why is it that British comedy often struggles to impress audiences in the US?
There's not much on television. And the ones that are....are taken and Americanized (like the Office.)
I for one love Red Dwarf, and a few others. But Red Dwarf is the most awesome thing since sliced bread.
Americans aren't used to subtle comedy.
There is not much on network TV in my opinion. Any channel that show commercials is not some thing I usually watch. I read my news online, and watch mostly movies on TV for the most part. When I do watch TV series it is usually the HBO variety like Curb Your Enthusiasm, Big Love, and the No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency. I also liked Flight of the Concords.
I just don't get the humor. I'm really sorry, but I just don't.
"Where is Charles Pensington this morning?" *Charles enters the room to soft, polite British applause* "I say Thurston, you will never guess what I just did." "What was that Charles?" "I was playing cricket, when all of a sudden I rounded the tilly wag with a crumpet." *Polite British laughter*
Nah I'm just kidding, I liked this one show, and I can't remember the name of it, where these guys lived in the country and one kind of looked like a farmer, but the others were well dressed. It would always play soft flute-y type music between scenes. I remember seeing that on PBS.
Seriously, British Comedy can be awesome.
Red Dwarf on YouTube:
"Sir, just suppose I did have the cat..what would you do to Frankenstein?"
"I'll have it sent down to medical and have it splice it up into a million pieces to make sure its okay"
"Well, will you put the cat back together when you're done?"
"Lister, the cat will be dead."
"Well, with respect sir, whats in it for the cat?"
I'm an American, my husband is English, this is a heated debate in our household.
The language barrier is one reason. It's amazing how two people can be speaking the same "language" without actually speaking the same language. I can't tell you the countless mistakes that have come out of this problem (including one very strange beef, potato, and spinach casserole).
Cultural differences present another problem. What a person finds funny stems from what they know, and what they know is based in how and where they were raised. British and American culture, despite their similarities, are surprisingly different. As one responder to this put "I just don't get it". This is the reason Little Britain isn't flying off the shelves of Best Buy.
American FCC regulations prohibit a lot more. My father-in-law is always glued to the TV when we visit, so I've experienced my fair share of BBC and Sky. Despite what Americans like to think, they aren't used to some of the content you get on regular British TV. We're used to having to pay for that kind of stuff, hence Showtime and HBO.
It's really a combination of these three that make up the failure of British comedy on American TV, which is a shame, because some of it is absolutely hysterical!
Check out 'Peep Show' Classic!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mv27PKxD … re=related
I still just don't get it It isn't my type of humor, it lends itself to think it couldn't really happen I guess. American comedy is either 1. Totally impossible 2. Oh my gosh that has totally happened/could totally happen. British comedy is somewhere in between.
I like both British comedies and American one, the myth that british humour is more "intellectual" is null I think, there's plenty of "clever" US shows. A selection of US and UK comedies I like are listed below:
30 Rock - (absolutely love this show)
The Office - (soo much better than the UK one, and yes I'm from the UK)
My Name is Earl - (alright for what it is, not the bes though)
South Park - (it's actually really clever and funny these days)
Chappelle's Show - (best US skit show ever)
Only Fools and Horses - (classic)
Whatever Happened to the likely lads - (again, classic 60s/70s)
The Inbetweeners - (exactly like me and my friends a few years back, so funny)
Look Around You - (first series is what schools used to show to kids to "educate" them but it's so funny)
Red Dwarf - (anytihng apart form the recent travesty three-parter they did)
Peep Show - uch a genius idea with two funny guys.
I love British comedies. But, then again, I was born in Scotland.
Among my favourite shows are:
BlackAdder (all 4 series') - with Rowan Atkinson
As Time Goes By
As you can see, most are older shows.
My current US favourite is The Big Bang Theory.
Big bang theory and Blackadder, two I forgot!
I watched the blackadder boxset from start to finish only a month ago too! D'oh!
I just have to add my own two cents to your selections. I love those! I didn't get a chance to even view Black Adder.
