jump to last post 1-16 of 16 discussions (24 posts)

I have been plagerized on Hub Pages

  1. akeejaho profile image60
    akeejahoposted 9 years ago

    I am kinda flattered, but mad as a wet hornet.  Has anyone here ever heard of barryrutherford?  Well, compare his Hub, Bipolar,more on this subject, and
    So, whats wrong with being bipolar?  I mean, good grief!  And this guys profile says he has studied law.  (Studied, but dosen't understand it evedently

  2. Lissie profile image78
    Lissieposted 9 years ago

    I flagged his - you should 2 -  he'll get banned soon

  3. Mark Knowles profile image60
    Mark Knowlesposted 9 years ago

    I flagged it also. I think you can safely say good bye to Barry smile

    How dumb can you get? I mean, really ! Copying a hub and pasting it at hubpages lol What a waste of time.

  4. dayzeebee profile image80
    dayzeebeeposted 9 years ago

    i flagged it now too. hope everything turns out well.

  5. rmr profile image85
    rmrposted 9 years ago


  6. terenceyap07 profile image59
    terenceyap07posted 9 years ago

    I've flagged him, too. Be at ease, my friend. Everything is going to be alright.

  7. akeejaho profile image60
    akeejahoposted 9 years ago

    Thank you all for your support, comments and actions.  I too flagged the article,but I was soflustered I did not write to Hub as per their instructions, yet. 

    Wow!  What a community I have found.  Thanks too you all once again.
    I checked out his other Hubs but didn't see anything else that was as flagrant as the one he took from me.  I hope no one else has been victimized.  (I feel so exposed!)  LOL
    I also contacted him through E-Mail. 
    Tootles to Barry!  Hubbers Unite!

    1. profile image0
      daflaposted 9 years agoin reply to this

      You can use copyscape.com to find plagiarized hubs.  It finds duplicate content. It's common now for people overseas to plagiarize, knowing that nobody is going to pursue legal action overseas for one post.

      I wish there was some way people could get together as a group and get a lawyer to represent them for overseas cases.  There is one person who has about 10 websites from China where all they do is copy and paste English blog posts. 

      One way to protect yourself is to put a signature line in all of your hubs, or to link back to a page somewhere that says "If you are not reading this at xxxx.com (url of your post), this article is plagiarized.  Please contact me (give contact link) to report it. Thank you."

      Those that copy and paste will not even know it's in there, and they will get caught.  When someone contacts you, write to the site's domain provider and they will usually pull the site.

      1. Shirley Anderson profile image76
        Shirley Andersonposted 9 years agoin reply to this

        Shane's right!  This is incredibly awesome advice, thx!!

      2. akeejaho profile image60
        akeejahoposted 9 years agoin reply to this

        Thanks so much for that information.  Great advice, and I will check that Web site

  8. crashcromwell profile image75
    crashcromwellposted 9 years ago

    That is awesome advice dafla!

  9. amy jane profile image82
    amy janeposted 9 years ago

    I flagged it too...I hope it gets taken care of soon. smile

    1. profile image0
      SirDentposted 9 years agoin reply to this

      Ditto. . . !!!!!!!

  10. profile image0
    daflaposted 9 years ago

    I tried searching some of his other content on Google, and it's not even indexed.  Surprisingly, his   plagiarized hub is indexed for the content, and yours isn't.  Strange, because yours was published first, and his should have been flagged by Google as duplicate content.  You can write to Google about this, and they may (never can tell with Google) remove him from the index and put you in, and if they find plagiarism, they will put all of his future postings anywhere online into a sandbox (a place where no one can see them).

    You can also file a DMCA complaint with his ISP, and they may cancel his account.  You can find info on how to do that here:


  11. Marian Swift profile image65
    Marian Swiftposted 9 years ago

    Flagged and thumbed.

    Thank you, Dafla, for your warning -- I had no idea that copy mills existed -- and for your great advice!

  12. SweetiePie profile image83
    SweetiePieposted 9 years ago

    Unfortunatley this is not the first time I have seen plagiarism here at Hubpages.  There is one person who pretends to be two different people, and one profile copies news articles from British websites and pastes these into the Hubs.  Sadly, plagiarism happens, so I just report it and give the moderator the link where I found the copied content.

