How Do Hubbers Feel About Other Hubbers Sharing Their Work On Sites That Pay For Clicks?
Just wondering because a couple of times when I shared things on RedGage, I got nastygrams from other Hubbers about profiting off their work. I thought it was kind of odd since they were profiting a whole lot more than I was from any traffic to their Hubs from RedGage. They were mad that I was making them money and taking a small cut? Anyway, how do people feel about sharing Hubs on sites that pay people for clicks? I am fine with people sharing my work on these sites, because I can see the forest through the trees, and that forest has Hub views and earnings on it.
That is...bizarre, to say the least. If someone took all of my hubs and posted links of them to websites and I got the traffic, I would assume that I'm winning more than the person doing me the immense favor. That is, assuming of course, that the person is mindful of the concept of SEO and good backlinking. You don't put a sports-related hub on a blog that talks about dogs, for example.
Now, if you're copying other people's articles...then there's an issue. I've had that done to me, and it's not pleasant at all.
(I've heard that RedGage is a poor site for doing that nowadays, according to people who know more about Google than me. Apparently, Google doesn't like RedGage at all and views backlinks from there to anywhere in a particularly negative light. Might be the nature of how the site works, or something.)
Say you love my hub on "Camping with Crocodiles" so much you wanted to share it with others . I suddenly get a load of viewers - maybe make a few cents - you make a few cents from sharing it - I don't have a problem as they would know I wrote it .
I would be happy you liked it enough to share it and say Thank You !
I discovered some of my hubs on RedGage.
Took me a while to figure out why somebody would do that, then I figured out what RG was.
Feel free to post my hubs there whenever you'd like.
Feel free to share my hubs any day if it's going to get me views!
I thought it was against HP policy to submit hubs to PTC sites.....
HubPages has no authority over the general internet. If some schmuck from wherever submits my pages on a site, I can't be punished for it, and neither can they.
The wording of the question is a bit misleading. RedGage pay their contributors for views of what they submit - in this case it is a link with a short description of the page the link leads to. Nobody is paid to click the link to a Hub.
I wouldn't say to no to some back links. I would be mad if you posted the content not the link.
I didn't realize that some hubbers get mad. As long as you're sharing the link to their article and you're not copying and pasting their actually article, I don't see why anyone would get mad. I have been sharing the link to other hubbers articles on my facebook fan page and I have never had a negative response because of it. I felt like I was doing them a favor by getting their article more exposure while at the time giving them the potential to earn a few extra pennies.
I use Redgage as well. As stated by others I too welcome sharing. Perhaps Hubpages needs to put an opt out of sharing button for Hubbers to use if they don't want others to share their work.
I am pleased you brought this to the forefront, as the most views I have had on Redgage are from hubs I have linked to.
When someone from RedGage clicks on your Hub's link, does this view show up on HP? I have had over 270 views on RG but only 9 registered views. And, have you sensed that Google doesn't like RG? I'm on it and not quite sure what to make of it. Thanks
I thought Redgage was a pay per view site?
I also agree with all others that you can back link to my Hubs any time you like
I can only agree with what seems like the common sense approach here. As long as there is a link is to the original hub page, then it seems like a win-win situation without a downside. Everyone benefits. If you benefit, then fine, as long as the original writer of the page also benefits from increased viewings and increased awareness of his / her work. Feel free to share my pages if anybody wishes to - sharing in this way sounds like a good idea on the face of it.
If I am in for gaining more views it shouldn't be a problem but some hubbers may not like the idea.
I agree with most folks that if both parties are winning through this then what's the harm?
I always have seen sharing links as a positive. Maybe there is some lack of understanding of how this is a benefit, from the users that were angry with you. I write hubs hoping they are deemed worthy of reading and sharing, and I think most of us do.
Well I have no problem with people linking to my hubs from another site. It gives me more time to link theirs
Seriously, where's the harm done? And they are not losing money, what you get comes from HP's share.
I would be delighted if I got extra views because someone thought my Hubs were worth sharing.
