A catholic attending christian church
Is it wrong for a catholic to attend a christian church? No priest, just pastor
I don´t think so. I go to whatever church that is as long as it is not close for me to attend to.
I never heard of this. I think if a Catholic were to attend a different church they would still walk out Catholic.
Your question should read, "Is it wrong for a Catholic to attend a Protestant church"?
Catholics are Christians just as much as protestants are.
Sorry you are so confused about that along with many others.
And yes, it is ok to attend any church you want to go to.
Most Catholics, when asked if they are Christian, will say that they are Catholic. Also, there are Christian denominations that are not Protestant: LDS, Unitarian, Eastern Orthodox.
I guess you are right there. But is it true that protestant and christian believed that Virgin mary should not be praise or prayed to?
I can only speak about my personal faith, with is Lutheran. Lutherans hold Mary in high esteem, but they do not pray "directly" to her for intercession between us and God. Yet, she has a soul full of grace, and is praised for that.
I was raised Catholic, and as a young person, I attended services with friends at Methodist and Lutheran churches, and a Jewish temple. It was really interesting to attend, and then talk about the differences in the services, and ask questions about the meanings of various things I experienced that were different than Catholic mass. My parents were all for it, although they did balk at first at the idea of me attending dances with my Mormon friends at the local stake.
I think attending a variety of churches is a wonderful thing.
When i was young, I had attended a christian church. It was totally different from our catholic church. All they talk about is Jesus, Jesus and Jesus, no Virgin mary and no God. Why?
That would be a question to ask someone who attends that church.
I can respond to the "no talk about Virgin Mary" question. In a non-Catholic Christian Church, we do not pray to Mary. We only pray to God, and usually add "in the name of Jesus" - which is a reference to John 14:13.
It's absolutely fine. I (Lutheran) have attended Catholic services, and my Catholic friends have attended my church services. There are a few minor differences in how things are run, e.g., Non-Catholic Christian churches do not have "confessionals" and we don't light candles, and a few other differences in ritual. But it is the same Trinity - Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. If you are still worried, just call the pastor in advance and get his or her viewpoint.
It is not me. My brother who has OCD, had turned to christian church instead of our catholic church. He is saying negative things about catholic church now. bad ones
I am sorry that is happening, peachy. I am certain that the Pastor a the Christian Church would not approve of that behavior. You may want to speak to him or her.
Oh I tried, he said that I am one of the bunch lousy scums of Catholics. He said Christians are the holiest. So sad. How did the pastor teach him??
I always thought catholics were considered Christians too. As long as you believe in Jesus Christ and that He was born to a virgin named Mary, and they was crucified and came back to life 3 days later, and follow His teachings, then you are a Christian. The catholic church does that. I am not catholic, but my husband is and I know that for sure. The catholic church isn't as strict with it's rules are they were once. We got married in my church by my pastor and it was ok'd by his priest and that was 45 years ago.
I got a bad experience from a christian when I was young. My classmate is a christian while I am a catholic, she said that Virgin Mary was a whore, a bitch who gave birth to Jesus Christ. That is why christians do not pray to Virgin mary.
That was just wrong. Hope you realize that not all Christians are like that.
Peachy, I am sad that you got a distorted view of Christian Churches. While we do not pray to the Virgin Mary, she is still considered a holy person. We sing positive songs about her at Christmas (e.g., Silent Night). Your classmate is misguided.
I'm sorry about that peachy, That girl was definitely not a Christian. She would never have said those things if she were. Please don't think that a true Christian would ever say that about Mary.
That is why I am negative about Christian or protestant churches. How could my classmate said such an awful word against Virgin Mary?? Anyway, until now, she still insisted that Jesus mother is a whore. So mad at her (my friend)
Peachy, your "friend" is just making things up about Mary. No true Christian would call her a "whore." Please don't be mad. Just be glad you got correct information.
Again, I am sorry about that girl. She is not your friend. She is no ones friend. I wouldn't listen to her if I were you. She will have to answer to God Himself and Jesus for her words.
Thank you all of you great christians for being positive. I don't speak to her anymore. Such a shame
I don't think that would be a problem. As somebody else says that a Catholic believes the same as a Christian, maybe they have different versions of the Bible. I have run across a Catholic or two who say that only Catholics are the only Christians. But then there are some Christians who may say that the Catholic Church is a cult. But that is just a handful. The only difference I can see are in the church services. A Catholic mass follows a set a rituals, maybe they might be different from mass to mass. A Christian mass may be more informal-depending on the type of church you go to. I belong to the First Assembly of God which is a Pentecostal church and focuses more on Jesus Christ and Bible Study
Yes, I too believe it's a matter of "focus" - not of basic beliefs. Good answer.
i guess every church have different way of practices
I know it is common for Christians of different denominations to attend other churches at the requests of family or friends. My husband and I are Lutherans from the Missouri Synod, we will sometimes attend other churches during the holidays or when there is a family gathering, however we do not participate in Communion at other churches. The LCMS practices closed Communion, meaning we do not Commune those whom we are not in full agreement with in doctrine. I understand that many Catholic Churches practice closed Communion as well.
I do not believe it is wrong for you to attend a church of another denomination, but I would think twice before receiving Communion. When you Commune with a church you are stating that you agree with their beliefs and there are many differences in Catholic and Protestant beliefs.
by gvalenoae777 2 years ago
If a Christian stops attending church and starts from home reading&studying his bible is he in sin?many christians attend church and are no different than those who do not attend. If a person committed to Jesus, decides to no longer attend the building but loves Jesus daily. Is making a...
by Susan Reid 5 years ago
Those Hubbers (and there are a lot here!) who identify as Christians.Do you consider yourself "born again?"What church or type of service do you attend?How often do you go to church?Are you in leadership or active volunteer in your church? Have you always belonged to this...
by graceinus 11 months ago
Should churches be allowed to invest the money from donations to be used for investments?Did you know that a lot of money given in the form of "tithing" or "donation" to churches are then used by the churches to invest in stocks, bonds, mutual funds and other investments solely...
by Wake Up Call Min. 9 years ago
We need church because we are relational beings.
by AnnCee 7 years ago
Do they generally provide a wider opportunity for the pursuit of happiness than nations founded upon the ethics of other religions?By Christian I mean Protestant Christianity because the form Roman Catholic nations to the south of us have taken is significantly different than those of North America...
by boyatdelhi 4 years ago
Is Roman Catholic church truly follow the bible?Where it diverted from the bible?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|