I have a question. I just did an hub which is a prose that was an interpretation of an art (say, Vango Gogh).
I think it's considered prose. I can't find anything that would make it unfeatured unless maybe it's not an article, poem, or set apart prose? Is it the nature of the hub?
Spelling and grammar is fine (it's a short hub). There isn't anything promotional. It's my own work.
Can you guys give me some insight?
(There was no reason why it was unpublished other than it didn't meet the standards. I'm not sure what to fix)
Oh. Another question in addition to that. We can post poetry and prose but not short articles.
Is the QA treeting my post as an article rather than prose/poetry if -that- is why it was unpublished?
We need to see it. Check out the rejection email - it will indicate how to get an answer: 'help from the community' or something like that.
I just got this message. I "think" it could have been too short. I can't find the rejection notice anymore. I made it into an article and it's going through QA again. If I get the same notice, I'll post it.
In general, how does the QA determine what is a prose/poem and what is considered an article?
I know I read what they look for in poetry, though I don't know if it looks for a specific format or type?
I write free verse prose mostly. I guess you can say somewhat epic? Non conventional.
If you post it into the correct category, i.e. creative writing/poetry, then it will be considered to be so. It's not the editors' job (at that point) to assess what category your writing should be in... that's your job.
I created a prose that is unconventional. It is also an interpretation of a piece of art I am intrigued with.
The "subject" is under poetry, literary arts (and so forth). It is the most appropriate place rather than business and LGBTQ issues.
Since it did not go through QA (which is fine; it's not a negative issue), does Hubpages evaluate poetry based on the type it is (free verse, acrostic, limeric)?
Since my prose is not conventional, maybe it considered it an article? I wouldn't know.
Other than it being too short and not conventional as in described above (and grammar is right and category is appropriate)
Another question about this:
If it is the category, how does QA judge whether a nonconventional poem is in poetry (which I placed it in) or in another section?
If you're not a moderator, I would like clarification from someone who is familar with the QA and has been a Hubby for a good amount of time.
I haven't been on here long; so, if there is an answer you can provide about this question or clarification, I would appreciate it. If not, what you said does not help me. (It's not constructive critism)
I answered your question as best as I could. The obvious thing that came to mind is that it may have not been placed in the right category - sometimes it's difficult to determine the correct one. And that can make a big difference as to whether an article is passed or not. That's why it's up to you to make that choice. For example, I've seen people put love poetry under the Relationship category. QAP would fail it as it's not suitable for that section of HP.
The QAP people are unable to place the work into the right category initially, but later a piece can be transferred to a network site, such as Letterpile.
You asked how QAP determines the type of work an article is, but, as no-one here is part of QAP we can't tell you what the criteria is.
How could I offer constructive criticism if I can't see the piece?
Sorry I couldn't help you.
Thanks. Yeah. Your tone was off. Stressful day I suppose. I think it's because it was too short. Maybe concerned as an article since it doesn't "look" poetic. I did put an article too it but it said it is low quality. I figured so since I just put it together. I don't think it's the article, though. I'd have to write another same type of poem and see. I can't find any category that matched poetry unless it's under literature. Who knows. I'd have to play with it a bit.
It didn't meet feature requirements. Is there anything that Hubbers can refer to, to correct our hubs?
The QA has a lot of information; and, I can't guess what is wrong with it.
It is hard to correct articles when there is no information about "exactly" what was wrong. I'm not earning money or anything; but, it would be more benefitial to be on this site if I can improve my articles as well as write them.
Then you have to fix it to make it meet the requirements to be featured. Try looking at Letterpile.com. That is the niche site where poetry and creative writing will go if the article or piece is featured and you can get it past the QA.
I have done the best I can with the article. This question I asked before I created an article with the poetry since I thought it was too short or not the "right" type of poetry. I was wrong.
I cannot read all the work on other sites. Is there something specific that is used for poetry (I have read the QA) to where I can compare my Hub with -and- know what to correct and worth my posts without guessing?
Does HubPages require poetry/prose to be conventional format?
Most poetry/prose goes to LetterPile unless the description or summary of the poem is riddled with mistakes. It's hard to have a poem that is "too short." If you post a link to the article in question here, we can further investigate.
I did unpublished it. I was thinking it was more unconventional since it doesn't rhyme and it's closer to free verse than anything else. I'd be surprise if there is an spelling or grammar error that wasn't intended as part of the poem itself.
After it was not featured I wrote an article with it and thought that may be the problem. The article wasn't published. I can understand if the article isn't published since my intention was just the poem. Though, I'm not sure if I want to work on the article more if it is the poem that's throwing it off and not anything else.
I haven't seen any prose written as a response to a painting before; so, maybe it's too unique. I don't know. I would have to publish it to give you the link.
Her tone was fine, your tone was off. The bottom line is, your work has to be easily understood by the readers. It can be as unconventional as the law allows, but the average reader has to be able look at the hub and know what it is.
This can often be achieved quite simply, for example by adding an introductory sentence or two that might say something like: the following is a prose-poem inspired by xxx that I wrote to express xxxx. If the editor has to guess what you are trying to do they will probably not feature the piece.
I have a few other hubs; so, it's not the title, spelling, category, or anything specific like that. It sounds like either it's too short, not conventional (it's a response to a artwork rather than a stand alone poem), or it wasn't appropriate to HubPages.
I don't know another way to rephrase the question. It's too short for HubPages -and- myself to see anything wrong with it in and of itself. I just don't have enough information on whether it is appropriate. I can't fix anything; it's only, I think, five lines. Poetry isn't like articles just as long as it flows and make sense (etc) it just depends on the preference of the person reading it rather than the poem itself.
I would write more since I'm more of a poet than an article writer; but, I'm at a loss. The other niche sites like the Literary one so far I read doesn't have prose like I wrote. Another, I don't think many write prose in response to something. It usually stands on its own. That could also be it.
I don't know. I'm just guessing.
Sam, thank you. I'll send it to you. The article didn't get approved; so, I know I have to redo that so I'll just send the poem.
...Oh. How do I send a private email?
by Paula Atwell 4 years ago
I just want to make sure I am clear on the transition information. My stuff transferred overnight, so that means that I have 4 months to clear up skulls etc before the hubs get moderated, correct?I am going to have to completely revamp quite a few former lenses due to the fact that much of my...
by NotPC 4 years ago
HubPages is very firm in their rule to only use photos for which you have permission to use. Hypothetically, what happens if you break this rule? I've seen many people using images that are clearly not theirs to use and I was just wondering if this affects them in any way...
by Lisa HW 3 years ago
(Maybe the answers to my questions is somewhere on HP; but even if any answers are out there on the site; so many changes have been made in seven-and-a-half years, I wanted to get the absolute latest with regard the questions below):1. If one unpublishes a Hub and just...
by Liz Elias 8 years ago
What the heck? I just published a new poem, for which I had no pictures of my own.I did a search for public domain images, found one, placed it into a photo capsule, and, to protect myself, put in the source URL.I then saved the edits, and got this message:" This hub is too short to...
by Sheila Craan 7 months ago
Lately, I have had 11 hubs unfeatured due to Quality Issues. I have assured my hubs do not contain grammatical or spelling errors. I have included relevant video and changed the titles and added new supporting texts and all this to no avail. The HubPages Staff continues to deem my hubs do not...
by Kelley Eidem 2 years ago
Every time one of my pages is updated it gets turned off for public viewing!?!? For example - please keep in mind that this is but one example out of many! - a change to the comment section either allowing or shutting down comments results in the page being taken down for a period of...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|