American student Amanda Knox was found guilty of murder in Italy and sentenced to 26 years in prison.
will she be in an Italian prison or in America?
i have to wonder what kind of "sex game" involves throat-slitting.
I do believe Italy . . freaks me out a little tonight. . my daughter is in Milano as a student this semester. .so happy she is coming home next week!
Speaking from France, people in Europe were kind of freaked out at the idea of a young American killing a flatmate and falsely accusing an innocent bar owner and father of four. I have no more idea than anyone else what happened that night but there's been talk of the Italians being anti-American and that just wasn't a factor here really. They also jailed an African and an Italian, so nationality doesn't come into it.
Your daughter's biggest risk in Milan, frankly, is getting into debt in the clothes shops!
oh no. I just read a book about the guy who prosecuted her and what a terrible man he is. He is under indictment himself.
I honestly don't know if she's guilty or not, but the process that was followed was quite bad.
She will be in an Italian jail.
and from what I heard her sentence is quite excessive....I pray for her and her parents...what a nightmare.
it will be appealed~ the prosecution is shoddy with no real dna evidence that proves beyond reasonable doubt. she is sentenced to 25 years, which in Italy is a life sentence and both her and the Italian guy are fined over a million dollars. he was sentenced to 25 years. at least in america, you're innocent until proven guilty. over there you're guilty until proven innocent. we're going to be hearing alot about this one.
Sorry but thats just not true, at least not since 1989. Italy has been following an American model since that year and is similar to most central European court systems, Italy is well known to breed some of the worlds best lawyers these days.... although I do believe that her conviction is weak. The appeal system will win through.....
it was a sarcastic statement, Ryan. I wasn't stating a fact.
this particular prosecution sounds sloppy, prejudiced. I'm not saying they're innocent, I don't know, but if guilty, there has to be evidence proven beyond any reasonable doubt.
I have to say that the conviction of Knox does sound weak, but she has the right to appeal. It reminds we of the Louise Woodward case, us Brits were slamming the American legal system then, and she spent time in jail as an innocent! It happens in every country.....
Do you think 26 years in jail for slitting a woman's throat is excessive if she is guilty? I wonder if Meredith Kercher's parents think so.
I was surprised to hear a life sentence is 26 years. 26 years is a light sentence for committing murder.
Pretty much the same in the UK. If the criminal is adjudged to remain a significant threat to society at the end of their sentence they can be held indefinitely by the state; I suspect it is the same in Italy.
If a person is capable of slitting someone's throat in a 'sex game' should they ever be re-inflicted on society?
Forgive me if I am wrong, but surely we all know that Knox did not physically slit the throat of Kercher? There are plently of examples of rehabilitated criminals, the killers of Jamie Bulger have been on the loose for years and haven't reoffended. The alternative is the death penalty, so we can see innocent people put to death on national television like America? No thanks.
Which particular bit would you like me to clarify?
When did you ever see an execution on national television in the US? Leaving aside the 'innocent' bit for now...
Two thirds of Americans support television executions, and for every seven people put to death, one is exonerated. With statistics like that, I would be first to volunteer to test the chair if they introduced it to this country.
If she took the other girl's life in such a brutal manner, then the sentence is not excessive.
I was in Rome for a few days in March and it was all over the place then. I don't know, but I think karma is working all the way around. If Knox is guilty (likely that she is) and the prosecution is corrupt, they are probably all getting what they brought on to themselves. Don't mean to be heartless, but what happened was pure torture as well as murder.
I've been following this and I also do not know if she is guilty of the crime. 26 years is a long time, I'm glad her parents are by her side. What happened to the boyfriend? Did he go on trial yet? I saw that a 2nd guy was also convicted and got 20 something years, but it wasn't Amandas boyfriend. I truely hope the young lady who was murdered is getting her true justice and some crazed person isn't getting away with murder. In any case alot of lives have been ruined.
I believe the boyfriend got 25 years - at least according to my husband.
Especially the person who was murdered...
Are you nuts? We should all be concerned with the convicted murderer! Why worry about those pesky victims always wanting justice.
I think it was Amandas roomate was a girl that was murdered. . either way so many lives ruined .. a tragedy all around
Her boyfriend got 25 years . I find it a little odd that they found no DNA evidence of her in her roomates bedroom .
Some of the American reporting in this case is a little biased, such as the sensationalism about how the Italian legal system is just not as fair as that of the US. I am not Italian, but if I were I might be irritated to hear all those reports. I am not taking sides in this case, but so much of the reporting is playing upon the poor American stuck in the Italian legal system. What about the poor girl that was murdered, she will never breath again. Amanda and her boyfriend received lighter sentences than they would have in a US court, and let us remember Italy does not have the death penalty.
From what I've read there were lots of questions about her bahavior and it didn't look good. However prosecutorial misconduct regarding the evidence is a big possibility in this case. Other Americans who have dealt with this guy say he's crazy and incredibly unfair. I'm sorry I can't for the life of me remember the title of the book I just read about him. It was a library book so it's not lying around the house. (It was a major US author who ended up being interrogated by him and feared for his life. Maybe he was just trying to sell books though.)
