All 4 kidnap victims aboard the "Quest" were found dead. Somali Pirates to blame. What will be the retribution?
Maybe it's time for air power to take out their nests.
I suppose Obama will appologize for America's past transgressions as a sorry excue for a citizen of the world... then he'll have Hillary write a really angry letter to the pirates threatening them with even more angry corespondence if they don't learn to behave and stop killing their hostages while stealing.
Nah, I think he'll take them on if his wife doesn't tell him to put the light saber down again.
Maybe... I'm just angry at what Obama has done to the image of America in the world! Has it come to this that a gang of two bit rag tag pirates have no fear of American military might? Obama should launch a bombing run on the pirates and send a message... there will be consequences for killing Americans... or at least there should be!
A gang of two bit rag tag pirates who have no fear of American military might . . . because they have no fear of death?
The point is, if your enemy is not afraid of death what threat to them is death? If you don't have death as a deterrent, what have you left?
well then...I guess the only thing left to do is to just quake in your boots!
Well you need to remember that they do not routinely kill hostages, they aren't interested, they want money and killing is not profitable.
The news in the UK says that the US navy opened fire on the pirates and as a result they killed the hostages.
Maybe a little foreign aid might be a better option than violence.
Who do we not give foriegn aid to...and isn't that blackmail?
Brilliant idea!!! Let's reward foreigners that kill Americans with cash!!! Should we also apologize for not sending money sooner?? We should destroy their entire village with fire bombs and every one of their boats we can find.
A bunch of dead pirates who were not afraid of death before or after...death? Letter of Marque thats the answer.
Lady, Somalia is your Libertarian dream - a land without government - pure anarchy. But maybe we can cook up some false intel regarding weapons of mass destruction - I think we need another decade of misadventure.
I hadn't heard the latest on this...how horrible.
How terrified those folks must have been...
There will be no meaningful retribution, not from this adminstration anyway......
Hillary Clinton has been on CNN quite a bit this morning. Unfortunately I have only the picture with the sound turned down so don't know what she is saying.
Military retribution may make us feel vindicated, but may backfire and cause escalated attacks.
If we could "settle" everything with military action, we would not need diplomats or a Secretary of State, would we?
So where were the Marines when these American couples were taken hostage then?
And why was it the Navy SEALS who were sent in to try to rescue them?
I am not saying the Marines failed!! I'm just curious if anyone knows the answer.
"So where were the Marines when these American couples were taken hostage then?'
That's what I'd like to know, too...?
It is NOT the job of the Marines to search the high seas for pirates....
It is the Navy's job to ensure that the sea lanes are open. The Marine Corps is a Department of the Navy. They are an expeditionary force.
Is it just me, or have there been quite a few Americans who wandered into dangerous waters/territory and got taken hostage (or killed) recently?
There was the group of hikers who got arrested in Iran -- they let the woman come home, finally.
There was the couple on their honeymoon jet skiing on a lake in Texas who entered into Mexican territory and the husband got shot (unless this story has since been refuted and found to be a set-up by the wife???)
And now these two couples on a "sailing trip of a lifetime" distributing bibles.
MM...No it is not you...granted there are some places on the planet that one should not venture off into. That is just common sense.
However, the folks that were jet skiing on a lake that is shared between Mexico and Texas...Now that is not a reason to got shot at...by no means or by any form of rationalizing.
Still...what will we do...when the places on this Earth that one should not go travelling in....keeps growing...and growing?
John...Oh John...I'm not sure if a little b_tt-kicking ahead of time wouldn't have also resolved the problem at hand.
Well...News flash...John 'ol boy...Neither of us have a say in it. I don't think diplomacy works with some people...and you sound like you're opposed to anything that would be any show of force...
Well, I'm not really into gun boat diplomacy.
You need to look at the whole history of Somali piracy and the history of Somalia and provoking pirates to kill might no longer seem the best solution.
I'm trying to understand...how it is easier to feel sorry for the Somalian Pirates then it is for the persons on board the "Quest". That escapes me...but based on the replies to this thread...I can see why every single thing on the planet gets so confusing.
Why do you say that it is easier to feel sorry for the Somali pirates? I don't.
Having some understanding of the problem does not constitute approval or anything else. Neither does thinking that nuking them is a bad idea suggest sympathy.
It's called taking the broader view, that war isn't the best option.
Ok...after all the "think-tank" political posturing and the "wishy-washy" strong arming has commenced....what will actually have to occur to resolve this problem? Or should we just be afraid of the Somalian Pirates and what they are capable of...from now until forever!
