Is it racist to have a concern about immigration?
A few of our left wing buddies start shouting about people being a racist when they show a concern about the levels of immigration.
Is immigration a question of race or a question of numbers?
People can be against immigration for any number of reasons, and yes, some people are against it because they are racist. However, not everyone that is against immigration is a racist. A silly notion, at best.
In my opinion many of the issues related to immigration aren't racist, but ignorance. Some are just plain racist, and some are genuine concerns. Our country (USA) was founded on immigration, founded on coming in and taking over a land that didn't belong to us. Yet now everyone ones to throw their hands up and say we need to stop it. I hear the ignorant phrase all the time that "they're taking all our jobs". A very untrue statement. Then I hear those that really want everyone to be able to come here, but believe it should be done by the long drawn out process of these people learning everything about the USA. My question to those people is did the immigrants who founded this country bother respecting the people who lived here before them? We also have those who believe immigrants have no desire to become Americans. I am 1/4 Honduran and 1/4 Mexican. I grew up in a home where speaking English was the only option. Even though I am Hispanic I speak only English. So again those who say this speak in ignorance because it is not always like this. Some are just plain racist. Living in the south of this country I see it all the time. I hear both black and whites talking badly about Hispanics. So to answer your question, Yes sometimes it is racist.
I completely agree. I also think demonizing immigrants is a way to take attention off of other people plundering this countries wealth, but that's another subject.
Everybody should be concerned about immigration, the more that come the more diluted the
resources become. Believe me its happening now in the UK.
The idea that it's racist to be concerned about immigration is a pathetic, weak attempt to discredit those who are for securing the border. Those on the "left" often use highly emotional "arguments," which are usually unsupported by the facts. Any strength that America has left is not due to multiculturalism, but rather the things that make us the same. If some people feel the need to call me a racist because I am more concerned with the facts than mere emotion, why should I care? They are just demonstrating how ignorant they are.
You say "immigration" but don't specify whether it's the legal or illegal sort. I personally believe immigration is wonderful. I must also admit my wife was an immigrant so I'm biased, I suppose. I also believe the US makes it very difficult on most immigrants trying to get to the US. As for immigration of the illegal sort, I try to put myself in the immigrant's shoes: if I were in that desperate situation, what would I do to help my family? What would anyone do? It's easy to cast stones if you've never been faced with the situation before. Having said this, I DO understand it is illegal.... but I believe the US should take steps to make the pathway to citizenship a level playing field.
As to the question: if a person is against any form of immigration at all, I would label that borderline racism at the very least. Why prevent someone from entering the country?
I agree with what you said. But the last question - well, preventing "risk" immigrants or visitors, for that matter, I am against. The FBI knows who the risks are and yet, they are allowed in. I'm NOT for that.
Totally true. Since my wife went through the visa and citizenship process, I know for a fact the most important factor is whether you have the cash or not.
I don't think being concerned about immigration means you're racist. There are many socioeconomic factors that are tied up with an increased number of illegal immigrants. However the debate seems focused exclusively around Mexican immigrants. It's true that the U.S./Mexico border is where the bulk of illegal immigration comes from, but would anyone even notice if a Canadian was here illegally? A U.S. citizen, of Mexican descent, will still get pulled over for looking suspicious. And they will still get told to 'go back to their country' despite being completely legal. So then, the push back against immigrants goes largely based on the color of one's skin, which is a racist way of thinking. So, while I'm certain that not all immigration supporters are racist, I do hope that they at least acknowledge that the debate is negatively effecting all people of Mexican descent, even the ones born and raised in the U.S.A.
One can be a racist and have that be a determining factor. But it's unfair to characterize anyone with such a concern as racist. There are numerous reasons to be concerned about immigration. They can be concerns related to national security, social entitlement spending, labor markets and various other issues. It's just an easy copout to call someone a racist because they disagree with your position. Unfortunately many on the left like to frame everything around some discussion about discrimination based on race or ethnicity when often times it has nothing to do with it. That's what sells. And if I stand in the street and scream racist while I point my finger at you, as long as I do it for awhile...some people will believe it, whether it's true or not.
I don't think we can say that racism is the primary reason some are anti-immigration. Though in many cases it may be true. I believe that the reason is more related to fear, closed mindednes and not being able to love their neighbors as themselves.
Or maybe some of us are concerned with the enormous fiscal burden being placed on our entitlement structure that is already racing towards insolvency.
I love my neighbours but that doesn't mean they have to live in my back garden and partake of my fruits.
Yeah, but apparently some of the clowns in DC feel differently. They love to spend other peoples money.
