As I read through some post, I found out that some hubbers with 0 hubs giving advice on writing and earning here, do you bother reply or read these post
That is a really hard question that requires a lot of thought AND a Single Word: NO!
Yes if the person knows about google. Google is used on lots of things and so is amazon affiliates. I would listen to them about those things if that is what they were talking about. They may have experience with google and how to earn money with it.
I have a problem with that too. I think one should at least place a Hub into the system before being able to join in the forums. It's just how I feel about it.........
I have a problem with hubbers who have no hubs and no picture or profile even existing. I get comments from people like that and I just think, yeah, whatever. Coward.
It depends what the advice is. Just because they don't have Hubs doesn't mean they don't have worthy knowledge.
One hubber was throwning a fit last night about HP's choice on advertising, and that is just a boring old argument. If you do not like that this site has advertising then there are plenty of other options for running an ad free blog.
Well I guess it's good that we all think differently and have different opinions. And Believe WE are Right
you know that could be a hubber who has since left or just unpublished their hubs
Dangit, Janetta. I wasn't thinking of that. You are one smart cookie. *fawns over Janetta yet again*
The Captain fawns over both of his fav girls
aww..I am batting my eyelashhes now--can u see?? lol
Maybe , but I wouldnt want Scientintology on my pages either,so I was interested to see if her/him's request was acknowleded.
I take all advice with the spirit in which it was given. If the advice is about writing, and I haven't read a word they've written, I might think twice about their input. But, again, it depends on the information of which they are advising me.
Yes, I like to read just incase they are saying something worth while. No point in ignoring someone who may be trying to help if they are new. They may know way more than me which wouldn't be much. I do not know all the good stuff about google and amazon, but I sure would peer into any helpful info.
Great response from participants on why one needs to have a hub in order to post
To add to my last comment, I have gotten in a forum and posted something only to be ignored and the information was something that I knew something about. It was their choice to ignore it. They lose, not me.
Ah yes, the whole "who the hell are you, noob?" mentality.
I usually do take note of how long someone has been on HP, how many hubs they have, and sometimes, fans.
I try not to be nasty to people who are new. I can tell if they are going to gel in here or not. Some don't, and I usually just say nothing and move on.
pgrundy has a point though. Some hubbers have been on HP for months, maybe even years, with no hubs, or a picture, and yet they are still here for some reason which eludes me.
Maybe they are here , because they can be...
But to be honest I dont take advice from just anybody , it helps to see if their mouth matches up with action ( their own hubs) etc...
Probably they want to see if hubpages can work or are promoting products to stay too long without posting
Maybe those are the ones who do have hubs and made another account so they can go around telling everyone everything.
Makes sense. A two-face like operation. One profile for being nice, another for raining down fire and ice!
Everyone has to start somewhere - we all began our accounts on here with no hubs - does that mean we were all less knowledgable until our first hub was published? Seems a bit snobbish to me, ignoring a person's advice simply because they haven't done a hub yet!
You have a good point, however I wouldn't say it is snobbish.
If someone gives out advice, I usually want to see something they have written or know something about their background.
There are several forum "advisers" here who have been on HubPages for a long time, have many, many excellent articles and are earning well. These things make their advice seem more valid. All of us have learned by experience.
Ravynsteel, don't loose your temp, just be cool, knowledge is knowledge whether you have published or not
However, the point is Hubpages does not have a lot of control over who advertises, etc. I think the noob comment was over the top too.
They have some control and choose not to excersise it. It's business. Period. You can make some money based upon ethics, emotion and good feeling. You can make a whole lot more by focusing on the money. And, to be honest, that would be classed as the better business model.
Anyway. The OP's question *smiles* Absolutely not
I just choose not to get worked up over certain ads. I thought the Scientology ads were kind of funny actually. My dad did some electrical work for a Scientology retreat, and while we do not agree with their ideas, they were pretty humorous. If people are adults I think they should do enough research to know any ad is usually just promoting themselves in a good light. L Ron Hubbard ads have been on the television here in the US for years.
I think that I would consider someone that does not contribute a hub after being here a month or so to be a lurker. I would question their motives for being here. The idea that they may be a second profile of an existing member makes sense, but I can't imagine what someone would get out of it.
you make lurking sound a bad thing Pete (j/k),but seriously though ,its cool to have some boundaries.
All adverts are quite parasitic in their nature,and I dont like the 'used feeling' so yea would be good business to have an element of respect (goodwill) for all parties. Like choice.
People with no hubs have no experience or reputation when it comes to discussing hub making and hub earning.
