Should men still ask a woman's father for permission before proposing?
Marriages in the past were very different arrangements than they are now. But one of the traditions that still exists today is asking the woman's father for his permission/blessing before proposing. Is this still considered common courtesy, or is it part of outdated gender roles?
I still think men should ask their future wife's father if they have their blessings. I think it is very kind and considerate, it shows how much of a gentleman someone is. I love seeing men behave like gentleman, this world has pushed chivalry and common courtesy to the side, but me and so many other women still appreciate it.
A lot of "chivalry" was rooted in sexism!
Women were seen as the "weaker sex" and needed to be sheltered and protected like children. The important decisions were left up to the men. "Don't worry your pretty little head". Being "special" is weak.
I see what you're saying, but "blessings" and "permission" are two different things. "Are you comfortable with our getting married?" If he said no, then I would have to say "tough luck."
My perception and opinion differs. Being "cherished" is wonderful. Chivalry is not dead, and I have tried to model that behavior for my daughter and son. My wife tells me I've succeeded.
I think that custom has always been a good thing. Yes, I think men should ask the father for permission and acceptance before proposing to the daughter. It shows respect, responsibility, and sincerity.
NO a thousand times. The intended is a grown woman and doesn't need her father's permission to propose. I feel that a man should ask the intended's permission, not her father. This is the 21st century when women are equal partners in career, life, & love matters. NO woman needs her father permission for anything.
A mature woman does not need her father's permission; however, if their relationship was healthy, she would likely want her father's participation, joyful support and approval without a dependency upon it.
Of course, but what does that have to do with getting his permission? My 21-year-old granddaughter's fiance probably didn't ask permission, but they asked for and got his participation in the wedding. My son had hoped they would marry.
I think it all depends on the culture. If the woman's parents are expecting it, I think it would be a good sign of respect on the guys part to ask the parents, and hopefully the fiance will let the guy know that her parents are expecting it.
But In many cultures where it doesn't really matter. I don't see why you would have to. But I think its still a good sign of respect and the parents will appreciate you more for it.
I'd say it very heavily depends on the relationship between the father and daughter and, of course, between the future son-in-law and her father. I expect to be asked for my approval or blessing out of respect, and I would respond well to that. My daughter is an intelligent young woman and she tolerates no disrespect or mistreatment. If a young man doesn't have the respect or the courage to ask for my blessing, he may not deserve to join this family.
If the woman is of legal age, absolutely not! Courtesy ha! Show her some courtesy by treating her as an equal, not a possession of her father. To ask her father is a symbol of acknowledging that he is in control of his grown daughter and needs his permission to transfer her to her husband's household, where she will be a possession. We need to get rid of some of these outmoded customs that make women subservient to men and move into the 21st century where souls are equal.
You may answer that this goes back to where the bride's parents pay for the wedding. In that case, if dollar signs are in your eyes, by all means ask Daddy if it is OK to marry his daughter, and, oh yes, please pay for out wedding, too. But in this day and time when most couples are older and pay for their own weddings, it certainly should not be done.
Somehow I can't see this happening when the couple live and work many states away or is in the military and the putative groom has not met them. What do the couple do if papa says no? Do they break up or do marry anyway and alienate the father?
Now if she is underage and pregnant, the law says she has to get her parent'(s) permission, or seek the permission of the court.
I'm guessing your family structure is very different than mine. Possession of her father? Dollar signs? What about the love and respect between a father and daughter? Or the fact she was was raised properly to observe certain courtesies?
That's exactly what I'm talking about. Where is the "courtesy" in treating a grown woman like a child? Why does the father get all the respect?
I believe the "bride to be" should be the first person to learn of a marriage proposal. Ultimately she should decide if she wants the man for her husband.
The days of two men making back door deals over a woman's future is gone.
Having said that it really does comes down to one's culture and country. In some countries this tradition is still the "norm".
A man doesn't propose until he has gotten the green light from the woman's father. However in most free societies it's outdated.
Chivalry and sexism tend to go hand in hand.
Having said that it's a real tough decision for some women to choose between being treated as an "equal" or as "special".
Lots of women want both!
i think it is polite to ask kind of old fashion , but if he says no then do it anyway.noone shoukd stand in the.way of two people who really love each other
by Sima Ballinger 5 years ago
Do you think a man should ask a girl's father for his permission to marry her? And why?
by ViVi2222 8 years ago
I have been with my boyfriend now for two years, he is my first "real boyfriend." I am living with him now and have been for about a year. He told me that he planned to propose to me over the summer, which has passed, and I am still not engaged? Then he told me he was going to propose to...
by Michele Kelsey 6 years ago
Do you have to ask permission to use someone's hub?If you find someone's hub very relevant to what you are writing about, do you need to ask their permission before posting a link to their hub?
by Sarra Garrett 6 years ago
Since our work here is copy written to the author, wouldn't it be prudent to ask the hub author if the link to the hub can be used in a different hub? We have to do that with pictures so what is the difference in using another persons hub that belongs to that person who wrote it. I am...
by Daniel And Amanda 3 years ago
How do you know when to propose?I want to propose to my wonderful girlfriend, Amanda. I just want some opinions on when this is appropriate. Is there anything I am supposed to do, other than asking her father? How long should you really wait before proposing? We have been dating for two years. Any...
by Kate MacAlpine 2 years ago
If your father has closed the door to a relationship with you, do you accept it or try to change it?My former husband who is in his 60s and remarried for many years wrote our daughter a letter that says too much has gone on to change the past; that he has grieved the loss of their relationship and...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|