The above warning appears on a couple of my hubs, maybe more, but doesn't show on the stats page. So, short of checking all 115 one by one, how am I supposed to know the warning is there?
More to the point, the warning is wrong. Occasionally I set the ads level to low or none because I don't want the reader distracted.
The hub does contain a link to a blog, but that too is not a commercial blog. I think we're getting a bit trigger happy with some of these automatic warnings.
I thought that if a hub had any links at all it was considered commercial?
The irony is, the warning appears on an essay against consumerism that links to a blog against consumerism.
How do I get it through that I'm not trying to make money out of this??
Provide the URL to the blog but don't make it a hyperlink... then you should be fine?
I suppose so, but that's less convenient for the readers. I've also used an rss capsule to the blogs 3 recent posts. That's not going to work except by displaying the hyperlinks.
Which article is this? I like reading your posts, but I don't want to go pawing through all of them looking for this either :-)
It's this one http://hubpages.com/hub/bloodless-revolution and its partner hub on the same subject. (You won't be able to see the warning though - they are only visible to the owner). Thanks for your interest
Naughty boy! now you have gone and promoted your hub as well - the Hubpolice are gonna get you !
Now I am off to look at it as well- sounds like my kind of thing
I had read that and the other.
I started a comment but just got overwhelmed by a feeling of hopelessness. Too much greed, too much bread and circus, too much ignorance.
I decided that I really had nothing to say except "I agree", which didn't make for much of a comment.
Pcunix - 'I agree' is just fine. What we can't change globally we can still opt out of personally. And if enough of us do that, we become the global norm.
I'm afraid I know far too many people who wouldn't even read what you wrote, never mind agree with it.
One of the reasons I love HubPages so much is the concentration of intelligence. Yes, of course we have our bozos, but the percentage of bright people (on all points of the political compass) is much higher. Even when I find myself in solid opposition, I can often appreciate the intelligence behind the argument.
In the real world, however, the diamonds are scarce and barely visible. Their voices are drowned out, ridiculed, ignored. It's rare to find intelligent conversation or, failing that, even *interesting* conversation.
I want to thank you for contributing to both. Of course there are many others; my New Hubs email is starting to get far too long and I'm going to have to risk insulting a few by un-following. You will never be cut :-)
I think that warning applies with three of more links to the same site?
I wish you the very best in finding your problem. I am sure that HubPages would happy to explain this situation to you.
You said you have an RSS feed that links to the blog's 3 latest posts. You also have a hyperlink to the blog in the hub itself. That's 4 links to the same domain, and is most likely the reason why your hub received the message. I believe we're not supposed to have more than two links to the same domain in any hub.
I was under the impression that an RSS capsule counted as a single link. If not, why does HP allow more than two stories per capsule?
A grey area, (or a gray one in the US)
Paraglider, the policy on RSS feeds has definitely changed. I noticed it myself.
A RSS feed used to count as one link, so you could have one other link in the text. I used to have several Hubs with that set-up and never got a flag.
Now, if you include the RSS feed, you can't have any other links in the text. So, the new rule appears to be that it's either two links or the RSS feed.
Thanks Marisa - that's what I suspected, that there had been a change. But without a warning in the stats page, how do we know if we've been warned?
Just read the rules Dave. ANY link makes a hub commercial - no matter where it points to, this was in the rules from the very start.
Not bad for me. Can't say for sure about Paraglider though, and considering his political views it likely bears at least mildly negative connotation for him.
However HP uses it as a neutral word, and all it's purpose is to define hubs that have to have ads enabled - for the reason of being used for more than just publishing content.
But Misha - my views are not political; they're just rational
Aya - commercial isn't bad, but sometimes I just don't want adverts spoiling the reader's experience. Especially flashing adverts! I'd rather forego the odd 2-cent click.
Kirstenblog - it wasn't the over-promotional flag. I've never had that one. It just says that because the hub is 'commercial' I am supposed to set adverts to 'high'. I don't much care for that.
Ahh, so that's the issue.
Remember, you have a partner here who takes 40% of impressions to pay the nice staff people. You are taking the milk from their teeny mouths!
RSS is a B*tch for flagging a hub as overly promotional or commercial or whatever. I had this happen to a hub I wrote and removing the RSS was my only option to get rid of that warning. Sucks but I can understand it, I may not wish to abuse the system/site but there are those who would and do abuse it all the time. I guess I prefer a site that makes it hard to impossible to spam the net that also makes it hard for me to promote myself and my works. I just have to work harder but it also means my promotion is more tasteful and useful to the net. Nothing wrong with promoting yourself, just spamming is wrong
Commercial just means that either:
1) you have an outbound link to a .com (or .info?) website, whether or not it's owned by you,
2) there's an affiliate text link, or
3) it promotes a business.
by Paul Deeds 10 years ago
New Hub Warnings - We now display automated warnings on hubs identified to be in areas where rules violations are common. These are the first step toward implementing some of the rules changes described on the HubPages blog last week. Please click on the warning to learn more about that...
by Sherry Hewins 9 years ago
Why is this warning on my unpublished hub? WARNING: This Hub appears to be commercial I'm not selling anything and have no Amazon or ebay capsules on it. Why does Hubpages think it's commercial?
by 6hotfingers3 9 years ago
What does it mean when Hubpages says " this hub may be considered commercial?"
by Bill Yovino 8 years ago
Hi All,I received an email from Hubpages -"We are writing to notify you that your Hub contains Unrelated Links or Products. Your Hub remains published, giving you the chance to address this violation."There are no flags or warnings on my account page and nothing indicated in the Broken...
by Thomas Dowling 4 years ago
I give! I've searched the first 3 or 4 pages of "Getting Help" Forum and I've read the entire Link's Capsule section in the Learning Center (http://hubpages.com/learningcenter/using-hubtool). That Hub, by the way, has a large number of Quick Links in it. How do you create a list of topics...
by junegage 10 years ago
I get a warning that my hub is "commercial", but I have no ads and no affiliate links and I...don't link to any sites that do. What's going on here? Hub Pages cannot be "hobby pages"?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|