In a marriage, does the man (husband) have to be the main money earner?
Does it matter if the husband or wife is the breadwinner -- main income earner?
of course not time has evolved so much that men are staying home and take care of the kids and do the chores while women work
I don't think so. I would have no problem with my wife making more money than me
Marriage is a partnership with everything shared, if couples start looking at who earns what, they really need to analyse their relationship, something is wrong.
I guess it depends on a number of things: How the two people in the marriage, or partnership, feel about it being the main thing.
Over the past few decades - at least in many 'Westernized' societies - it is deemed largely acceptable for a woman to earn as much or more than her husband.
However, you need to remember that cultures change slowly and often painfully. Even in the West, there are still a great many who believe a woman's place is in the home.
But as I said at the outset. The two people who have to make the decision on this one are the man and woman concerned. It is their life, afterall.
I should say not. The man can be a stay-at-home dad. I think, though, if the woman is to be the main money earner the man really should pick up the slack when it comes to the housework and hands-on rearing of the children.
As you know, as is usually the case when both the man and woman work outside the home, it is still the woman who handles the bulk of the housework (even if she earns far more money than her husband) -- this is a state of affairs is what some economists, I hear, refer to as the woman's double shift.
There are many who say that women will never actually achieve equality in the workplace until there is equality in the home, and I think that's right.
Take it easy.
No but as they will never have nine months pregnant or push out a baby a two, I think it would be wise if they were, unless he was able to look after the children and take sick days instead of you when dealing with terrible case of morning sickness, which in that case, do as you please.
Also the other issues is, with time off taken by women during pregnancy and child rearing, they loose a lot of money in superannuation.
But again the husband doesn't have to be the main money earner, however what else will he do to keep himself feeling "worthwhile" or whatever it is that does drive them to work. Unless of course he has lots of hobbies or something. There is a lack of stimulation when raising children and women always complain of it that they didn't have a decent conversation with anybody today. I think this is a bigger question that it seems at the start with a lot more factors to consider than I originally thought.
For part of our marriage I was the main income earner, while my husband studied and then consequently looked for work.
I don't think it matters any longer, like it did in the 1950's. Today a household has to have at least two incomes to substain any quality of life (like making sure the mortgage is paid, and bills don't pile up). I think it depends on what type of work the man or woman does. Most men do get paid more for what they do, however women are catching up at incredible paces. I would not be offended if my man made more than I did. In return I also know he would not be offended if I made more than him.
Marriage, by definition in my mind, is a partnership, and should be an EQUAL partnership. So it should NOT matter who brings home the bacon or the bread or whatever. It matters more that both partners go with the flow, and support each other, and are willing to pick up the slack and keep things fair and equal.
It really depends on the personalities and security levels of those involved in the marriage. We absorb so much into our own ways by observing our parents as we grow up...moreso that even we know. If that is the traditional role that a man or woman was exposed to, then it may well be built into their subconscious expectations. With a man, if that is the case, and he does not turn out to be the person bringing in the most money, psychologically he feels like a failure. A woman raised in the environment may have that expectation of her husband and when it does not evolve, she may see him as a failure. In a strong marriage where two people share the same vision, it really does not matter where the money comes from as long as they are living out their shared dreams of life. In today's world, one never knows where opportunity will show up and most of us live in two-income homes by necessity in today's expensive world thus we really have better things to worry about than who makes the most money...just be thankful they do! WB
Both partners in a marriage should respect eachother and love oneanother no matter who earns more. Besides, who makes the rules that says we have to do one thing or another anyway. You dont have to follow oldschool ways of living with your parter, rather concentrate on both being happy.
I think whatever works best for each couple's particular situation is the way to go. I knew a couple where the roles were reversed because she made better money. So he stayed home, took care of the house, and supervised the kids. He didn't do any real housework; they hired a cleaning woman. But he did the cooking, the laundry, taking the kids to soccer, etc. and just managed things around the house in general. It seemed to work well for them.
I think it has to do with the capability of either side of the partners (husband and wife). The best couple that I have ever seen are most complementing each other.
No it does not matter. The woman can earn just as much money as the man. But it is not a competition and if it turned into one, it would likely ruin the relationship.
Absolutely not. I do believe that it is important for either the husband or wife to be at home at least part time especially when you have kids. Therefore that person can take care of the home this will help keep everyone happy and not stressed by having to come home to more work. When you have kids I believe they need at least one parent home a lot with them otherwise they are raised by strangers, obviously in this world of single parents and a bad economy it is not always a possibility.
