Should Bruce Jenner be Stripped of his Medals?
Some petitions to The International Olympic Committee are asking take back Jenner's Olympic medals now that he is a female.
Whats is your opinion on this?
That doesn't make any sense. He didn't cheat and (at the time) he was a man competing in the men's division. There is no justification to take back the medals because he changed genders later in life.
I agree that makes no sense! He won those medals fair and square under the designated gender of the category he competed in. The real question is if he transitioned back then would he/she have been allowed to compete against women?
She would deserve a higher medal as Men's competition is harder than Women's. Since he won a Gold anyway I think there would be a major uproar if they took them from Caitlyn!
No, she would not have been allowed to compete against women, because the Olympic committee does chromosome testing if there's a dispute about gender, and Caitlyn would fail the genetic test for being female.
I do hope that if Jenner gets publicly stripped of something, it will be his Olympic medals and not his clothing.
I don't think he should be, since he earned those. I do wish the country would stop exploiting his mental illness. That is just sad.
What century is this again? Psychiatry long ago dropped the idea that transgender people are mentally ill. The now counsel people going through gender transition to help them adjust to their new lives, rather than trying to somehow cure fix them.
What mental illness, exactly? Not particularly up to date on news these days...
Gender identity disorder is no longer considered a mental illness, but gender dysphoria is. GID was removed to help lessen the stigma of "transgender" 2 the general public, but was "renamed" so they can get the mental services they need.
A plethora of very serious mental-health issues are plaguing the US today. Thus, it is unfortunate that many of the resources needed to effectively address those issues have to be diverted to treating folks who have "gender hang ups."
u are NOT mental health professionals & know NOTHING. I AM & I can tell you it's a sick mind to have delusions U R superior to others. Yrs. of drug & alcohol kill brain cells.U may even see & hear spirits in jail, known as D.T's.or pl
If seeing and talking with Jesus is a case of the DT's, then you have diagnosed me correctly. And you're damned straight I am suffering brain damage from alcohol-drug abuse. And the reason why is I was man enough to go out & get myself FK'd up.
fpherj, you have written here on HubPages that you have loved ones and close family members who have fought in wars. Well, you should know that when some of us warriors returned home, "we were not all there."
Dad drafted & THEN enlisted U.S.MC. (WWII) husband (Viet Nam) son (Iraq)..MANY friends too.. Every one, stellar men, loving Dads,devoted husbands. Don't brag, don't whine, don't make excuses. No drugs, no alcohol. get the chip off ur shoulder!
fpherj, instead of accusing me of self-pity and having a chip on my shoulder, you should be thanking your lucky stars that your loved ones returned home in one piece. Millions of mothers and wives of "warriors" were not as fortunate as you are.
fpherj, please come right out and say it; you hate my guts. Well, let me tell you, madam, you are a member of a very tiny minority. I am well liked and highly respected by all the war veterans, poor people and incarcerated men I provide help to.
Keith, actually this is not an escalation. A few weeks ago, fpherj told me, in so many words, that she would never communicate with me again.
Freddy, have you see the movie "The Sandlot"? If so, this reminds me of the part where the two boys were in a cut down contest.
No, they shouldn't be stripped. They were won fair and square at the time.
Those petitioning for the stripping of the medals are merely doing do because of their transphobia - their lack of understanding that Bruce is still the person he was back then, but she's finally honest with herself and presenting her authentic self. It does not make Bruce the Olympian a cheat, nor does it mean that Caitlyn is not deserving to keep them. They were earned by the same body - just in different clothing.
If It was found that Bruce had been a drugs cheat at the time, I'd be all for the medals being stripped / but if they were won fair and square and legally, they should remain with their winner.
I think that's the worst idea I've heard all week! Bruce Jenner trained hard for those medals, and won them legitimately. There is no basis for revoking them now, simply because his life has gone in a direction that some narrow-minded people don't like.
Worst idea this week? You must be having a slow year because this is the worst idea I have heard in a long time.
Please allow your imagine to run wild. All the cash that Jenner spent on "transforming" himself could have paid for such things as thousands of meals for hungry people and numerous computers for public schools in impoverished communities.
Excuse me?? Are you accustomed to people telling YOU what you should be spending your money on as opposed to what you spend it on? WHO the HELL died & left you anyone's director of finance? "Imagine" for yourself...not others!" MYOB!
fpherj, liberals are constantly accusing "the rich" of being self-indulgent and uncaring towards the poor. Well, I guess that only applies to rich "straight" people and rich conservatives and Christians. But when it comes to rich transgenders ...
feenix...How U got into politics, only U could know. it's obvious u've run out of independent thought, which is par 4 the course. Ur comment is jibberish, makes no point at all & is unfinished. Another hallucination? U need a break.
fpherj, I am real screwed up. I'm nuts; insane, brain-damaged, as crazy as hell; dumb, stupid, unoriginal, in need of a break or a stay in an asylum. But, at least, my comments do not resemble teenaged text messages.
Not sure how"teenage text" somehow trumps potential insanity.
Link, where were you when cleverness and senses of humor were being handed out? Please, lighten up.
Link...the truth is, neither is feenix sure how character limit texting trumps insanity. Key Word: Insanity. When U don't play w/ a full deck, u run out of cards. Then try to divert w/ nonsense & immaturity. They just don't GET IT.
I guess we have different definitions of cleverness and humor feenix, because implying she is childish for texting like a teen and that it somehow bumps of your pedestal doesn't fall under either of those.
Damn, I'm in the same situation that Daniel was in when he was in the lions' den.
There you go again Mr. Delusional.....When you're not playing God, you just have to compare yourself to someone in the Bible! No self-respecting Lion would even bother with you, feenix. Stop flattering yourself!
