Why do you think Atheists argue against something they don't believe in?
Is it rational to argue against a belief that you don't ascribe to? Why would my personal belief impact someone with different beliefs. Can denying someone a right to believe be considered normal.
Probably for the same reasons, whatever they may be, that Christians argue against something in which they disbelieve.
I think that its just human nature just as the believers are on a constant crusade with a directive from god/allah to convert the non believers. As a non believer I try my best not to argue religion but I procrastinate then I get distracted and fall into the time wasting black hole. On the other hand I have noticed that on HP religion is among the top traffic pullers so admittedly I stir up a bit of controversy from time to time to attract traffic.
It is rational to argue against allowing someone else's imaginary beliefs from being an authority in one's own life.
@junk why not just ignore them and their "imaginary beliefs"? No one can be an authority in your life unless you allow them to. When you allow others to impact your life with their beliefs you are saying that they have power over you.
It's not their beliefs that have authority, it is the public policy those beliefs shape (e.g. marriage, abortion, contraception, school curriculum, etc.)
So, junkseller, I guess what you are saying is that no matter what, at least now when the vast majority of people in this country believe in some sort of deity, there is no way to separate church and state, which aggravates you.
It is no more or less rational than it is to argue for a belief you subscribe to. A lot of atheists argue against it for a couple of reasons. 1) They simply think the idea of God is a fairy tale based on outlandish claims. 2)Christianity is so prominently expressed and (by some) shoved down peoples throats that atheists take exception to the treatment of being force fed beliefs and then threatened with eternal torment and Hell for their lack of belief.
At least that is what I've gathered from atheists I have encountered
When was the last time you heard a knock on your door, or had some one approach you in public, and thought "I hope that isn't another atheist trying to make me believe they have all the answers to life"?
I can count the number of times that has happened in my life using all the fingers on one knee.
The main reason is that theists are constantly trying to get their beliefs inserted into education, government policy and laws.
Another is that theists ask questions or challenge discussion points based on religious doctrine as though it is somehow a totally accepted truth rather than a simple personal belief, from our perspective an irrational one at that.
And this is why your beliefs cause such hatred. How insulting.
I agree. You can have have your own beliefs, just don't insult mine and there will never be reason for such frivolous debates.
No Mick, if debating we are normally having to take up for our God, or someone has rudely interrupted in our conversations. There is no reason to belittle someone's God, what is the point?
As long as your beliefs are ridiculous, I will point out that they are ridiculous. If you had beliefs that made any sense, there would be no reason for such frivolous debates.
Quit right, there is no reason, JT, - never blaspheme another man's God... Even if that is a lack of god. However your arguement sounds like the old, - ah, it's different when we do it. It ain't, it's exactly the same thing.
There are a lot if Christians (from my experience) who are ruled by their ego and think their beliefs are the correct ones.(I'm playing advocate here)
If you're talking about playing advocate, Yea I do. I believe in at least taking the belief of others into consideration in my posts. But make no mistake, I still Believe in God. But there are some comments that I address because it is necessary.
Deepes is right, your comment is a condemnation that you are guilty of the same crime as those you would judge. The truth is you don't know because you never tried to understand.
God bless you too. By taking the stance I do you will notice that I'm treated with more respect than others by atheists (even though they still disagree with me). This is because I am not dismissive of their views nor do I attack their views
You are a very patient man Deepes. I admire that.
We are supposed to be patient and long suffering. Even Jesus was mocked in his return to Nazareth. But he didn't fight back or beat anyone over the head. He helped those that believed and asked for help then kept it moving. I try to do the same.
I know this and try my best, although sometimes I fail. I am praying about my temper and intolerance for certain attacks.
But that is in your power to control. One thing I learned is that nobody can "make" you angry. It's all in how you choose to respond to what is happening. Sometimes God allows things to happen to show us our shortcomings so that we can make changes.
