How do you feel about a hubber making reference to their hubs in answers to questions?
Everyone wants people to read their hubs, but is there a point that you think this can be excessive?
I think it is ok if someone answers the question and also makes reference to one of his or her hubs that goes into deeper detail on the matter, but it is not ok to just link to a hub as the answer itself.
Thank you for your answer.. What if they only answer questions for which they can advertise their hubs?
I completely agree with you here Spongy0llama.
In that case, windygreen, I would agree that that is just plain bad taste. If someone only answers questions where there is an opportunity to promote him or herself, then that is a sign of more interest in personal gain than in the hubpages community
I agree spongy .. I think thats at least misuse of the Q n A forum. Thank you for answer
I just did within the past two hours or so. I never knew it was an issue to do it. So please correct me if I'm wrong.
I don't think it is an issue if its not excessive, but I wondered what others thought .
It was my intent to help the person. And I hope she got something out of it. And if it did help her then I don't care what others thought.
I think it's natural to plug one's hubs ("A Brief History of Max, Who Was A Dog") because its something they have created ("The 7 Best Internet Comedy Videos/Series of All Time") and is special to them ("Maddox Bellacole and The Child of Two Worlds: Prologue"). They should be proud of their work ("The Basic Rules of Etiquette for the First Time Karaoke Singer") and have that desire to show it to a wide audience ("Along The Shores Of Your Heart").
I suppose it can get a bit excessive though.
("No Nonsense McGuire" presents: The Infinite Tragedy of the West Memphis 3.")
I do think it can get to the point that it becomes spammy. That being said sometimes the best way to answer a question is to leave a link to a hub that as already answers the question. But the hub should legitimately answer the question and I do feel there is a need for discernment.
I don't have a problem with it as long as the Hub being referenced relates to the question's topic.
I have to admit that it bothers me. I did it once and felt like a complete self-promotional a$$. So I try to stay away from that but you do see it a lot here.
I have answered over a hundred questions and i can honestly say I have only done this twice. Each time the questions directly related to a hub I had written and I only mentioned in my response that I had actually written a hub on the topic. I didn't bother linking it because I felt that if the questioner liked my initial response and wanted to read about my thoughts and experience in detail they could go to my page and find it themselves.
I would never just link to one of my hubs as an answer to someones question though, I like to give my answers some thought and I think each question deserves an original response.
I think it's appropriate if the mention of or referral to one's hub is directly related or germane to the disccussion. As long as it's not done frequently or with a link. If a fellow hubber is intrigued by the mention or really wants to read your hub, he knows how to find your profile without the link.
If you provide a link and it has to do with the subject, there is a good chance I will click on it. I am a lot less likely to go to your profile and try to find the hub. It may border on self promotion, but if the link is relevant, it is helpful.
It comes down to relevance. If what is in their hub answers or expands on your question, I think it's fine to share. If there isn't a link or the link is tenuous, then that's spam.
Anything may be overdone. Too much water can kill. No, I don't mind a hub plug if the hub being referenced is pertinent to the question.
I note that you asked this in regard to Q&A rather than forum questions. Some might feel differently about the two.
Since Q&A permits "make a hub about it" as one way to answer a Q, it can't be completely wrong. If you've already got a hub about it, however, there's no way to connect it to that button. A direct link saves time that might otherwise be spent trying to figure out which of his hubs he intends--especially if he is somewhat expert in that area and has several similar hubs. But it's spammy to post the link without reference to which part of the hub is relevant, or in what way.
As for your follow-up Q about those who only answer Q where they can advertise their hubs: It's a subtle line. I notice procedural Q more than opinion Q and only want As from those who are subject matter experts. I hate As from people who clutter it with speculative "Good Q", "Google it", etc.
I answer many questions in Q&A because I enjoy reading the different responses and sometimes ask questions to get a broad spectrum of hubbers' opinions, occasionally using this as source material for a hub.
Sometimes I see a link yes, but this doesn't put me off IF IT'S RELEVANT TO THE QUESTION. What's really annoying is some nerd linking to their unrelated hub without any thought for those answering genuinely. This is spammy. But it is rare in my experience.
If I answer a question knowing I have a hub on the topic I sometimes mention this as I know it will help, but I don't link it, I leave it up to the questioner to seek it out.
by Mike Pugh 11 years ago
How much time should you give before rendering the 'best answer' to a Hubber?Us Hubbers now have the option to award fellow Hubbers who are very helpful at answering questions here in the Q&A section, what do you think is a fair time to give many other potential answers you may...
by Kelly Pittman 12 years ago
How do you feel about a commenter who's not a Hubber?I've noticed that a certain users "Hubtivity" is nothing but commenting on religious forums always arguing the existence of God. I know everyone is entitled to their opinions and allowed to share their own beliefs, but...
by Catherine Giordano 6 years ago
I was browsing through Owlcation yesterday and saw "Answers" was being promoted more than hubs. Previously if you clicked on "best", latest" etc,. it was all hubs. Why the change?I am a little upset that hubs are not getting enough attention in the "best",...
by Suzanne Day 9 years ago
Hi everyone,I'm just starting out in the wonderful world of Hubpages questions and answers. I've had a look through the help centre and only found a little info....basically that Q&A's are meant to be a very mini hub type thing, where you can earn the 60% for all views on your Question and...
by Billie Kelpin 9 years ago
So, I understand that the question-answer section is to inspire hubs, BUT it feels a little disingenuous to use the information everyone provided, especially when that information would fit nicely in a list. I asked a question about recipes and received lots of great replies. How do I make a...
by Heather Edgens 11 years ago
So, I kinda accidentally stumbled across this website called webanswers. I know some of you guys use it because I came back here to learn more about it, and if it actually was all that everyone was saying. I am now addicted to this site! I love it. And amazingly enough, I see earnings growing in my...
Copyright © 2024 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID
|This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.
|This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.
|HubPages Google Analytics
|HubPages Traffic Pixel
|This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.
|Amazon Web Services
|Google Hosted Libraries
|Google Custom Search
|Google AdSense Host API
|Amazon Unified Ad Marketplace
|We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.
|Conversion Tracking Pixels
|We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.
|Author Google Analytics
|Amazon Tracking Pixel