I would suggest taking away the causes of the piracy would be a good start.
That's so dull though, and it requires understanding, patience and probably a sacrifice of some sort. It's not like we're after comprehensive solutions here or anything. Their problems are their problems, not our's. Should their problems become a problem for us, then we just want to shoot the suckers. It's sooooooo much easier.
Where's John Wayne? We want action! We want glory! We want vengeance!
And those somali pirates should be hung for disrupting the Lord's work.
That's right...You sure got it all figured out, Pandora. Course we have never done anything like humanitary aid before....for anybody. What a revolutionary thought. Gee whillakers. How mean of us. Ok...let them go on about there way...We have not fully taken them under our wing yet...they are allowed to kill off a few here and there in passing...juz' cause we haven't done our part. Whoops...our bad! Hope we didn't disrupt there killing or looting or kidnapping or ransom spree. Maybe...we can send some more poor unfortunates over there sailing nearby next week...so they don't run out. Maybe that is soooo much easier, also...
what the hell were people doing in / near Somalia to begin with?
And half the people on this forum want to launch a war over 4 people who idiotically chose to go to such a f-ing dangerous place?
Note, yes I'm in total agreement with Evan on this
Oh so it's okay for Mexicans and others to just stroll into America illegally without consequence, but free people shoul avoid travel in international waters so criminals can occupy it?
The purpose of our government is to keep us free they have a right and a duty to extract justice on those pirates! We pay a lot of money in taxes for our military might and I can't think of a better more justified use of force than ridding those waters of that scum!
I suggest you read Ryankett's very fulsome explanation of the situation and then you might be in a position to howl for blood but until then, please don't.
Yes I am aware of the plight of Somali fisherman, but I don't see how that justifies murder! Somalis have to get their act together and form a government that can respond to situations involving their sovereignty in international courts in a legal fashion and petition world governments for aid. Piracy is not the answer and certainly neither is murder.
But they don't murder normally. The hostages in this case were murdered after the US navy had attacked the pirates.
They take hostages on a commercial basis, a dead hostage is worthless to them.
No, they were murdered then the US personnel boarded The Quest when they heard shots according to a Washington Post account. They were still in the middle of negotiations. I know your anti-american mindset would find that hard for you to believe but there it goes.
I don't have an anti American outlook, I just don't watch Fox News.
That is how our press reported it, that'll do for me.
Those people were not in Somalia for a pleasure cruise. Their boat was hijacked off the coast of Oman then sailed to Somalian waters. Before you make any assumptions, read up on it first.
It is the only viable route for World Food Programme shipments.
The reason why piracy has risen in Somalia is, according to the United Nations, because illegal foreign fishing has decimated their fish stocks. Developed nations have also dumped toxic waste in their waters.
Ultimately, the once thriving fishing industry is dead as a result. Subsequently the pirates and the people in their towns go hungry, so what do they do? They rob foreign vessels using their now unprofitable fishing boats.
A hungry man is an angry man. I watched a documentary on Somalian pirates which quite clearly showed that proceeds are used to feed the towns and villages that the pirates are from, there were certainly no rolex watches or sports cars.
When there is nothing worth robbing they hold hostages instead, held as an asset to be exchanged when they run out of food, they currently have 650.
If I were a man with hungry children and with my livelyhood stolen I would probably consider taking a machine gun onto my fishing boat too.
Somalia has a GDP of around $600 per capita per year, that is less than I will make from Amazon this month. Take away the only thing that they needed, food, and you have people who want to take that back. 73% of the population live on less than $2 a day.
There are Indian, British, Russian, Chinese and American navy boats patrolling the waters of Somalia to combat the pirates. How much does that cost? Probably far more than would be necessary to feed them.
What you also have to appreciate is that the pirates almost exclusively operate in waters which can be considered Somalian waters, not International waters, yet western ships pass through their waters rather than around them for no reason other than to save time and money. If the Somalian government wished to object to the passage of boats through those waters they would be legally permitted to do so, and they would be legally permitted to cease the boats and their assets too.
Since the piracy problem got out of hand the foreign fishing trawlers have been scared away and the fishing catches have begun to improve again.
Ultimately the US or any other country has no true right to kill Somali pirates whilst western countries illegally fish in Somalian waters and send trade vessels through non-international waters without express consent and some economic benefit to the country.
All these "pirates" have done is taken up the job of patrolling and protecting Somalian waters whilst their government has a serious lack of sovereign control. If your government collapsed tomorrow then people in Florida would probably have to resort to blowing up Mexican fishing boats.