A few people already said it, but I'll also reiterate. In general, I don't think atheists have any problem with other beliefs, it's when those beliefs impact the atheist (usually through harassment or government influence) that we start to push back. Many religions over step their bounds, then, when we point it out, they hold their hands up as if they're being victimized. Religion has a very powerful and dangerous influence on our society, and if left unchecked, can result in the numerous atrocities we've seen over our history. I'm not saying that religion is at the heart of every bad thing that happens, but its undeniable that people do horrible things in the name of one god or another. So, really, atheists aren't arguing against the things they don't believe in, they're arguing against the people who want to use those beliefs to harm others, whether mentally or physically.
Those who claim to do bad in the name of God are hypocrites. Plain and simple.
M.T. Cool pic btw. I understand that atheism is supposed to be about a secular existence, but it is usually not presented that way by atheists. If you look through the posts, they are negative towards religion, not positive towards secular.
I only argue when people argue with me. I tend to avoid religious arguments otherwise, I don't believe in it and it annoys me to waste 4 hours explaining all the reasons why
Not if it did not affect us nonbelievers...but it does, as these beliefs are the basis of much abuse. When believers are allowed to promote this nonsense, they are spreading it to more people, who would otherwise probably never buy in to such idiocy, therefore it is the responsibility of the rational opposition to curtail the spread of this affliction.
What does this accomplish? Christians are only trying to help those who are lost to accept Christ as their "Personal" savior. Shouldn't you leave it personal between the two people? Why do you feel you are on a crusade against God. What tells u this?
Because if you weren't so indoctrinated, you would see that your beliefs are brain destroying nonsens, meant to enslave the mind through irrational despotic foolishness. Left alone, religion has nothing but silly delusion for the afflicted. Grow up
LOL...... Grow up? I am an adult and know the truth. Hopefully, one day you will find it before it's too late.
@belief in God is an "affliction". Then most people suffer and u are rational. How intolerant. I bet if u could u would kill believers to rid them of their affliction. U people are frightening
I am not a devout religious person or a professor in psych, but usually athiest come from a very religious background and are rebelling against the religion or their upbringing/parents, not God.
This is inaccurate I'm afraid. It is increasingly the case that the majority of Atheists are born and raised in secular families with no religeious indoctrination whatsoever. In Europe at least, this is largely the case.
At atheistcensus.com, scroll to the bottom. Only 17.7% don't come from a religious background.
Yes it must be quite intense over there when religious debate occurs between Atheists and the faithful. There is none so zealous as the fresh convert and this applies to Atheists as well as born again Christians.
A response to CertifiedHandy's question 'Why do you think Atheists argue against something they don't believe in?' read more
by Eric Dierker 4 years ago
Can anyone really argue against a faith based belief?A good friend of mine was just trying to dissuade me from my beliefs. And he was quite good and convincing. But alas we agreed that if my beliefs were founded in my faith then arguing was pointless and that it was just the way it is. And likewise...
by Angela Michelle Schultz 2 years ago
If they truly believe that there is no God, why does it matter to them that I do believe?I have written online Christian articles. Those who comment on my Christian writings are usually, 75% Christians, 25% atheists. I appreciate all the comments, but what I find interesting is how hard some of the...
by Ruby 3 years ago
Why do atheists preach against God but hate when believers preach about Him?Atheists think Christians are foolish. Well it has been a long time & God has not been proven false! I constantly hear them preach against the Lord yet get angry when Christians preach to them. This is the...
by James Q smith 10 years ago
Just a question, but it would seem if there really were no God, then Atheists couldn't exist. Is Atheism a religion? They definitely seem to be unified by a common belief.
by Thomas M D Hemsley 15 months ago
This forum is for anyone here who wishes to debate on the subject of religion and religious beliefs. Outline your position, whether it be theist or atheist, explain why you hold that position, and then people can debate against you. This forum is not meant to polarize or antagonize people, simply...
by HannahRiley 2 years ago
Does it make me close minded if I can't understand why people are atheists?I guess how is the better way to say it. I seriously question everything...like facts from history, ect...but for some reason Ive never questioned religion. I grew up in a Christian home, not a SUPER Christian home, but one...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|