"You can't please every one so you got to please yourself."
Thanks for hijacking my reply to have an unrelated cut down contest! As for the whole money thing, it's not my business what some vain, self-centered Kardashian clan member does with their cash. They're not known for their brains or philanthropy.
Lisa, please accept my sincere apology for being one of the ones who hijacked your comment.
Dont see why. Its not like Jenner was a woman physically from get go and used some elaborate disguise to compete as a man at the time.
Then again, even if that was the case, that would probably be more impressive.
For the reason they are giving, they might as well ask every family of a deceased Olympic winner to give back any medals that were won. They won them while they were alive, but now they are dead so clearly they dont qualify in keeping the medal anymore.
Thats what we call stupid people logic...
I really do not see the point in this, so I would say no. I think someone is just trying to get their names in the headlines because their case does not hold any water what so ever.
He was a man when he won the medals, so he should get to keep them.
Why would they take his medals away? He was a dude back then, he competed against other dudes, and he won. That's pretty cut and dried.
Bruce Jenner should not be "stripped" of the medals he won many years ago as Bruce Jenner who was awarded those medals based on his championship performance. He out-shined his opponents and he won. Simple, cut and dry. This is a permanent part of his past athletic accomplishment.
Actually, I can't understand how you would have even come up with this rather mean-spirited question/suggestion. He is not exactly the lying, cheating culprit as is the ego-maniac, phony Lance Armstrong.
IMHO Bruce should not be stripped of anything he had or was worthy of prior to his decision to gender change. He is entitled to love, dignity, respect, rights and a life free from stigma or judgement from ignorant individuals who have yet to TO GET THEIR OWN LIVES IN ORDER AND FREE FROM NEGATIVE ISSUES. Playing God is a disgusting habit and one NO mortal has a single right to do. It merely proves total ignorance.
Pay attention to your own behavior and that of your family. Keep your degrading comments to yourself and get on with your lives. Allow Caitlyn Jenner her choices and the freedom to get on with her life. No one can possibly know how or why anyone deals with serious issues in their lives and this is how it should be,. What others may think or say is the very least of their concerns. It's THEIR life......NOT YOURS! Don't worry your tired and narrow little brains wondering about someone else.
Do the world a favor and SHUT the F#$k UP!
Surely Bruce Jenner (Caitlyn) is not the first and surely will not be the last to go through this experience. Personally I am sickened by anyone who feels the right to judge, criticize. condemn or persecute.
For some reason or the other, the terms sanctimonious and self-righteous just came to mind.
fpherj, yes, I am a "sad man"; I will be the first to admit that. But one of the primary reasons why I am a success in life and I am respected by a great many people is I have had a tough life and, as result, I have gained the tools to lift up others
I don't know if you are referring to me as the one who suggested this but it was in the news and I am simply asking a question. No need for such hostility.
Some people are just angry at the world, so in this case, I wouldn't take it personal
Absolutely not. He earned them already. That wouldn't be a fair thing to do. Besides, his medals are irrelevant to what he is doing today. Let him be what she wants to be.
I thought that was happening first but then he/she was in the hospital due to cancer because of the surgery.
I thought I saw on Yahoo! that he changed to she.
I'm not sure what you are referring to....Bruce was in the hospital for cancer??
Perhaps he was not in the hospital but I Googled it - "did bruce jenner change" - and Bruce Jenner is now Caitlyn Jenner (if I spelled that correctly). That may be why he lost his medals.
First, he didn't lose his medals. Second, I don't know what being in the hospital for cancer has to do w/ sex change. He did not have sex reassignment surgery and that surgery does not cause cancer. Your first comment is very confusing.
I said that I was wrong about the hospital and the cancer, but right about the sex change. He had surgery for the change. May lose Gold now because of this, nothing yet .
He did not lose his kibbles and bits, so he is still genetically a dude. He did have facial feminization surgery and got some boobies, though.
Those medals were fairly won and well deserved. Whatever decisions he has since made cannot negate past accomplishment. I don't regard that worth consideration and I seriously doubt the suggestion will be popularly supported.
by rhamson 8 years ago
How is it an award is now justified for courage about coming out with ones gender identification? Arthur Ashe was a terribly private man and when faced with exposure by the press of his health he told the public. He caught a disease he never would have imagined would afflict him. Caitlyn Jenner has...
by LoliHey 6 years ago
What if transgenderism is really mental illness?Is there any chance it is? Should those with gender issues seek professional help? Why would we embrace it, rather than help the person overcome it?
by N B Yomi 7 years ago
Hi Hubbers,I'd like some help with passing the Quality Assessment Process. Will you please give feedback on my Hub The Transgendered bathroom issue, isn't a real issue (must be signed in to view). What can I do to improve? Thanks!
by Summer LaSalle 8 years ago
Does Caitlyn Jenner deserve the ESPY award for courage over Lauren Hill?Caitlyn Jenner introduced herself to the world at the beginning of June. After hundreds of plastic surgeries, and a sex change operation, Bruce Jenner became 'her true self' and is now a woman. The ESPY awards are...
by Peg Cole 7 years ago
You've probably seen the reports stating that the "Director of Education has ordered a suburban Chicago school to allow a boy who claims to be a girl into the girls’ locker room, whether or not the girls or their parents like it." Other states will soon be facing the same issue.Breibart...
by Debra Allen 10 years ago
Where Do Gender Reassignment People Fit in?I was just watching a show and they had a father who got a sex change. That family was having issues with family-type things. Our society is going through an identity crisis and it is not only who we are but what we are and what we are to...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|