I know there's limited space here and it's hard to fully comment. I don't quite understand the last 2 comments though. What do they have to do w/ immigration? For instance, more Americans are sucking the economy dry than immigrants. Just clarify plz.
The border states are overrun with people utilizing social services such has Medicaid. They are a huge drain on State and Federal Budgets. Particularly Mexico which has a very poor totalization agreement with the US on Social Security.
Johnsonrallen, if your children were sucking you dry that would be OK right? What about if your neighbours children were sucking you dry too and your children where then going without because of it?
I understand your point, Silverspeeder. I think it can apply just as much to Americans though. I think there are more "born and raised here" Americans that we're taking care of than immigrants.
Answer - Only if your concern is based on race.
If it is based on any other criteria, then it is simply a standard concern.
There are 2 types of immigration, the legal kind and the illegal.
Both have generated chaotic pitfalls for a nations citizens through numbers.
Left wing liberals always shout racist when speaking against concerned citizens because it sparks an emotional thread within others. The left wing always uses the most emotional categorizations because they have little truth on their side when speaking or confronting opposition.
Immigration is not about emotion, but about objective. If a nation does not need immigrants to sustain itself, then the objective should be to limit the numbers.
Pure and simple, immigration to the left wing is an emotional ride, while to the right wing, it is an objective to be defined.
Immigration has noting to do with any particular race. Since 9/11 our main concern should be about terrorist entering our borders. We are much too trusting and leave our own people in danger because of our worries of being called a racist or other names. Visitors have always been welcome in most countries, but respectful introductions are needed to keep our families safe.
.This is the whole reason for passports and/or proper identification..
Some ignorant arguments against immigrants are racists, but most are xenophobic.
Sometimes statements by the media make my blood boil.
After 9/11 they screamed "racial profiling" if someone was obviously Middle Eastern got searched at an airport. Excuse me?
If a red-headed robber goes into a bank and kills some people and goes on the run and the cops stop cars that have redheads in them, that's racial profiling? Peleeasee!
I'm not a racist. But I feel NO pressure at all to be "politically correct"
If you are in this country and you are bringing hatred and crime with you, you should be ejected faster than a nanosecond.
If they got the robber, but they keep stopping every "redhead in a car", then is profiling. You have obvious prejudice against them. Being middle eastern does not mean "hate and crime".
No. I am not prejudice. But there are large cells of terrorists in the Middle Eastern culture. Therefore they have not been all caught.
Immigration is a question of numbers. One fears to bring immigration into a conversation because one is afraid of being called a racist. It pains me to say it but we all preface any mention of immigration by saying; 'I'm not a racist but....' Why should this be?
In every country there is so much work available to the population, that's clear and obvious. Should a country allow more immigration than is tolerable then strife will follow.
in my opinion it's a question of numbers. I personally don't want a bunch of immigrants in America because they take up jobs that my relatives and myself could be using. I definitely don't support illegal immigration from anywhere (mexico, canada, etc.).
as citizens of this country it is important to stay aware of what is going on in our country, and it is only natural to be concerned. to show concern does not mean you are. racist. it means you care. my only issue with immigration is in regards to illegal immigration, from any country.
by Ronnie wrenchBiscuit 5 years ago
I have seen a lot of posts made of late against the so-called illegal immigrants from south of the border. I have also heard a lot of smack about how we should be helping our "wonderful veterans" instead. Really?Hear Ye! Hear Ye! I am one of those wonderful veterans. (1974-1981) I am a...
by Marcy Goodfleisch 3 years ago
What do you think Trump wants to do about immigration?Will Trump take the country in the wrong direction? What should be done?
by Greg Schweizer 3 years ago
Why are people so concerned about their heritage/ancestry?I am not asking this question to be mean. I am just curious. Personally, I know that my ancestors came from Germany. I am satisfied with knowing that. I don't need to know specifics of 100 or 200 years ago. That part of my ancestry doesn't...
by Readmikenow 12 months ago
really get tired of people who say the United States is a horrible place. I have no idea why they just don't go to a country they think is better. I wonder if they are too unintelligent, cowards or just lack the conviction and commitment it would take to move to another country. ...
by Kathryn L Hill 5 years ago
We need to fight against what is bad for our lives/survival. We need to realize when to fight and when not to fight. When to yield and when to stand firm.There are times to stand firm. Those times are in defending one's life and way of life.This principle applies to Politics as well.What would...
by Eric Dierker 5 years ago
Who supports illegal immigration?Please note we are not talking about asylum seekers, refugees, victims of human trafficking or regular or investment or skilled immigration seekers. We are not talking students or visitors.Just: Who supports illegal immigrants. (also we are not talking support like...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|