Worse than that is if they have only a few hubs and they're all "How To Hub" hubs.
The best way to learn is to do. Trying different methods. Experimenting.
Yeah its usually just a paid guy to make an account leave comments on specific topics with a script and leave. I've seen it before.
Some of the hubbers with no hubs giving advice, might actually be long-standing hubbers who have just made a new alter-ego identity. Then, they do know what they're talking about. You just never know!
What an amusing forum topic.
It's a bit unfair to assume that just because a person doesn't have a lot of hubs that they know nothing about making money here or even how to build a hub.
I have a lot of experience off-hubpages in many different areas of affiliate marketing and making money online, and while I'm relatively new to hubpages (at least in realising the potential of what you can acheive here) I certainly wouldn't call myself a newbie or say my advice is worthless.
As some other hubbers have mentioned, don't judge a hubber by his cover, listen to what he or she has to say and THEN decide if their advice is worth taking or not.
I've never really thought much about this issue, though ive noticed it many times.
They may be experts where they are coming from, testing the waters to see if they'll like HP. If its worth their while.
Im very open when it gets to learning. I've learnt a thing or two from people who dont know as much as i do. Online and offline, so, i give everyone a chance to impart what they know.
I always thirst for knowledge. From any source, as long as i learn something from it.
I would say they are Russian spies. I am willing to listen if they give up a nice cabbage Piroshki.
Yeah Blonde, let's incarcerate them and force them to eat your boiled cabbage and fish heads.
Get them to bring over some prawns. I'm having one of those cravings. Think I might go out and have a nice juicy steak with prawns on the side
I am going to be dreaming about this tonight you wait and see, torn between a prawn dream and an erotic one
Is that Hugh?
In defence of the newbies.. it takes a little time to become acclimatised and the forums actually do help with that. I wouldn't presume to tell anyone how to work the site.. but I can chat about other stuff.
You will have to just await my hubs.
I have this gift, this incredible gift to forsee these things. I am not a greedy gal I will share the dream with you. do you want the shrimp half or Hugh
I wouldn't expect haaalf. You got there first.
Maybe once you tire of hugh, you could put in a good word.
It's possible they're an established member and they're just asking under a new profile to hide their identity.
I think it depends on what the advice is about. If it's something non-HubPages-specific, I wouldn't think twice about taking it seriously (if it generally looked like someone knew what they were talking about; and it usually shows when people do know what they're talking about).
If it were about HubPages specifically, I wouldn't take it too seriously. There are some things that only time on HubPages helps someone know about. True, it could be one of those "alter-egos" - but I'd wonder, then, "Why not post the answer under the name/avatar that shows all the person's writing?"
I would just like to point out that even those who are new to hubpages may have vast Internet experience, know and fully understand SEO and have other successful businesses online that have been profitable for many years.
Don't know if it happens on this site, but like on ebay, people have a login for posting auctions and then a seperate log in they use for posting on the forum. That way it keeps people from bash or spamming an auction due to something they said.
Here on hp, I could see it if they want to say rude things and then not have to worry about people hitting the "no" I don't like that hub button at the bottom.
by Art Wartenbe 10 years ago
I've come to the conclusion that in order to get people to even look at your hubs, you must post in these forums. It may help get a few more fans, but if it doesn't, what have you lost. I've come here to hubber's hangout to see if anybody will become curious about my writing. I'm guessing I'm not...
by Susan Holland 5 years ago
What top 5 pieces of advice would you give new hubbers on how to improve their hubs?
by Karen Wilton 9 years ago
I've been on here for 9 months and followed all the advice from the learning centre, forums and hubs from the best hubbers. I earned the first $24.00 in the first month and I'm only $1.00 ahead for the next eight. What am I doing wrong? All help will be greatfully received.
by grillrepair 10 years ago
My current hub score is above 75 nd i have not been flagged for anything overly=promotional. however, all my article links and everything in my profile has been nofollowed. i just checked a few other hubbers and i am the only one i have noticed where my links are nofollowed. does...
by Nell Rose 9 years ago
I have read quite a few hubs recently where people have been upset by disgusting or just plain rude comments directed at their work, mainly by anonymous hubbers with no content, and also stealing other peoples hubs. My question is, do you think they should be allowed to join and stay...
by Luis E Gonzalez 7 years ago
Although I understand the concept behind the moderator's reviews that sometimes disables advertising due to what many (including me) think is nonsense, we either accept their decisions (as mistaken as we may think they are) or go somewhere else. Personally I have not found any other site that is as...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|