Is it okay to tell children there is Santa Claus, the Tooth Fairy, and the Easter Bunny?
Share your thoughts please.
It's okay to tell them there is a Santa Claus, but it's not okay to tell them ten years later he doesn't exist. LOL
Seriously sure, what the heck...is there a harm in it I'm not aware of? I wish I could still believe in the jolly old fellow.
Yes, let the children have their childhood and fairy tales, they will soon be gone.
Normally we try to teach our children not to lie and as parents, we sure don't like it when they lie to us.
Life should be more to children than "getting things" from the bunny rabbit and Santa Clause, these are all lies the devil has used to deceive God's children. God doesn't lie to us, in His word He tells us nothing but the truth.
We must not deceive our children, we must tell our children the truth about these things.
Some may think it's a big joke and it doesn't hurt kids, but how can they look up to their parents when such lies are told to them. They are very innocent and trusting and believe everything their parents tell them.
Think about this:
People see Jesus Christ at Christmas time as a little baby.
THE LITTLE BABY GREW UP!
He is returning to this world soon to save it and BE OUR KING!!!
What is better? For kids to look to Santa at Christmas to "get" presents?
Or be taught to look to Jesus Christ as the source of all the answers in this life and the next?
What a load of clap-trap, you have tried to hi-jack this question for your own little pulpit.
Hmm, Jesus loved to tell stories. They're called parables. And he said that people would understand the parables one way when they were young in his teachings, and another way when they understood more deeply. Why shouldn't Christian parents do same?
My fondest childhood memories are those magical years when I believed in Santa Clause. I also believed in the tooth fairy and the Easter Bunny. I in turn, passed the tradition on to my children. I still BELIEVE in magic!.
I think it's okay. But be prepared to guide your children in deeper understanding as they get older, and even help them if they get teased at school or by friends. You might try, "No, there really isn't a fat red man who fits down our chimney - who has a chimney anymore, anyway. But I taught you about Santa Claus when you were little because I wanted you to start to learn about the spirit of gift-giving and the wonder of the season.
On the flip side, one of my favorite Doonesbury cartoons is the disappointed look on Zonker's face, while he's in college, when he learns there is no Santa Claus!
I don't like it. I never have. I was seriously angry about it when I was a child and found out. I didn't and still don't get the point in telling these lies to our children. Can't good memories be made without making up random old men that sneak in the house while we are sleeping to offer our children toys?
With that said, my husband wanted to so I go along with it. I say as little about all of it as possible and focus on the meaning of the day for me, family.
Don't lie to the kids about stupid stuff. In turn they might start lying about stupid stuff. Before you know it you got a house full of liars. If your going to tell your kids about Santa and other make believe beings, be honest about it. Just as if you were reading them a fairy tale about Jack and the bean stock.
I doubt most people would shove that story down their kids throats and call it truth. The same should be for these other fairies as well.
Also Jesus never claimed that His parables were true stories like most people do with Santa. So the question was, is it okay, and I think it's a mistake to lie to your children. They hear enough fake stories in movies and cartoons. Why add to the lies? Teach your children to be upright and honest by being that way yourself.
I think it's okay. As a child I knew Santa Claus never existed and that never broke my heart. So I guess it wouldn't be too much of a problem
of course it is! We tell them to believe in their government and punitive system, don't we?
Why not a good fiction?
No, it is not. The reason is that these concoctions serve no purpose other than to commercialize holidays. They are just tools to be used to turn children into consumers and slaves to corporate power. Better to teach them the complete history of the holiday or custom and decide as a family how (or whether) to celebrate according to what has been learned.
Sinterklaas was inspired by the generosity of a man who assisted the poor. If introduced correctly, the child will learn to share their abundance with those who have little.
The Easter hare was introduced as an animal that Jesus spoke to during a visit to a beautiful garden. Following his crucifixion, the animal returned to the side of Jesus just before he ascended.
The tooth fairy was introduced into society to provide a reward for the child who presented themselves as a strong individual when a tooth was lost. Introduction of the tooth fairy was found to identify that the lost tooth would be replaced if the tooth fairy were to leave a gift for the child.
If used correctly, these symbols permit the child to learn compassion through development of a strong empathetic nature.
