jump to last post 1-9 of 9 discussions (16 posts)

When is it okay or socially acceptable to resort to violence?

  1. Maria Antonia profile image60
    Maria Antoniaposted 3 years ago

    When is it okay or socially acceptable to resort to violence?

    I'm not advocating violence, but some professions have a level of danger and violence that is inherently attached to it.  When you leave the profession it's difficult not to view the world as a dangerous place in which if you don't respond appropriately either verbally, with a threat of violence, or actual violence, you and others may die.  Recently I started thinking about what the rest of the population's violence threshold is.  Meaning, is there ever an instance or scenario in which you would resort to the threat of or actual violence against someone?

  2. Craig Suits profile image78
    Craig Suitsposted 3 years ago

    Of course there is a time and place for violence unless one is a complete passivist or fool is more like it.
    However, short of defending oneself or others violence of any kind is one of humanities greatest shortcomings. Unauthorized violence of any kind must be abolished but to accomplish that, it may take 100 years or so of strict and severe punishment for humanity to learn. A small price to pay comparatively speaking.
    Lets get started solving this problem right now. Count me in...

    1. Maria Antonia profile image60
      Maria Antoniaposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      Craig, do you think that it's possible to abolish unauthorized violence by solving the root cause that lead the individual to commit a violent act rather than just inflicting more violence like punishment?

  3. junko profile image77
    junkoposted 3 years ago

    Different degrees of violence is sometime needed according to different situation in dealing with man or beast. To kill or injure is extreme violence and should be used in life or death situations only.

  4. Link10103 profile image75
    Link10103posted 3 years ago

    The unrealistic answer would be never. It sounds good on paper to never resort to violence, but life sucks.

    Realistically, only resort to violence when you yourself are a victim of it.

  5. PhoenixV profile image76
    PhoenixVposted 3 years ago

    There is an adage, that perhaps some people might find cliche: It's better to be judged by 12 than carried away by 6. A person can use reasonable force to defend themselves and others against violence. I think good advice would be to avoid situations as much as possible that could involve violence against you or others and channel aggression into utilizing law enforcement to do their job as effectively as you can.

  6. Nadia Ribadu profile image60
    Nadia Ribaduposted 3 years ago

    In self defense, of course, and to protect my loved ones, as well as my home, such as if a burglar intrudes.  If, however, I presented a gun, baseball bat, frying pan, or whatever I could get my hands on and the intruder fled, I would let him go without hurting him, because property is only that.  I could still be in danger if I tried to retrieve things he/she took.  It wouldn't be worth it.  I'd call the police.  Only if he didn't flee when he saw that I was armed and willing to wield a weapon would I resort to violence, which in general I oppose.

  7. Maria Antonia profile image60
    Maria Antoniaposted 3 years ago

    Nadia those are all really good, rationale reasons to use violence, and I especially like that you would let the intruder go at the point where your family is safe.

    1. Nadia Ribadu profile image60
      Nadia Ribaduposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      Thanks, Maria, and glad you broached the topic.  It's timely, though it's always been since violence has always been with us.

  8. dashingscorpio profile image87
    dashingscorpioposted 3 years ago

    Violence is not socially acceptable in general. However self-defense is within everyone's right and is generally understood by many.
    Another instance might be a person wakes up in the middle of the night and discovers an intruder in their home. Ordinarily it would be unacceptable to go around shooting people but if someone breaks into your home you legally have the right to do so.
    And if you live in Florida you have the right to "stand your ground" if (you) "believe" your life is in danger wherever you are. Personally I consider that one to be a little bit of a stretch. Too many people are paranoid and have an itchy trigger finger these days.

    1. Nadia Ribadu profile image60
      Nadia Ribaduposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      I didn't say that violence is "socially acceptable in general."  I said I'm opposed to violence in general.  Vast difference.  How is an intruder "another instance"?  A burglar IS an intruder when it relates to private property.

    2. dashingscorpio profile image87
      dashingscorpioposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      Nadia Ribadu, I never read (your) comment! My answer was in response to the overall question being asked. Maria's last sentence:"is there ever an instance or scenario in which you would resort to the threat of or actual violence against someone?"

    3. Maria Antonia profile image60
      Maria Antoniaposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      I am pro-self protection but I am against stand your ground laws.  I have had to use violence to save my own life and it is hard to put on the breaks when you're in survival, it's your life or mine mode, but when you value all human life it is easier

    4. dashingscorpio profile image87
      dashingscorpioposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      Maria, I with you regarding "stand your ground" laws. They're too subjective and anyone can claim (in their mind) they felt their life was being threatened. Such laws also do not require the "would be victim" to attempt to walk away.

    5. Nadia Ribadu profile image60
      Nadia Ribaduposted 3 years agoin reply to this

      Sorry, dashingscorpio, don't kill me!  If I misread or you weren't addressing me, SORRY!

  9. Say Yes To Life profile image80
    Say Yes To Lifeposted 3 years ago

    Definitely to defend yourself.  People are less likely to attack you in the first place if they know you're going to fight back.

 
working