Did you opt in or out of Hub Pro?
Hub Pro is HubPages efforts to edit our hubs and bring up the quality of the whole site. I chose to allow my hubs to be edited. I'm not saying that is what anyone else should do or that I did the right thing. I just wanted to make an observation about the edits done to my hubs.
All 154 of my hubs are featured and 67 have been edited by Hub Pro. The majority of edits were in the comments. For each edit to my article, there were five in the comments, a 5 to 1 ratio. Is editing comments a good strategy to improve the quality of HP? Mandatory comment editing with Optional hub editing?
I did not opt in or out. It edited them anyway. I had one edit in a hub. The rest were in the comments. I really do not think they should be editing comments.It should stick to the hub itself.
I chose to opt out because I feel that editing is my responsibility, and I didn't want someone else to makes changes to my work. Now with editbot we see corrections anyway. Most are in the comments although a few are alternate spellings of words like nighttime. ( I use night time or night-time.)
No, I think editing comments is a poor idea. Comments are direct quotes from people. Editing should concern the body of the hub only.
The "Hub-Bot" correction/spell checker thingy (which is what everyone here seems to be referring to) is an automated process, and there is no opt-in or opt-out. Hub-PRO is where an actual human being edits your hub(s) and can make changes to them.
If the Hub-Bot wants go thru my Hubs and fix typos, that's one thing, but I opted out of the Hub Pro service because I like my Hubs the way they are and I don't want anybody messing with them but me.
Keith, thanks for clarifying the difference between Hub Pro and Hub-Bot. I wasn't aware of Hub-Bot until the icon showed up on my statistics page. I just assumed it was part of Hub Pro.
I think technically it *IS* part of Hub Pro, but it's "Hub Pro Basic" - which is meant to perform very low level, minor corrections.
The full-monty Hub Pro is when a real person goes into your Hub, moves stuff around and/or adds/removes things.
I can't edit the original question, so I'll state the correction here. Keith Abt has clarified the difference between Hub Pro and Hub-Bot/Edit-Bot. We can't opt out of Edit-Bot which is what I mistook as Hub-Pro.
Anyway, I suppose we can continue the discussion about mandatory vs optional editing of our hubs by bots or people. But the original question is a bit flawed. Thanks for the clarification, Keith.
I think the edit bot is a bit annoying. Why do I need to spend my time editing errors in comments? I'm with you, does this make the hub better?
I opted out. I'm not interested in having some random person edit my work. It's fine the way it is.
I opted "in" for Hub Pro but doubt any of my hub will be selected (they haven't yet). Editbot on the other hand has run rampant through around half my hubs (about 100). I'm not overly concerned because most edits seem to be in the comments. Some people seem to think having the editbot icon on their hubs means they have to edit the words/phrases suggested. They don't seem to realise it has already been done automatically by editbot. You only have to do anything if you don't agree with the change and want it to revert back.
The recent edits done with the symbol of Editbot is not Hubpro. It is a separate tool freshly introduced as far as I think.
I am out of Hubpro.
I opted out. I don't want my work messed with. However, now we have HubPro Basic, which we have no choice over. It's pretty harmless, tho. It just corrects spelling and grammatical errors, not content, layout, photos, etc.
All of the corrections made to my hubs by the bots were in the comments section. Guess it's imperative to proof our comments before we hit the submit button. I really don't think comments have anything to do with Google ranking, though. It's titles and content that Google trolls.
I've just started looking at the bot fixes. I didn't check the comments but the fixes to my posts are mostly changing Canadian spelling. I'm not keen on that but I know some sites will only accept US spelling. This was a reason I left some sites in the past. For one thing, I don't remember all the US spellings.
by Marina 3 years ago
Happy Thursday, everyone! In August we pre-announced a new tool that fixes common spelling and grammatical errors across the site. Today, Editbot, the first iteration of the tool, is live on a small percentage of Hubs and their comments. It will be gradually rolled out to all Hubs over the next...
by Catherine Giordano 2 years ago
I opted in to Hub Pro and I just had my first edit. Nothing was changed except to remove three of my four amazon capsules and remove links to other websites that I included to provide supporting evidence for my claims. So I'm pretty proud that the editors didn't feel the need to change, or add,...
by Caren White 2 years ago
I am screaming with frustration! Most of my hubs have been unfeatured due to lack of traffic. I write about gardening which no one wants to read about in the winter. Spring is coming so I want to get my hubs featured again, but every time I try to edit them, I either get an error...
by Dr. John Anderson 3 years ago
Well I have done it. Over 600 hubs cleaned of the wounds inflicted by Editbot and the Bandaids posted all over my hubs to conceal the unfixed 'errors?@$5^'. No more bot robot symbols on my profile - Ahhh it is so nice.Membership is free and open. Join us in being Cleaned and Healed in the...
by Eric Dockett 3 years ago
Oops! That title is supposed to say "Impact of Massive Hub Editing"!I'm interested in hearing from anyone who has totally rewritten a Hub that ranked well and was getting a fair amount of traffic (say, 20-50 visits per day).Also, anyone who has experimented with deleting a significant...
by katiem2 7 years ago
I constantly look for ways to improve a hub, old, new or middle aged. It seems each time I'm brought back to a hub, by a new comment or notice any opportunity to change it I do so.Now when we do that, the hub is no longer active until reviewed. It becomes unpublished. Most of my changes...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|