My all time favorite Brit Com is Keeping Up Appearances. Close behind that: Are You Being Served?, As Time Goes By, Waiting For God, The Vicar Of Dibley, Fawlty Towers and yes, I have to admit I used to watch Hero. I know all mine are the old ones, but they have served me so well and I will still watch them whenever they are on.
The Benny Hill Show was my favorite british comedy, too funny!!
We got a bunch on PBS for awhile and my brother was quite the addict. My favorite was The Vicar of Dibley, and I keep meaning to check out Red Dwarf, which was his favorite.
Don't forget about 'Some mothers do av em', 'Porridge', 'The Good Life', 'Last of the summer wine' and that old one with the two rag and bone men but I forget what that one was called, all greats!
There's a definite difference not only between American and British humour, but also their writing styles. Even here on hubpages I can often pick out a British writer without referring to the box in the top right-hand corner. I think we British love to send ourselves up, and we're very fond of humorous characters that are almost caricatures of stereotypes, such as Basil Fawlty (right-wing, ultra Conservative sea-side hotelier) and Geraldine Granger (pretty, amply proportioned lady vicar based in a village full of completely oddball eccentrics)
The Vicar of Dibley and BlackAdder are two of my favourites, but I also love the humorous undercurrent that runs through some of our dramas such as Ashes to Ashes, and Life on Mars.
I stumbled onto The Catherine Tate show on youtube. I love her!! She makes me laugh so hard I almost pee my pants. Anyway, I am keen for British humour. Love it all. I used to be a fan of Absolutely Fabulous and the show (forget its name) that takes place in a department store (was popular in the 70s I think).
Ok after seeing all the responses on here maybe I was a bit wrong, some British comedy oviosuly is well recieved in America. With regards to American comedy in the US the first one I ever remember watching was "Cheers" what a classic. When I was at school I also used to love watching My Wife and Kids. Can someone tell me what are the biggest comedies in the US at the minute?
Oh, I love British humor! I'm American as is my husband and he complains that he just doesn't get it. There isn't a lot on TV, I've caught a bit on BBCA- I like Couples, and I LOVE GRaham Norton! I usually laugh til I cry every time I watch an episode. And I know they are comediens, but I really like Russel Brand and my fave is Eddie Izzard
One of the funniest commedies from this side of the pond is Father Ted - a series about Irish priests on a remote island. Pure genius all the time.
I absolutely LOVED Keeping Up Appearances on PBS via re-runs. I own all the seasons now on DVD lol. Other than that, I never really got into any other British comedies....not sure why.
by Ken Burgess 2 days ago
A vanguard of the thousands of Central American migrants, who have been traveling for more than a month, has reached the U.S.-Mexico border where they hope to seek asylum. What have you heard, what do you think?
by Rod Martin Jr 5 years ago
I've corresponded and chatted with a number of Americans who think the 9/11 Truth movement has been thoroughly "debunked." But when pressed for details on the source of their belief, they can't provide any. One gentleman said that he didn't have time to investigate such things. My big...
by My Esoteric 21 months ago
Donald Trump has been President for 14 days now. In that time he has issued around 14 executive orders, most of which impact the world.The American polls show over 50% of America think Trump is doing a poor jobs.What is your opinion?
by Steven Escareno 2 months ago
Hey folks, i thought it might be a cool idea if we all shared cool youtube videos with each other. just put up a link to some of your favorite youtube videos, THAT DOESN'T VIOLATE THE HUBPAGES GUIDELINES OF COURSE! That goes without saying. some of these videos can be just random...
by Susan Reid 7 years ago
Genre doesn't matter. Can be male or female.What singer do you think has (or had) a KILLER set of pipes?I'll start with the one and only Freddie Mercuryhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cxbFLYa0_bw
by Rod Martin Jr 6 years ago
What would it take to elect Gary Johnson as president?We may never agree on the small things, but who wants war, tyranny and economic strife? The Demopublicans and Republicrats both want more war, tyranny and government spending. With $16+Trillion in debt, we can't afford more of the same. With the...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|