At what point does someone stop being human?
Just wrote a hub on Deus Ex, and it really got me thinking. At what point does someone stop being human? Technology is progressing rather quickly, and things like robotic limbs and augmented mental states seem to be close to reality. So, my question to everyone is this: does changing the human form with augmentations strip humanity from the person? What constitutes humanity as well?
I think as long as you are able to think and dream for yourself, then you are human. True, technology may be taking over, but as long as you are still you, then you are human.
But what about people who are mentally ill or comatose - they are still human.
Interesting idea. I think that being mentally ill or comatose also blurs the line of humanity. After all, a person in a coma is essentially an object, incapable of love/fear/etc.
That is a good point, but I have to agree with GamingCowboy. It's the same as with an unborn baby before the brain is formed. I believe it's different for the mentally ill however. Who is to say they don't have dreams?
Interesting question. For sure, the lines are quickly becoming blurred; science fiction is becoming everyday life. Coming from a medical perspective and as someone who has dealt with life and death on a regular basis for many years, I would say that someone stops being human at the moment the brain waves go flat. That has always been my working definition. Now, with what we can and will be able to do with the brain, even that becomes an interesting discussion, because perhaps a human could stop being a human when a certain amount or percentage of their brain is manipulated or modified to the point that they no longer have human thoughts or emotions....again, interesting point to ponder.
Ah, so your definition of humanity hinges on the emotional/rational part of the human mind. What about if someone replaces their body parts with robotic parts? Could you look at them and still claim they are human?
I did not say that I believe a person has to have emotion or be rational to be human; I said the absence of brain waves makes a person no longer a human, and yes, robotic parts do not make a person non-human.
Even with the most advanced technology, we still will be human and nothing can replace our thoughts.
Yes, we may change body parts to survive but it will still be human as our feelings remain. I do believe we are striving for survival as human beings by prolonging our lives through technology. But with that, it does not replace our humanity.
Good idea, I also think that humanity and human emotion go hand in hand. Something to think about though: Would a person who is placed in a robotic shell, but with a functioning human brain, would he be considered human?
I do believe that as long as we have thoughts, it is still human. But guess it will be rather hard to have a complete replacement except the brain. Who's knows that the future can make this happen.
what constitutes humanity is his capability to do three basic human actions: 1. freedom; 2. knowledge; and 3. voluntariness. The absence of these three basic constitutions would simply mean certain "acts" tantamount to sneezing, breathing, etc. in line with your question, no since external attributes do not make the person but what makes him human is his capacity to enact the three qualities just mentioned.
It's only a matter of time before robots surpass us and possibly take over.
Will technology really ever reach an endpoint where nothing can be improved? No way. So as long as we're constantly upgrading our technology, tomorrow's robot will always be more powerful than today's. May take 50 years, may take 200, but mark my words, robots like in Blade Runner will happen.
So then what?
I certainly don't want to be around when that happens!
This is not an easy question to answer. If you go down the line of consciousness incarnating in human form, I wonder why one would want to incarnate into a body that is robotic or hooked into a machine for an experience of humanness.
A possible tragedy that could strip humans of their essential link to the human condition, is if they lost the ability to feel. Sexual intercourse is so sweet a pleasure not because we think it but because we feel it. An embrace is to enjoy feeling, an entwining of two humans.
In order to really grasp the concept of loss of human traits, is to separate thoughts from feelings (not emotions) but the tangible sensual feelings we have.through the skin. Is love something we think or is it something we feel? It is more the later, whilst we do think of the ideals of love, it is through the ability to feel that we experience it. So there is an organic layer to our existence that may be dismissed in the mix of feelings. If we were primarily robotic, or hooked to machines, how does this effect our sense of touch?
Great concept, I agree that touch is essential to humanity, as is the rest of our senses. I wonder how people who have lost the ability to feel (through nerve damage/genetic damage), if they feel that they are less human than us?
There is also the realm of virtual reality that I would suggest lessens the current concept of being human. Certainly makes you wonder what Real is.
When they stop loving them-self and others for who they are, Love is the key to a lot our problems although love cannot solve all but can smooth some of the bump in the problems.
In a book I read, a question is asked similar to this one. Simply put is asks if someone had one prosthetic limb would it still be considered human?
What about after four prosthetic limbs, then two robotic eyes, then a synthetic heart, finally a synthetic brain? (Book Title: UNREMEMBERED By: Jessica Brody Page:143)
At what point did this human become artificial?
In my opinion, the answer depends on if you are a very factual person. The heart theoretically is an organ that simply pumps blood, which is significant, just not emotionally. Yet, there are instances of unexplained depression after heart surgeries/ transplants that lead to emotional trauma. Is there something about the heart that we don't understand enough to answer this question?
The Brain, of course controls your emotions. Not only that but also how you think, your actions, and your personality. Isn't your personality what makes you yourself? One definition of a Human is: a man, woman, or child of the species Homo sapiens, distinguished from other animals by superior mental development, power of articulate speech, and upright stance. Isn't the brain what controls all these instances.
There is no answer to this question, only other questions.
by Peeples 9 years ago
Christians, would you stop being friends with someone if you found out they were atheist?Even if they were still the good person you knew them as?
by ga anderson 17 months ago
I stumbled across this in a free Disney+ subscription. I don't know if the link will work for you without a free subscription—but give it a try. If not, Go looking for it. It is definitely worth a watch.I put it here because a segment of this first episode deals with jobs predictions in the coming...
by Zenofsong 9 years ago
How long can you hold onto the idea that you are god, playing at being human, before you go back...to your previous way of thinking?
by Christina 8 years ago
At what point would you consider a fetus a human?I don't want to get into the whole abortion debate, I just want to know how you would decide if something was human or not. An individual or a part.
by Knight6 3 years ago
I recently read one of the post here from a woman who ask for help in trying to understand why god let people who abuse kids have kids and those who wanted kids not have them. As i read her piece and read through the comments from other users the term free will kept on coming up. So i ask the...
by Neil Coulson 8 years ago
Where/what is the origin of the human race?Were we created here on Earth? Evolved here on Earth? or is it possible we originated from another planet?Cave paintings in Africa indicate space travel, and the squat ape like images of early man may be a result of the difference in gravity between the...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|