  13. Shadesbreath profile image85
    Shadesbreathposted 9 years ago

    I tried that copyscape.com out, but it doesn't matter what I type in it always says I've "exceeded my ten searches"

    1. profile image0
      daflaposted 9 years agoin reply to this

      It's blocked Hubpages for some reason.  I can scan other sites, but not Hubpages.

      1. pauldeeds profile image
        pauldeedsposted 9 years agoin reply to this

        They only give 10 free searches in each domain, each month.  For hubpages.com those get used up pretty fast.  You can buy more searches for 5 cents each by signing up for copyscape premium.

        1. profile image0
          daflaposted 9 years agoin reply to this

          I guess they'd have to do that, or places like this would use up a lot of bandwidth!  It might be worth paying for a premium membership if you are a serious web writer.

          I was surprised that a lot of the copy I tried to Google wasn't even indexed.

  14. ProCW profile image83
    ProCWposted 9 years ago

    Hate to have to add my two cents... sad

    I've come across hubs that are duplicate - verbatim - word-for-word copies from other pages off of the net as well.

    I've searched (with quotes) on google and found that the hubs were published after the original article. I've flagged the hubs that I've come across and sadly... nothing was done. I don't know if HP is overwhelmed or something, but it really is wrong to have duplicate content here.

    Whether or not the hubber has been here for a month, a year... 2 years... get over it and get rid of them.

    ATTN: Plagiarists. I'm telling you now... regardless of your location (in or out of the USA,) I will file a lawsuit if you plagiarize any of my work. I will win. You will lose. You will pay hefty fines. You will go to jail.

    It really isn't that difficult to create original work. You can even base your work on something else, however it is morally and ethically wrong (not to mention illegal) to copy someone else's work.

    You need quotes if you're quoting the author. You need a link if you're using their RSS feed(s). (Regarding RSS... I've checked up on it... unless the original author provides a creative commons or similar license in the original work, it is illegal to duplicate or "re-mix" the content fully, without prior consent of the copyright holder.)

    I'm thinking of starting a online writer's guild to help combat plagiarists.


    1. SweetiePie profile image83
      SweetiePieposted 9 years agoin reply to this

      ProCW, you know I think you always give great advice and ideas, but I just wanted to say other countries do not always abide by the same copyright laws as the US, so their is no guarantee that a plagiarist would go to jail for their crime or even be prosecuted.  It all depends on the laws of the country.  Of course I hate plagiarism as much as you, but unfortunately we may not be able to control all of it on the Internet.  Do google searches to ensure your work is not being copied will help to curb plagiarism.

  15. pauldeeds profile image
    pauldeedsposted 9 years ago

    This has been discussed several times before, but just because something has been copied it doesn't necessarily mean that the rights holder didn't give permission.    We don't remove hubs just because they are duplicated, we remove hubs when a DMCA complaint has been filed.   When we identify duplicate content it simply means that the HubScore will be reduced for that hub (and when chronic, for that author).

    So, I'd encourage you to not just flag the hub on HubPages as a duplicate, but to contact whomever you think is content owner and give them a link to the hub and instructions for filing a complaint.  When we receive a valid DMCA complaint, the hub will be removed (typically within hours).  Serious or repeated violations will result in the author being banned.

  16. akeejaho profile image60
    akeejahoposted 9 years ago

    I hardly know where to begin.  Thanks for all the advice and help from you all.  I will be lodging a formal complaint when I get out of forum.  This is the first opportunity since I got home from work to get on the ol puter!

    About the Writer's guild, well, whatrthedues?  I'll sign up!

    I do know I will be reading the Hubs a little closer and I will contact any author if I ever see an article I even suspect has been fivefingered, borrowed, stolen or just plain plagiarized or other wise not belonging to the dude,(dudet) who's name appears on it. 

    Procw, I couldn't have said it any better myself.  My Hubs hold my blood sweat and tears, and having them plundered by the boob down under just burns my butt.  So, what you said, Ditto.  (That isn't plagiarizm, is it?)

    But, I will say it is oddly flattering that someone felt I had something important enough to say that they wanted to take it as their own.  (Now if that ain't perverse, I don't know what is!)  And the thing is, I didn't even think the Hub was all that good!  (But don't tell anyone!)