Do you think it is important to comment on a hub if you have read it?
I've read that some hubber's read hubs but do not leave comments. On person said be assured I read your hubs even when I don't comment. I don't get it. I think it is courtesy to comment if you read someone's hub. Unless, of course, you see nothing to comment about. Do you comment on the hubs you read?
Yes , sure i do comment whatever i read here and the true feelings that comes from within that exactly goes out as a comment from me to be honest.
Yes it is important. Sometimes my comments are questions. it helps me understand the hub. You are also correct about it being courtesy. If authors want people to comment on their hubs, they should comment on others. But, then again, sometimes there are so many, I guess you can't comment on all of them.
I probably comment on about a third of the hubs that I read. If I do not have something constructive to say, or a question, do you feel I should just say "great hub"? What if there were factual mistakes? I read a hub yesterday and the hubber mentioned that sugar gliders were a type of rodent. A mistake like that could have been corrected easily if the material was better researched. Should I say "your hub was good but it contains factual mistakes"?
So, I have to answer this question with a question. Do you think you should comment on hubs that are poorly written, have many words misspelled, contain numerous factual errors,or contain information that you feel is wrong? Is it my place to argue with a hubber that lists the Siberian Husky as a dangerous breed, or should I just ignore him?
I don't think commenting is a matter of courtesy, though it's nice to have feedback. We can see from the stats how many people read our hubs. I comment when something is particularly interesting or engaging, but to comment on everything would be time consuming. And sometimes, there isn't a lot to say.
I do use the votes, useful, interesting etc. to show I've "been there."
Good point innerspin, we can see how our hubs are doing and how many people are reading them through the stats. But it is also very helpful to know when something you write touches someone on some level.
I agree with innerspin, I read the hubs of those I follow, but only leave comments if it is of interest, I have a questions, or can add to the content. I also vote on them, even if I don't leave a comment.
It's a personal option. Sometimes I do, something I don't. Pretend you own a store and people walk in and out every day, some comment on how lovely it is, while others won't. Whether they buy something or not, would it really bother you if they didn't comment? I think as long as they came in to visit you, that's a compliment in itself. They took the time to read it, which counts. And that says a lot. Plus some people are just shy that way.
Good perspective Rosana, The comment 'know that I am reading your hub' seems illusive.' How can we know a certain person is reading if there is no comment? I'd not considered the shy, I thought all writers love words & use them to express themsel
I agree, I think it is courteous to leave a comment unless the person really disliked the hub. Then I would hope to hear from the reader privately. I always leave a comment on a hub that I have read unless it is so bad, I simply can't find anything to comment on.
As a hubber when I publish a hub then I expect comment on my hub and several times, I check my account for that. But not from everyone who have read my hub. Because, it is duty for an author to reply those comment. If everyone who read my hub, comment on that then it will be many and then I may face difficulties to reply them all. But I think comment (discussion) is the ornament of a hub (article). That is why it is important for us to comment on a hub if we get interest from that but not mandatory.
It is always considered as courtesy to comment or to be accurate Appreciation.
I think it is important to always comment, as not only does it help that hubber, but it gets your name around too. If you offer detailed, insightful comments that is. The whole community grows based on the acts of each individual using this site, and so it definitely plays a big part in all of our success.
However, people are busy, some browse from work. If they haven't time to comment then they can't. Often you'll find that these people do quickly vote up and click a feedback link.
A hub is a hard work of a person .Be active in hub pages community by reading and leaving comments.Be happy and make others happy. read more
As with many things in life, the Golden Rule applies here: If you want feedback on your hard work, then try leaving feedback on other peoples' hard work.
by 3bagsfull 12 years ago
I just read the hub challenge that asked us to flag hubs that were poor in quality, etcso, out of curiosity I went to the Hubs section and hit latest and ....holy cwap, batman!!! there is so much junk here. It is clear that many either wrote a hub in their native language and translated it via...
by Chasuk 11 years ago
Or do you only vote a hub down because it was poorly written, or contains erroneous information?What is your criteria?
by David Livermore 8 years ago
Do you think Hubpages should take a harder stance to poorly written hubs?I hop hubs when I can, and find so many that are of poor quality. They have little to no content, or just one long text block. Don't get me started about the spelling or grammar.Should HP take more of a harder...
by KevinC9998 9 years ago
Are you always honest with your comments even if a Hub is not well written?
by Mom Kat 8 years ago
Holy cow! I've been hub hopping and looking through a few freshly written hubs today and I am blown away by the low quality!The thought hadn't even crossed my mind before now to add "flagging" to my list of things to do while hanging out at HP as part of my daily ritual. I'm...
by Peter V 9 years ago
Do you often flag content on HubPages?I see a few hubs everyday that are in English, but poorly written. I hate to flag a hub if someone is just trying to start on HP, but I don't like reading poorly written hubs! What are your thoughts?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|