Web-site/URL: http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20101215/us_ … a_shooting
This will only give more ammunition to people who support JOHN MCCAIN'S message to "Complete the danged fence" (Web-site/URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0lwusMxiHc). The Arizona anti-immigration law, which says that people can be thrown out of the US just because they LOOK LIKE an illegal immigrant, will surely be in front of the Supreme Court for a long time.
Don't you think "More Ammuntion" was a bad choice of words, considering the topic?
"The Arizona anti-immigration law, which says that people can be thrown out of the US just because they LOOK LIKE an illegal immigrant"
Is that what the law says?
I'm totally against that kind of law.
Horrible, horrible men and women wrote that law.
What does an illegal immigrant look like anyway?
I don't understand why, if they're illegal immigrants, they keep flying their national flag yet they don't stay there.
Don't you remember.
The Southwest belongs to them.
So its their land.
I think the Native Americans have something to say about that.
Incredibly ignorant statements from both of you.
Read and try to comprehend the history of this region. You'll get it eventually.
I don't have to read history to know what La Raza has said about the Southwest.
It's not what the law says, the law is to do with racial profiling, but thats because not many non mexicans spend 3-4 days trying to sneak across the border with only 2 gallons of water between 4 men.
They are not instantly deported, but they are asked to provide identification (drivers licence would do) so that their records can be checked.
This is just another way to try and crack down on illegal immigration, but as a US immigrant myself, I can kind of understand why it is so hard for mexicans to come up with the money required.
Immigration can be a problem though, some immigrants come to a country expecting work and find none, turning to crime. Some people cross borders with the intention of crime (a particular worry with the current drug problem in Mexico) and there is also the problem that foreigners working in a different country often send money home, weakening the economy.
Some of these issues have been particularly relevent in the UK over the last decade, since it has been one of the few major countries to accept large numbers of immigrants from the weaker EU states, and now it is paying for it.
I am all for immigration, but keep it legal.
RIP Agent Brian A. Terry who worked a difficult job in an area known for drug trafficking.
The border agents are so few in number. We should get the army to reinforce them. The Mexican gov't has not been effective in controlling and arresting their drug traffickers.
The Mexican government wants in on the lawsuit against Arizona. They whine about what it takes to keep drug traffikers down. They don't enforce laws. Don't expect anything out of them. The front line of defense is the border and I agree, the military should be there.
I disagree with placing US Troops on our own soil. However, I do believe that the border States should have funded and trained their own militia to tackle this issue. I know, it sounds unfair, but look at the alternative. Do you realy want to set a precident of longterm martial law?
Whether it is the US Army or the Arizona National Guard or Texas Rangers, it doesn't really matter to me as long as the Border Patrol has some kind of reinforcement that will be able to deal with the traffickers.
I do like what Texas is doing. They have created their own "border task force" they defend their own borders. They believe in states rights and they are practicing that belief. Simply writing legislation is not going to stop the problem.
Especially when that said legislation is being undermined by your own federal government.
Agreed. However the legislation was flawed in that it only required them to investigate based on probable cause. That's the slipery slope that has gotten them into trouble. Had they simply created a task force and defended their border(not the Federal Border) this would not be an issue today. Granted, the Fed should not be a roadblock to security....
Texas, though has a much healthier economy and can afford the Task Force, probably. I don't think Arizona is in the same economic position.
Thats what happens when you don't have liberals running your state.
A healthy economy.
"However the legislation was flawed in that it only required them to investigate based on probable cause. That's the slipery slope that has gotten them into trouble."
I'm not sure why that is a slippery slope.
All crimes are investigated because of probable cause.
If the law read you had to identify everyone who looks hispanic then you would have a slippery slope.
Actually you would have slid right to the Supreme Court faster than its going now.
But, it doesn't say that, no matter what the hysterical left says.
Because we have allowed the flawed idea of "Special Classes" to infaltrate out law as well as our thinking. Probable Cause, when applied to a protected class is often termed "Profiling". While I disagree, it is what it is. This threat(illegal immigration/drug trafficking) is too serious to mistake movement for action. Border security is what we need. Not more work for police. Work that will only land them in court.
as opposed to placing US troops on foreign soil?