I don't think so...everything is shared in a marriage
Interesting ejovwovincent. Why do you feel that way? I wrote a hub about this question after I answered it. What do you think?
http://reneedc1979.hubpages.com/hub/Who … more-money
In today's economy it's not as easy as it once was to send a man off to work while the woman stays home, also I think men are more involved in home life than they once were.
Marriage is a partnership and if both parties pull together to make it work then why should it matter who makes more money?
Secure men do not feel threatened by a woman who earns a good living and in turn a strong woman does not need a man to pay her bills and take care of her.
In a good marriage, both parties share in all responsibilities of the relationship from child rearing to bringing in the income. How they balance that is up to them but I do believe the stereotypes of the 50's are starting to fall by the wayside.
What is this...1923?
A woman has an exactly equal right to be an earner for her family.
Women are equal and, sometimes, superior!
I guess, This is old tradition
Today is XXI century and as for me, both have to carry about family budget
I think that there's no difference now, of course husband ego can be bowed because of that. It always used to be this way, that a husband earns money, and his wife monitors the house...
Well, it depends on how you look at it. In eastern cultures, think middle east, India, China and others, it is the duty of a husband to work and bring bread for his family. In other cultures, it doesn't. But for any successful couple, regardless of cultural backgrounds and personal beliefs, the main income earner should never be determined by gender if mutual understanding, love and respect weigh more than anything else.
For some men, it is important that they are the main breadwinners. It is best if the woman knows this about their man before getting married. Otherwise it could cause problems later.
No. Each relationship is different. Both partners' feelings and needs should be taken into consideration. In our modern world where it is very difficult financially it is not practical to be overly concerned about who earns more.
no, not at all. I was a military man and my wife had a degree and was making much more than I was or ever did. I see nothing wrong with that.
No the man does not have to be the main money earner. That would be nice but today it does nto always work that way. If you find that perfect person you should not allow who makes the most money to be your reason for not getting married. You will need to talk this over and know for sure this individual is everything you are looking for. He/she should be aware of spending habits for this could cause problems. Ask the necessary questions and be prepared to discuss them openly.
When i got married I was makeing twice as much as my husband and that was not ever a worry in my mind. What i was focused on was how much i loved my husband. We have been married for one year and have never had a money issue. Working together towards the same goal is whqt keeps a marriage strong not who makes the most money
Not really. Both partners should support each other fully and if the man is jobless, why should the wife not provide
Definitely no. It's time for people to grow up and give up ideas that a man is, somehow, the provider.
In the animal world the female is more often the provider. Just look at lions.
Thanks for all of your contributions. Your responses are very interesting and lively. Let me hear some more thoughts, take your stand on this topic today!
Ha ha! I think with men, if they aren't the main earners they feel as if they are less of a man and it takes their manhood away...but hey if they wife makes more money what can you do...she's hardly going to quit her job, so the man will have to get over it.
Great question Treasuresofheaven and nice name. I don't think the amount of money either one makes should matter. Being someone who was formerly unemployed and no mate to help with the finances, I wouldn't care which one of us made the bread as long as the bills are paid on time, we are happy with each other and enjoying life. I think money is a major problem in alot of relationships because we are such a materialistic world. We focus on the wrong things. For whatever reason, some men feel emasculated because their women makes more money. But, why? If it's coming into the household who cares. And some women use that as a reason to treat their men like crap. But, why? Like they say money is the root of all evil. It is interesting how a piece of paper, cause that's all it is has so much power and control over us, our lives, our behaviors and perspectives.
by ngureco 18 months ago
Why Do Wives Get Mad With Husbands Watching Porn? How Does It Interfere With Marriage?
by John Wilson 2 years ago
How can Hillary be "for" women when her husband is a womanizer who's lied throughout their marriage?I find it odd, that so many women are for Hillary Clinton, when her husband is accused of being a rapist and of having numerous affairs.Hillary always says the accuser is lying, though...
by pisean282311 8 years ago
does bible state that? ...if yes then it must be stating something for husbands too...what if husband himself doesnot know what he it talking about?...if wife expected to obey husband even if husband is irresponsible?
by Kathryn L Hill 5 years ago
Men in the past paid for most everything in the household, including the house. They brought home the bacon, so to speak. In today's world, women also bring home their share of the bacon. This is one reason why daycares are thriving.Is this true for most/many/any women, or not? Focusing on a wider...
by Cristale Adams 6 years ago
Is it right for a woman to work and give her husband her pay check?
by MissJamieD 7 years ago
From experience I know how frustrating it is that my husband is the boss of our family and makes 95% of the choices we face....but I'm also thankful because I have enough to deal with as a SAHM and it's kind of a mental break for me...what do you think? Does there need to be a dictator or is there...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|