There are two sided to every argument, as they say.
"The reason why piracy has risen in Somalia is, according to the United Nations, because illegal foreign fishing has decimated their fish stocks. Developed nations have also dumped toxic waste in their waters."
No doubt. Another reason is that piracy has paid off handsomely with only moderate risk. And the Somali "government" ain't the greatest.
I agree with you Ralph! The motivation is money pure and simple. Ransoms have risen steadily and currently average over 3 million pounds according to the daily mail.
I don't buy the argument about the fishing grounds any longer. That may be why some have decided to go into piracy but that isn't what motivates the pirates... from the daily mail
"The pirates from Puntland in northern Somalia are not hardline Islamists, and the fact the Adams carried Bibles was not likely to have been a problem. Pirates in Puntland are known to spend their ransom spoils on alcohol, drugs and prostitutes."
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article … first.html
If these were just poor fisherman wouldn't they be using their spoils to support their families and neighborhoods? No these people are thugs, criminals, and murders, morally bankrupt scum that deserve nothing but death!
As tragic as these deaths are and as abhorrent those scum pirates are, they do not merit or deserve our country's attention. No action is required from our military and there shouldn't be as this is an ordinary crime. However, I have no objection to having, say a group of ex navy seals, do some reconnaissance and do what they can to eliminate the nest of pirates in Somalia. No official connection to the federal government of course, just some scores to settle from some Americans to Somali pirates.
According to a Washington Post article, the Somali pirates hijacked The Quest when it was off the coast of Oman, then sailed the ship to Somalian waters. Apparently the Somali pirates were observing the yacht and dispatched a smaller boat from the mother ship to capture it. Clearly, the Somali pirates' actions were premeditated.
Look we just can't allow thus to continue. Its not just these 4 people that were killed its not being able to navigate freely in international waters. I'm not advocating a boots on the ground mission to install democracy in Somalia, if those peole wish to kill each other fine! But some well placed cruise missiles and perhaps a few drones should do the trick... if not perhaps another version of shock and awe will wake them up! We can't allow such scum to kill our citizens without consequence.
Yeh I don't think we got that news in america, John. The article I read did not state that either, and though I don't recall where I read it at, I assure you it wasn't fox news.
Wow. I feel like a citizen of china.
I just find it sad that God didn't save them. I can only guess he was displeased. Maybe they ate some shrimp.
I'm sorry they suffered. I'd be hugely upset if we started another war over it.
And you know, I thought vengeance was the lord's and all that. Of course I also thought Jesus advocated the strong helping the weak, still trying to understand how that one never seems to transfer over in the new birth of christians.
Geez I hope the bibles made it okay! What a loss of such a worthy cause..
I find it hard to believe that you found the deaths sad. Considering at one point you said that you didn't see human life any more valuable than an animal's. Well I'm sure you will be happy that no more shrimp will be eaten by those four people any more.
I still don't see human life as being innately 'better' or more 'valuable' than the lives of animals.
Doesn't mean I don't play the same survival game they do, however.
In fact, I made a big old pan of shrimp etouffee Monday night in a white roux. I don't care so much for the red version.
It was delicious!
Of course I'm sorry those people suffered that way and died. I'm sure the whole ordeal was horrifying, and I wouldn't want anyone to have to go through such a thing. This despite the fact that I think their mission was basically folly at best and that they had no business being there.
Yes, I used Fox News as shorthand for biased press, my bad.
Oh yeah because the british press is so not biased.
Murdoch has his finger in the British Press no doubt about it.
No need to speculate on what will happen. Remember last week?
"A U.S. judge sentenced a Somali pirate to 33 years and nine months in prison on Wednesday for his role in the 2009 seizure of the Maersk Alabama container ship in the Indian Ocean." (Feb 17, 2011 Reuters).
This newest bunch will also be hauled back to the U.S. and imprisoned or executed. Extremists and pirates may not fear death but they all fear Western prisons.
The pirates are getting more sophisticated - last week the Brits took down a stolen fishing vessel that was acting as a "mother ship" to pirate small craft, which let them operate farther from their bases.
As with many issues, there just is no quick fix.
http://www.royalnavy.mod.uk/operations- … rees_h.htm
by ahorseback15 months ago
This, one more totally impeachable offense , for the release of American hostages to Iran - the most terrorist and thus I.S.I.L supporting nation in the world ? Whatever...
by MikeNV7 years ago
They put them in a boat in the middle of the ocean with no food, water or supplies... a boat with out oars... and told them to "go home".Got to think that the Russian Ships will be left alone now.Good for...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.