Our country has laws to address troop deployment. Deploying troops from the Federal Military is not allowed unless there is a case for Martial Law. Using our Military to enforce foriegn policy is a different issue. While I disagree with the idea, it does have a stronger legal leg to stand on.
They whine because they want more dollars to pad their pockets. The corruption in Mexico is past imagining. You have a country that is a major oil producer and who have received help in the form of major manufacturers from the US moving there to take advantage of the cheaper costs and still this lame Mexican government can't be effective.
I guess now we should ban immigration to the U.S. and deport all immigrants, legal and illegal. At least that's the argument some will surely make.
Because they are big bad scary immigrants with weird skin colors and funny names.
Because we're over here stealing your jobs.
Well if you are stealing jobs then by all means you should be deported. If however, you're legal and you offer skills that employer finds worthy of hiring I don't see why you should be deported.
I am entirely legal under the 'skilled worker' category, I am just offering the reason people use on me.
Well there is another discourse entirely about how the foreign skilled workers category does take jobs away from the domestic work force because the employers don't want to pay the higher salaries, but I don't think they should blame you for it. They were just rude.
Actually that is another issue again. I am on a very generous salary due to being a highly qualified (PhD) specialist. But thank you for demonstrating my point that some people think any immigrant worker is a job stealer.
I don't think it's much of a point, a majority of people think it's okay to hire a foreigner with special skills. There are always some people who see a foreigner working here as someone who steals jobs that an American should have. They have a point too, we are assuming no American can do your job because it's so special and they had to hire you. No one can really second guess an employer on that. I know that there are highly qualified Americans unemployed right now. I'm thinking that you are here on one of those special work visas?
Indeed I am. And I think another perspective would be that an American company should have the right to hire the best possible person for the job, as they see it. But this whole thing came up because of a question about whether some people are against all immigrants. I can tell you, this is certainly true. Some people are. Although technically I am not even an immigrant, I am a non-resident alien here to do a job. Plenty of people assume I am here to stay, assume I am a job stealer, assume I am not just the best person for a job or--as your comment implied--assume I am working for less than an America would. People like to make assumptions about other people that fit their view of the world.
Of course your statement is true. It's also not unique to the US.
Well of course any foreigner would want an American company to hire the best employee regardless of their legality or nationality. They wouldn't be here if the salaries weren't higher than in their home countries. And no one is disagreeing that there are SOME Americans against all immigrants but you would find that behavior in other countries as well. And normally, foreigners with special skills have what they consider a high salary but an American usually knows to negotiate at the higher end for the same kind of position. Employers like to hire foreign skilled workers because it's for a specific length of time and in the end it's usually cheaper. That's been my experience anyway.
And who said anything about banning immigration?
Well Im staying out of the Political debate ,but feel incredibly sad for the dead agent and his loved ones!
Well, Germany had their damn wall, why can't us American fascists have our fence? I mean. Really. It's only faaaaaiiiiiiiierrrr!
by Stacie L5 years ago
Supreme Court upholds key part of Arizona immigration law, strikes down restBy Liz Goodwin, Yahoo! News | The Ticket The Supreme Court upheld a key part of Arizona's tough anti-illegal immigration law in a 5-3 decision...
by Ronnie wrenchBiscuit3 years ago
I have seen a lot of posts made of late against the so-called illegal immigrants from south of the border. I have also heard a lot of smack about how we should be helping our "wonderful veterans" instead....
by Riece7 years ago
In my humble opinion, the Arizona immigration law is not racist. I'll tell you why. Yes, and this cannot be argued, most illegal immigrants in Arizona are Hispanic, but the law targets illegal immigrants, not illegal...
by Mike Russo13 months ago
Trumps speech on August 31 was fraught with lies and miss-information. He should not call it his policy on Immigration, but it should be called his policy on Deportation. I watched the entire speech and it...
by MikeNV7 years ago
The media continues to omit the word ILLEGAL when they attack the Citizens of Arizona for taking action when the Federal Government will not.The Arizona law is NOT an anti immigration law... it's an anti ILLEGAL...
by Eric Dierker3 years ago
I cannot find a group that supports illegal immigration. Yet we cannot stop it. Now that is pathetic. So we must conclude that without saying it, some - many in America support it and do what they can to stop control of...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.