jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (16 posts)

Black Slaves Were......Immigrants

  1. gmwilliams profile image85
    gmwilliamsposted 9 months ago

    https://usercontent1.hubstatic.com/8415868.jpg
    Dr. Ben Carson, Secretary of HUD, indicated that Blacks in America weren't slaves at all but immigrants like other immigrants who worked for less.  Dr. Carson maintained that other immigrants endured the same harsh treatment in America as Blacks did.  According to Dr. Carson, Blacks in America didn't have a monopoly on being mistreated.  Your thoughts?

    1. wilderness profile image99
      wildernessposted 9 months agoin reply to this

      As immigrants become citizens of the country immigrated to, I'd have to say that Carson is trying to make a political statement rather than a factual one.

      Also not real sure how anyone could have less "earnings" than beatings, rape and forced family separations through being sold to new owners.

      1. GA Anderson profile image82
        GA Andersonposted 9 months agoin reply to this

        I don't think it was the non-slave "immigrants" that he was referring to that earned less. As I listened to his talk, it was the other way around. He spoke of the immigrants that came through Ellis Island first, and how hard they worked and how little they earned. Then, he went on to the part about those that came over in the bottom of slave boats that worked even harder and earned even less.

        Although poorly stated, and I am not sure I can go along with calling slaves immigrants - he did have the work and earnings parts right.

        I am not sure it was a political statement either. In the parts of his talk leading up to the controversial segment, and in that segment too - he was referring to the American dream of the opportunity for all to make a better life for themselves and their children, but he mostly focused on the working hard for their children part.

        Youtube has the full 35 minute talk to his deptment's employees.

        GA

        1. wilderness profile image99
          wildernessposted 9 months agoin reply to this

          Well, that explains the earnings, anyway.  But I'm not sure at all about the opportunity for slaves to make a better life for them and their children; outside of a few runaways there was only one small period in time where that was possible vs hundreds of years of slavery.

          1. GA Anderson profile image82
            GA Andersonposted 9 months agoin reply to this

            Hey bud, I get your point, and I agree. Dr. Carson strikes me, (only through his public exposures), as a sincere and honest guy with a lot of personal integrity. But he sure seems to have a problem articulating some of his beliefs. (and for some of his more controversial ones, he should refrain from even trying)

            GA

            1. ahorseback profile image81
              ahorsebackposted 9 months agoin reply to this

              Actually Dr. Carson has qualities that are truly rarer  than ever in America , He's polite , a nice guy ,   His level of intelligence is above and beyond most of us "on the streets ",    It would be great if all leaders had his  presentation . He just doesn't  fit the  Face Book mentality of most of you .

              1. GA Anderson profile image82
                GA Andersonposted 9 months agoin reply to this

                Well damn ahorseback, still lumping me into a group are you? A leftist 'snowflake' one at that.

                I have not disparaged Dr. Carson. I spoke highly of him. But I did say there were caveats to my opinion. (a choice that doesn't seem to occur to you)

                Explain to me how your view of his superior intelligence accepts his belief that Joseph built the pyramids for grain storage.

                GA

    2. Live to Learn profile image79
      Live to Learnposted 9 months agoin reply to this

      I admire Dr. Carson for this. Although I wouldn't argue against Wilderness' points I think what he is attempting to say is a valid point. All faced adversity. Of one kind or another.

    3. ahorseback profile image81
      ahorsebackposted 9 months agoin reply to this

      No , Dr, Carson   didn't say  " blacks weren't slaves at all ",  it is inferred  from his whole speech by those who've made "slavery "  the most populist , hate primed ,message of the modern day times ,    To have especially a black man discuss history of all  immigration and NOT call out slavery as the number one immigration issue ------TODAY ?  OMG .  I'm sure Dr. Carson  knows his history and probably  far better than most today !  His version simply doesn't fit todays alarmist style.

      He's just brilliant  enough to know all of it Gm. Williams , not just todays "version"  !

    4. Credence2 profile image81
      Credence2posted 9 months agoin reply to this

      Slaves are not 'immigrants' in the classic sense. I don't know why Dr. Carson said that?

      It reflects on the Trump administration to put a neurosurgeon with absolutely no experience in the knowledge of the Department he has been placed in charge of. Conservatives always complain about the concept of quotas and tokens. Are we returning back to a spoils system away from one based on merit? It says a lot about what Trump actually thinks about Carson and the Department for which he is now the head.

  2. ahorseback profile image81
    ahorsebackposted 9 months ago

    As Pres. Obama also called slaves immigrants of the past ;  Is it fair to only single out Dr.Carson ?   
    Being a little partisan are we ?

    1. crankalicious profile image92
      crankaliciousposted 9 months agoin reply to this

      I'm not a Ben Carson fan, but I think this thing is being blow out of proportion. President Obama made a similar point - basically that coming from another country presents shared challenges. They both attempted to use slaves as an example, but with caveats. Carson isn't a professional public speaker and just didn't articulate the point quite as well as he could have.

      1. GA Anderson profile image82
        GA Andersonposted 9 months agoin reply to this

        I certainly agree with you it is being blown out of proportion. When his full address is viewed, it is clear that he was making a point about sacrifices good folks were willing to make for "The American Dream."

        I think it is that he is a Republican, a Trump supporter, and part of Pres. Trump's administration that he is being attacked for his remarks. While I agree that he didn't do so well making his point, only someone primed for attack would jump on this issue.

        GA

  3. Paul Wingert profile image79
    Paul Wingertposted 9 months ago

    https://usercontent1.hubstatic.com/13442296.jpg

    1. ahorseback profile image81
      ahorsebackposted 9 months agoin reply to this

      There you go again , One more liberal  label , Dr. Carson's   Insane ,  call out a label -win the debate every time ?

  4. ahorseback profile image81
    ahorsebackposted 9 months ago

    I didn't get this at first ,No wonder Blacks are enraged ,  It took a constitutional amendment to legitimize Black slaves U.S.  citizenship  - and illegals are allowed to simply steal theirs ?
    Think about that .

 
working