This is a question for men or women as it is more of a philosophical question than one of gender.
If you were Eve, would you have taken from the tree or obeyed God?
I have to look at my prescribed diet first...
It's not a fair question bc knowing what I know now affects my answer.
Then, forget what you know and just answer the question from the perspective of your own personal values.
K, lets see, some booming voice says I can live in paradise where all of my needs are taken care of and I never have to worry about a thing and in exchange all I have to do is not eat fruit from one tree... sounds like a no-brainer if you ask me!
(It's pretty convenient that the story makes the woman look like the cause of all problems (especially in a world that's been as messed up by men as this one has since the beginning of time. ) (Of course, I'm still a little puzzled about the thing with Eve and her kids - and then everybody else showed up. (???) Something was rotten in Denmark, I'd say (or should I say, "in the Garden of Eden"?)
There is a NEW EVE.
Watch the video :-)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVAVA4hx … re=related
(a good eve.........) to replace the sinful one.
I prob would have sinned too. For we are human.
how come eating is sinning?...if god wanted not to eat..why did god create tree at first place..now since it did and somebody ate fruit from it..it is joint responsibility...now god can't escape from the price just bcoz god owns the system..that is called immoral...
It is always so easy to say what we would do, or wouldn't do, in any given situation. The thing is, unless we are in that situation we really don't know. I would like to think that I wouldn't take of the fruit of that tree.
...had to chuckle with this question....wonder where this thread will go...
well...my first thought...is I'd definitely eat something 'cause it looked really tasty...after I was finished...and then no doubt I'd grab Adam and have some fun...why not?
...can't remember what the big guy said....
If I were Eve, I would still be trying to find directions on how to get to the tree!
I am a person who questions authority, so I'm sure I would have taken from the tree.
Well I'm sure this will cause a "dust-up" with much of the female audience, but my thought has always been this:
Eve was created "from" one of Adam's ribs(Gen 2:22). She was given to him as a help-mate by God (Gen 2:18,20b). God intended for the woman to be in subjection to her husband. He was to instructed her, love her, care for her--together they were as "one flesh"(Gen 2:24).
Eve's first mistake was to listen to the serpent, especially when what the serpent spoke was in direct conflict with what her husband had told her, which he had received directly from the Creator.
Her next mistake was to allow the deceitful reasoning to enter into her heart, so that she looked upon the tree with "desire" (Gen 3:6).
Her next mistake, was that she SHOULD have told the serpent that she needed to speak to her husband about the matter before she broke the 'only law' that God had given to them, regarding what NOT to do!
If Even HAD told the serpent that she was going to be obedient to what her husband had taught her, which had come from God, things may have ended differently.
If Eve had told the serpent--"Look, I am not going to do anything of the sort, UNTIL I speak to my husband about it--things probably would have turned out differently!
Okay--I know, this is probably NOT going to be a widely accepted viewpoint, but that is what I think--none the less!
We have the knowledge of what happened when she disobeyed God. So by hindsight, I would not have done what she did
It wasn't a tree. I know that doesn't answer your question but it should be food for thought...
and yet, an apple a day is said to keep the doctor away (and these days, apples are said to be a "super food"). Go figure. The moral to the story is, "If a serpent ever shows up and tells you eat an apple, get your apple at the grocery store instead."
Maybe it's because I live in an isolated part of the globe but with thousands of snakes here I still have not been offered an apple by one.
Where I live all there are little grass snakes, and none of them has ever done anything but run away from me. (Hmmm. Either Satan has decided to stay away from New England (unlikely, from what I see going on in my local news), or else I, for some reason, scare him away every time I rake leaves and run into him. I think I'll go with the thing that I - and a woman, by the way - scare Satan. )
wasn't a snake and wasn't an apple. Even on this topic you can't stretch yourself to more an what equates to a one liner. sheesh.
The subject is not worth more, and your comments can be read elsewhere.
knowing what I know now, the answer is no, I am still mad at Eve, for eating that fruit. Because now I have to suffer through those pesky periods every month. It's all her fault.
I always thought that involved a curse of some sort. Did God do curses, besides the whole weeping-and-gnashing-of-teeth thing? Either way, hang in for a few decades and that pesky situation eventually goes away and is replaced by brittle bones and all kinds of other horrible things passed down from that scoundrel, Eve. Oh wait - weren't women made out of some surgical situation involving Adam's rib?? Hey!! We get the osteoporosis thing from ADAM!!!
yah life was so much better in the garden and God only promises to help with child rearing not child bearing, but i am willing to believe that he helps with the other, although he's not saying lol
I wish I could say I would have obeyed God, but I think that my sin nature would have taken over. Hindsight is 20/20.
by sandra rinck 10 years ago
So GOD tells Adam and Eve to eat from whatever tree they want to except the one in the middle cause it is the tree of good and bad...So then the Serpent comes along and convinces Eve that it is ok to eat it and that God is lying, so she eats and then Adams eats it.God says that if you eat the from...
by iceangel 8 years ago
I personally blame all of them.
by Dave Mathews 8 years ago
What If, the serpent had not been able to Con Eve into tasting the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge, of Good and Evil? And, What if Eve had not talked Adam into doing the same thing? What would the outcome be and how would it effect life for mankind today?
by ngureco 16 months ago
Should a wife allow her husband to attend the funeral of ex-wife who divorced him 15 years ago?
by topgunjager 8 years ago
What was god expecting to happen when he put the tree of knowledge with an obviously ignorant and naive adam and eve in the garden of eden? Telling them not to touch it and punishing them so harshly when they did. It's like putting your children up for adoption for eating a cake you left on the...
by Rham Dhel 6 years ago
How would you address a student question about the topic of god/s?If you are an elementary teacher and an atheist.
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|