements. Some times the hubs are just a safe haven for those who do not want to deal with comment wars. I have deleted a few comments and do not apologize for it because the hub is the opportunity for the writer to share, and if someone is being too disagreeable I just delete.
Sometimes their comment might be good, but I have received novel length comments that were basically critiquing everything I had to share, and that basically means the person should be writing their own hub on the subject. The hub itself is an opportunity for the writer to spread their wings and fly, and sometimes they may not want all comments. Some people have deleted my well meaning comments in the past, but I never was offended. However, it is better to have a comment capsule for those comments that would enrich a hub.
I've accidentally deleted the capsule, but I suppose I can see how someone may write one particular Hub or another and just not want comments on it for one reason or another.
It could be the hubber is so busy with some other things that said hubber doesn't want the comment thing to be on his mind all the time allowing hubber to do these other things while not leaving the comments go unchecked. said hubber may go back and open comments for the peanut gallery's when other things are done.
If I write a commercial product review kind of hub I'll often remove the comment box. Chances are it's not going to receive many comments because there's not really anything to debate, and most importantly this brings the bottom Adsense block right up to the bottom of the article removing the comments block as a barrier in between, which could possibly increase clicks.
I did that once by mistake. Once I realized it I put the comment capsule on. I feed on the comments of my readers. It makes HubPages what it is.
by Christy Kirwan3 weeks ago
Please visit the HubPages Blog for an update on Comment Capsules in articles and let us know here if you have any questions or comments.
by Whitney9 years ago
What's the point in having a comment box if the particular hubber denies every comment posted on the hub?I noticed a comment on a hub, so I read it. It wasn't a bad comment at all, just something that I would see why...
by Longhunter5 years ago
A few weeks ago I commented on a hub but the hubber deleted all mine as well as others comments since they didn't agree with his views of the Bible. I found the hub on 3-16 and the hubber took one of my removed comments...
by Marcy Goodfleisch3 years ago
I just noticed that comments I delete from the 'comments' section on my accounts page are not being deleted from the actual hubs. One of my hubs gets spammed a lot by people posting links and email addresses for...
by Catherine Giordano2 years ago
If you deny someone's comment does it hurt their hubber score? Does it hurt you own hubber score if you deny the comments of others? Does it hurt the hub score if the hub has a denied comment?
by James A Watkins4 years ago
I published a new Hub this morning:http://james-a-watkins.hubpages.com/hub … n-HubPagesAround 11:15 I noticed it had half a dozen comments already. I remember the first one was from GPage. I thought I would...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.