Commercialization of these symbols has been plagiarized by sly marketing specialists for their own rewards.
Absolutely not.Children believe really easily and have faith in these fake persons.And when you tell them the truth they will refuse to accept it.Then,it will take them a long time to trust anything you tell them,Even after they get over it,they will always reconsider what you are saying and never instantly believing it.
It was magical to believe in Santa Claus and to lie awake listening for the sleigh bells. I don't think there's any harm at all in young children living in a world of the imagination, a world that contains elves and leprechauns and every kind of wondrous thing. The sense of wonder nourished in those early years can sustain us in later times when we are tied down to a grim and pedestrian reality. If we are lucky, we never lose that sense of wonder and can feel it every day. As long as our imaginations can take flight, we are free. We can transform our reality. We can see the magic of life and not just the grey walls. I see no reason to deprive children of that.
why would you want to lie to your children if you expect them to trust and respect you?
I personally think that it is okay. I feel that children should be able to believe in a little magic. I am 27 years old and I still out cookies out. ( No I am not crazy ) it's the thought of it all, the tradition I like to keep a live. I make my hubby eat them in the middle of the night. Not that he minds eattin some cookies and drinking some milk. I would definitely tell my children about these characters and ofcourse be prepared for when they find out te truth.
No, because then you are lying to them. Is lying to your children good?
Also, once they find out you have lied to them, how do you think that makes them feel about you, and about God? Because now if the bunny etc. is not real, then perhaps God is also a lie...
I told my son the truth from small, and he did not suffer for it. Instead, there was high trust between us all the time, even now when he is 17 years old. He knows that when I tell him something, it is the truth.
No, because lying is not O.K. Just think about possible ramifications later on: disillusionment when they learn the truth about these things, not believing other things you tell them later on, not listening to and obeying you when you tell them not to lie to you or others. And, then, why are you surprised and/or frustrated when you have to deal with these issues as the child grows up? Do you have the right to feel these things if you yourself taught them how to, and that it is O.K. to, lie?
I, for one, wish these "traditions" had never been invented. I agree that childhood is a time for wishes and dreams and all that happy, hopeful stuff, but a lie is a lie.
You shouldn't need to threaten to call Santa to discipline your kids (ahem!!!!). I think the motive might have been well-intentioned, but these - are superficial. Easter and Christmas are not about bunnies and chubby elves with reindeer. And you can help a child celebrate a milestone such as losing a tooth without putting crazy ideas of a coin-dropping fairy coming under your pillow that night.
If you accept most of the answers here, then it is wrong to read fairy tales to children, or let them read fictional work. I had an encounter with an atheist who celebrates x-mas as he wrote it and said Santa for Toys and The Easter Bunny for Candy. That was hardly being truthful.
Kids figure out pretty quickly that their parents were playing a game with them through the use of Santa et al. I think it is called pretending.
I don't think that lying is okay. When they find out the truth kids can get angry with you. Also, it can influence on their attitude to God - they will think, it's just another lie, about the guy, that doesn't exist.
I think it is okay to tell them when they ask or at the age of seven because If u lie to them saying oh they r real they might find out that u were lying to them and they would hate that so bad
by Daniel J. Neumann 11 years ago
Why do we tell kids that Santa Claus is real?What are the positive and negative effects of this lie?
by RodneyBlaec Rainey 9 years ago
Why keep perpetuating the myths of Santa Clause, the Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy etc.?
by DaKingsKid 13 years ago
Santa Claus, The Tooth Fairy, Easter Bunny, and Baby Jesus.They find out that Santa is not real.And the Tooth Fairy, Not RealAgain the Easter bunny, Not RealWhat happens to the Idea of baby Jesus?I feel like I am playing the game, remember the line "one of these things is not like the...
by tswilson 11 years ago
At what age should children stop believing in Santa Claus?Should parents let them come to it on their own? What do you say when they ask?
by nanderson500 10 years ago
How old were you when you stopped believing in Santa Claus?
by scarlettdragonfly 12 years ago
Are there any mom's here that writes fun notes to their kid's from Santa or the tooth fairy?Do any other mom's here write note's from the tooth fairy to their children? or draw a tooth on that special dollar bill?
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|