As long as Hubs are shared in an appropriate manner and on an appropriate site, I really don't see what the problem is. Nobody is going to get rich sharing my Hubs on RedGage, so why should I begrudge them a little extra income?
Yes a backlink is good. But do we always gain from the backlink as a hubber?
The problem arises if the post on Redgage or other site outranks the Hubpages content (Rare but I've seen cases on my work where it has done so, albeit temporarily) whereby the person on Redgage might gain and it does not guarantee the hubber any further clickthrough and gain.
Link buzz is always going to be a positive to a hubber
The SEO people I know see Redgage in particular not as a negative site but that there are sites that give a lot more status to links. Plus it pays a very tiny sum so you're going to have to post serious numbers of links to make any money.
So if someone from RedGage clicks on your Hub's link, does this view show up also on HP? I have had over 270 views on RG but only 9 registered HP views. I'm on RG and not quite sure what to make of it.
GoldenThreadPress I think a lot of people just don't bother to click the links. It's something I mentioned in my Hub about RedGage because it doesn't make sense to me either.
I believe redgage scrambles the links (i think i read that somewhere) but I find that clickthrough from redgage is minimal. I think i've had about 150 page views as a result of clickthroughs from redgage over the last 18 months
I don't know why anyone would get mad. I have seen some of my hubs around he internet and as long as they have a link to my hub I'm fine with it. I did find some with the exact words to one of my hubs and when I clicked, it would go to a place selling insurance or something like that. That I didn't like and I filed DMCA complaint. Google took him down.
I LOVE IT!
Share My Stuff ..... Please!
Like you said, wehn you share my Hub, I get credit for a "read" and to some degree, I will probably get a penny or two from the other reader. That is what the whole Sharing program is about.
Not to mention the fact that your works are getting a wider audience.
I do not understand a Hubber that would not understand the Share system, or be upset.
Strictly speaking my friend you are in breach of copyright if you take the material someone publishes here and post in onto another website. If you then make money out of this it is consider criminal even.
However you can use someones work if you have their permission and you stick to any terms the person puts down.
As I said earlier, at the end of each hub, there is a "link to this page". Surely HP can disable this if a Hubber wishes their Hub not to be shared. I think calling the rest of us criminals is out of order.
It's just a link back to material someone else publishes. Not the original material or even a paraphrase of it. Just a link. No copyright issue there.
I would think the only reason to be upset about this is if you didn't understand what was going on. If posting on RedGage looks like you have posted someone else's article there, I can see how someone would be confused.
That said, I welcome anyone else to link my work wherever they like and am happy to do the same.
by Jerrico Usher 13 years ago
My new experiment:http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/8289is looking better every day, and in fact I am trying to figure out ways to help as many Huber’s as possible in this path so I decided I'm going to develop my site in a way that gives authors some link juice (and this site will get massive...
by Bible Studies 11 years ago
I got into an interesting discussion on another thread, and thought it would make a good thread itself. The question of the day is how do you feel about other hubbers clicking on an ad in your hubs?Personally I really don't see a problem with it as long as the ad interests them from a good quality...
by Shadaan Alam 9 years ago
Hello all my fellow hubbers, hope you all are fine and enjoying your work!!This is my first forum topic and i hope i am able to explain myself well here- as to what i intend to ask you all.My question is: I read somewhere on the internet that if you want to drive maximum traffic to your main...
by Carolee Samuda 10 years ago
Dear staff, is there anything that can be done to the feed where I can choose not to receive notice of hubs shared by other hubbers? There are people who share every hub they read. If I want to read a hub or follow someone I will. I don't need to see all those hubs of people I don't even know in my...
by Patricia Scott 6 years ago
Do you read hubs that are shared by hubbers who often 'share' their own hubs?Just wondering what your thoughts are ....by often I mean, several times a day or several times a week....
by Kate Swanson 11 years ago
Whether I agree with HP's new policies or not, I respect the site's right to set their own rules. However, I think one of the reasons Hubbers are getting upset isthey're getting warnings based on rules they don't know existExamples:1. I have "overly promotional" warnings on several...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|