jump to last post 1-13 of 13 discussions (13 posts)

Do you ever leave comments on hubs that you have not read in full?

  1. donnaisabella profile image79
    donnaisabellaposted 6 years ago

    Do you ever leave comments on hubs that you have not read in full?

    Once in a while I see comments on hubs that suggest that the writer did not take time or care to engage the writer by fully reading the hub before commenting. A lot of times a hub makes great reading but the sheer content of the hub or the style of writing makes it difficult to finish (in short you are tired or bored), so what do you do? I have always read and commented because I wanted to, but when people read to move levels, what happens? Just asking.

  2. profile image0
    Website Examinerposted 6 years ago

    Actually, I do not think it is always necessary to read a hub in full to form an opinion. If the reader is bored, or have formed an impression about the writing style at an earlier juncture, it is possible to leave a meaningful and constructive comment based upon that.

  3. hillymillydee profile image61
    hillymillydeeposted 6 years ago

    No I don't leave any feed back or comment  if I didn't read the whole article, when I comment it must come from my heart. I don't like to flatter.

    But if I read the whole hub I will thank the hubber for the information in my comment

  4. zanaworld profile image67
    zanaworldposted 6 years ago

    I read full content of a hub before commenting.  It is not fair to be comment without reading the full content of the hub.

    Another point.  If someone has left a comment on your hub, then I prefer to post my reply comment immediately - even if it is just a thank you msg.

  5. Rabia Khitran profile image82
    Rabia Khitranposted 6 years ago

    No, not at all. How can I give my judgment concerning a hub which I have not read? In case I am tired and bored and I didn’t read it full, I’ll leave the hub without commenting.

  6. Loladusk profile image60
    Loladuskposted 6 years ago

    I am new to Hubpages, and I have been reading so much and really enjoying it, I have read a few that I started and lost interest and I just moved on, I think that it if you make a comment it shoul be based on reading the inforation presented, thats why we are writing to be read.. I am not sure about the ones that just do this to climb ladders it seems kinda sad. there are some amazing creative people here, and they deserve genuine insight.. just sayin... Cheers!

  7. traveltoinfo profile image57
    traveltoinfoposted 6 years ago

    No, I always read them and find good information to alleviate my internet ignorance.

  8. Cameron Corniuk profile image89
    Cameron Corniukposted 6 years ago

    I don't read as many hubs as I should, but I would never consider leaving a comment without reading the article in full. I try to leave comments on the hubs that I do read in full, though. If the hub isn't interesting enough to keep my interest, why am I going to waste time on leaving a comment? Then again, noting the lack of captivation somehow in a nice, constructive way may be worthwhile to some of us.

  9. pharuk temmy t profile image37
    pharuk temmy tposted 6 years ago

    Well I don't pass comment if I didn't read hub,and if anyone does,it shouldn't be done that way, "HE who doesn't read is the same as HE who can't read at all"there is much to gain in reading!

  10. profile image50
    avelalposted 6 years ago

    Write comments just to level up is for people who do not have the slightest creative ability! sry my english, I'm from Portugal

  11. JamaGenee profile image84
    JamaGeneeposted 6 years ago

    I do sometimes, but not very often, and then only if I'm already familiar with that person's writing style or the point of the hub has been clearly spelled out in the first few paragraphs.  It's also not necessary to re-read an entire hub before leaving an additional comment in reply to one made by the author or another commenter.

  12. Lisa HW profile image72
    Lisa HWposted 6 years ago

    I don't leave comments if I haven't read the whole Hub.  In fact, I often don't leave comments if I have, because if I don't have anything to say that I think adds something to the discussion I won't add the old "good Hub" thing without anything else to say.  I generally always (unless I forget, which I don't do too often) vote a good Hub up.

    If I think I have something that might be worth saying on the person's Hub, I'll say it.  Sometimes I do longer comments, and not everyone appreciates those; but I figure they can just not-approve the comment if they don't want it on there.  Personally, I like it when someone takes the time to write a long, thought-out, comment (and contribution to the Hub).

    I think if I ran into a Hub that I'd see as great reading (but didn't feel like reading at the time) I'd probably vote it up and leave.   If people go around leaving meaningless (or close to meaningless) comments on too many Hubs, they're likely to see their score drop; because HubPages discourages that.

    In fairness to some people who make comments that make it seem they didn't read the Hub, just the other day I went back to a Hub that I had read and commented on.  It turned out I completely misinterpreted where the writer was "coming from".  I went back to see if I'd missed something when I read, and I couldn't see that I'd missed anything.  So, sometimes it can look as if a person didn't really read when, in fact, s/he did.   hmm  BUT, in that case, I think someone would see from the substance of my comment that I had missed "where the writer was coming from", rather than believe I didn't read the Hub at all.

  13. gabgirl12 profile image79
    gabgirl12posted 5 years ago

    Never, and I could comment on person's hub and not necessarily follow them. I guess I'm picky. To be honest when I comment on a hub, I usually return to that hub later on and see what the hubs author or other's have commented.

    To be honest, if a person doesn't have much to say, you can also use the feedback tool that is located just under the hub for beautiful, interesting, funny etc or encourage the hubber with fan mail. I think the comments should be reserved for what it is meant for: to be insightful and engaging.

    If I could I'd spend more time working on hubs and also the Hubpages community to build my writing skills. I think the more I build my writing skills and creative technique the more it will also influence my commenting (it already has).

 
working