Have you noticed it or is it just me?
Do you think it's beneficial to not put the comment box? Or does the comment box help you?
I like the comment box personally. I like to read what people think of what I wrote.
Yes, but is it of any benefit to have it there or not?
I see the main benefit of it not being there is no spamming, but other than that is there a good reason for it not to be there.
I just removed a few from my more recent hubs because there's really no reason for those to be there, but they didn't bother me there, either.
I haven't noticed a decrease, I think maybe most are about 1/3 of the viewers though. I would be lost without my fans opinions, it really adds to the hub too at times I think.
I like it in the fact in recent hubs of mine some people have added good advice that I didn't have in my hub. I find some of the comments left are actually long and offer as good advice as that within my hub so yeah I think it's a good benefit.
I like having it though not a lot of ppl do comment on my hubs. I'm still going to post them on my hubs
I thought that the comments offer more chances of getting your keywords on the page. Is that incorrect?
Not sure about this one, but I seem to remember one of the SEO experts mentioning that comments count as new content, which Google likes.
Maybe Sunforged or Relache might have more idea
Personally, I like comments - a few people have given me some excellent feedback.
I always include it, but I've noticed that most readers choose not to comment so I have to wonder if its practical, after all when you read a magazine is there space at the bottom for comments or likewise on the back cover of a book. I have noticed that all to often people seem to mistake comment for debate and will leave ramblings longer then the original hub itself.These same commentators seem to have an inability to write their own hubs too, just an observation I have noticed.
I like comments, but lately all I've been getting is 1) your hub is great or 2) a question that I've already answered a ton of times.
Comment boxes are good for the following reasons:
- people LIKE to interact and you'll make the day of your visitor that can comment, this is more likely to encourage them to come back and use hubpages more in the future and tell more people. This results in a higher popularity, more hubpages traffic and eventually, potential for higher earnings for the writer
- people leaving a comment will be adding new content to your hub, for free. It's like they're working for you. Having new content added regularly keeps the hub high in google's eyes as it's not gone out of date.
- In replying, you get the chance for a bit more keywording
- replying to a comment is good because the person who wrote it knows you care enough to respond and are more likely to come back to hubpages/become a fan
- comments left might make you realise the potential for a new hub, linking to this one. Or, you might just want to update your current hub a bit.
I'd not get rid of a comments box unless there was a strong business case for doing so... you don't have to "accept" the ones you get, but it's good people get the chance to write to you immediately.
All good reasons to keep the comments box. It's always right at the very end of the Hub so I dont feel it's "clutter".
While comments capsules are beneficial for, say, 90% of hubs, some types of hubs do not naturally attract comments. When a reader sees a blank comments area, it's just clutter on the page. Clutter encourages content-blindness. A good general rule is to not encourage content-blindness in visitors.
I have been debating whether or not to remove them on a few of my hubs that tend to attract lots of spammers. I think it depends on the hubs.
I think it depends on the Hubs too. Some Hubs seem to invite spam comments. I have one that's about news on a new product. For a while it was getting a big flood of spam and little else. I think some Hubs are enhanced when people contribute different ideas or elaborate on the original ones. Sometimes, though, if a Hub is "big, deep, serious" or "very scientific", I think comments can make it look a little less professional. Not long ago I wanted to - for once and for all - "say my piece" about religion; and I didn't put the comment box on that one because I wanted the last word. In general, I think they help the Hub.
I think the comments capsule is helpful to encourage feedback on hubs. If there are spams, it will be up to the hub owner to just disapprove the comment.
So what if nobody comments as Fiction teller suggests that it creates content-blindness, would it be better to remove the comments capsule? or leave it as is? I haven't seen a hub with no comment capsule.
I guess I'll keep adding them, and just add them back to the ones I deleted. I'll just delete the no-content comments, such as 'great hub.'
Chinchin, I've seen several that I'm fans of stop putting comment capsules. At first, I thought it was by accident, but then one person in particular continues to exclude the comments capsule. I've seen many only use them for advice hubs, so that people can still comment, but not for other hubs- reviews and such.
Besides many other benefits described here in this forum thread, there is another.
There is an RSS feed for comments. You will lose this if you delete comment capsule. RSS is an excellent way to get back links.
Why do you want to lose that? You are getting tons of comments. Much more than many others.
I've gotten some writing jobs as an indirect result of hubpages comments so I think they are really important.
Also have noticed that comments have generally dropped off both on some of my hubs and the hubs of others, not sure why.
by ross670daw 10 years ago
Hi EveryoneI guess it's not only my problem but for some other hubbers too, how do you encourage visitors to leave a comment on your Hub, or give some sort of feedback.I am getting some traffic to my Hubs, but for some reason I am still not receiving any constructive feedback, either good or...
by Sabrina Yuquan Chen (陈玉泉) 9 years ago
There are two newly discovered hubbers who have only posted raw translations by using online translating tool, what they did was merely copy and paste the results without doing any further modifications. From the comments they replied, you can tell they don't really understand much English. Even...
by Whitney 10 years ago
What are the potentially cons of not using a comment box?I'm tired of answering the same questions over and over again. I'm tired of getting rude comments. I'm tired of dealing with it basically. I want to help people, but answering the same question over and over again or having to defend myself...
by Valerie Washington 8 years ago
Does it bother you that people visit your hubs and don't leave comments?What's more important to you, getting tons of traffic with no comments or getting less traffic with comments?For me, I love to get comments because it lets me know if I have touched someone or given someone a new way of doing...
by David Stillwell 7 years ago
How important is it to have a comment section on your hubs, or How important is it to respond?I was going through some of the hubs that belong to some of the top paid hubbers ( info found on the success story page) and a lot of those people do not respond to comments. In fact, many of their...
by Dale Hyde 8 years ago
I just happened to be viewing one of my hubs that has been deemed a sleeper, and I noticed that the Amazon and Ebay advertisements in the capsules displayed on the hub has been increased in size. This alarms me, as I have many hubs with various text capsules with these capsules within that...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|