Okday library to the rescue the author was Douglas Preston and the book was the Monster of Florence. Preston was there writing a murder mystery set in Florence when his run in with the prosecutor happened.
Yes the prosecutor sounds corrupt, but there is still a slant to the US reporting. It is plain as day really.
I saw a news snippet the other day and the reporter (American) was all sympathetic and actually said aloud, "She doesn't look like a killer." Really? What does a killer look like?
Ted Bundy didn't look like a killer. Scott Peterson didn't look like a killer. Any number of people who are guilty as hell don't "look" like they would be capable of the crime.
I must say it does seem like the American media are playing this up as an "innocents locked up abroad" story. So I guess the moral is don't go to Europe to study so you won't be tempted to kill your roommate. Wasn't sure if adding a smiley to the end of this would make it more obvious I'm being totally sarcastic. Those of you who know me know I am.... MM
It's about time.
The fact that the trial went on this long is just a side-effect of the Italian process... everything in Italy is slow. In my opinion, she is clearly guilty and deserved more than what she got. All the American articles I read about it seemed to make her seem not that bad, yet the evidence in her defence was basically non-existent. As is it, if the Italian justice system works as it usually does, 26 years will become 10, for a person who slit the throat of an innocent university student. I was disgusted to see 'Free Amanda Knox' facebook groups...
I watched a criminal psychologist who had studied Amanda Knox's diaries (the ones she wrote while in prison on remand)being interviewed on Sky News International this morning.
He didn't have a lot of good to say about her, describing how self-obsessed she was among other things.
His best quote has got to be when he described her as a 'gap-year Rose West'.
If you don't remember Rose West, and what she and her husband Fred weres convicted of, its here:
She's an American; she was convicted before she ever made it to court.
It has nothing to do with American or Italian. Three were found guilty, an Italian, American and a man from the Ivory Coast. The trial has been going on for over a year, and she's guilty as hell. Her alibi was (originally, before she changed her story about 3 times) she was too high on marijuana to remember exactly what happened...
She's guilty because she was found to be guilty; never mind that the evidence was spotty at best.
It's one thing to see a case play itseld out, but it's another to know beforehand the verdict. I'm not disputing that she's guilty: the court said as much. I just say that it is difficult to have an unfettered case when it gets so much publicity.
The case got huge coverage here in Europe too; that is why I think the court will have come to their decision based on the evidence very carefully. The eyes of the world were on them.
She will appeal, but she has now been found guilty and that is it.
There is NO anti-American sentiments being expressed by the Euroean media.
My sympathies lie with the family of Meredith Kercher.
However the path to her demise, I wholeheartedly agree with you. No parents should ever have to bury their child; and to a senseless tragedy no less.
Izzt on that one I have to agree . With the focus on Amanda Knox I think people forgot there was a victim here !
It will be interesting to see if the US population creates a backlash against Italy through social media. It can be very powerful if there are significant numbers that think she was convicted unjustly. Travel ban, cancel college years abroad, pressure on politicians.
I'm not clear if you are advocating such action, or just saying it will be 'interesting'?
Over a single murder? If this same story had happened in the US she would've been behind bars for life months ago... now just because it's abroad, Americans think they are being done an unjustice.
And why on earth would they do that? I bet that Italy spends more money on American products then Americans spend on Italian products. Any travel ban or unfair tariffs or quotas placed upon trade with Italy for no reason whatsoever would be a disaster for America. Italy are a key member of the EU, could you afford to alienate the entire continent of Europe? France? Germany? UK? You owe money to those countries for a start. Any bans on Italian goods or services for something so petty and insignificant would 1) not happen as Obama isnt a twat like you, 2) would bankrupt your country and alientate your closest alloes if it did. It is the minority like you that make Americans look like the morons of the world.
I'll start by saying that I'll thank you for not making blanket comments like that about my country. Do you think anything productive will come from that kind of provocation?
Second, any 'trade war' with Italy would be felt very little if at all in the US economy. France, Germany, et. al. would not sacrifice their own economies for Italy if push came to shove.
Finally, calling someone a "twat" will only guarantee that this thread degenerates into nothing but personal bickering. You can do better.
you do the crime, you do the time..simply put and all criminals will eventually do their time by someones hands...you never will get away from the skeletons in your closet forever
by karl 7 years ago
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article … trial.htmlSurely if she knows she is innocent the she should go back and prove it?
by IzzyM 9 years ago
Amanda Knox has been freed by the court of appeal. I am tempted to think money talks. Your opinion?
by BillWest165 9 years ago
Even after the evidence in the case was completely discredited. Most British and Italian people including the victims family continue to believe the bizarre "sex orgy" theory concocted by the corrupt italian prosecutor. I think Amanda was just a surrogate for the United States. And...
by Erin Lee 7 years ago
Should Amanda Knox be retried?
by Jonathan Janco 11 years ago
Is anyone familiar with this story? An American college student accused of murdering her roommate in Italy. She has so far been held for two years. The prosecution practically admits they have no case. They also more or less admit they are only still pursuing this case (they have convicted someone...
by TruthDebater 10 years ago
How does a government and society expect people to value all life including themselves and each other, while at the same time, the government can influence and enforce the death penalty and abortion? If people see abortion and "DP" as justified when someone is inconvenienced or found...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|