Should I tell my friend her husband is having an affair?
Should I tell my friend her husband is having an affair?
My other friends say she won't believe me, and I'll only end up looking like the bad girl! But if it was me, I'd want to know.Are you willing to lose your friend over this if she doesn't believe you? And are you willing to live with the knowledge if you don't tell her? I'm a believer that generally we should stay out of other peoples business unless it somehow is going to involve us. Have you talked to the husband, see if he's willing to come clean to her himself? How close a friend is this? Is she likely to believe you? You know you're friend, would she thank you for telling her, after it all blows over, or will she be upset forever?
But what really matters is can youlive with not telling? If it will bother you to continue to keep the secret, then talk to her. If your comfortable lying to your friend, then keep it quiet.I would tell her if you had legitimate proof but if you don't and still tell her even if she doesn't believe you, it will start to make her wonder and she will find out sooner or later. She may hate you at first but when she sees it for herself she will thank you later.
Yes . Just make sure that you are right and it is not you. It will all work out in the long haul one way or the other.Been there and done it. I had to tell my sister and needless to say we are both going through the big D. I can live with myself can you.
Ask your friend the hypothetical question.
You are in a bit of a bind here, if you don't tell her and she finds out you knew, she'll hate you just as much, maybe even more.
If it was a one off event you could probably let it go, if its an ongoing thing, she does have a right to know he's making a fool of her.- reeltaulkposted 15 years ago
0If you consider her a friend and you are a true friend...it is your place to do so!!! How would it feel if she found out elsewhere and ran to you to console her? Little would she know that you already knew but withheld the information just because????? You would NOT feel good and trying to act as though you are finding out for the first time would be deemed as crazy!!! Whats the point of acting clueless as well as the two faced behavior. It doesn't take you wanting someone to inform you if they knew to have you do the same to your friend. You know some damaging truth and you need to tell the individual that you consider a friend--- the truth!
YEAH BECAUSE SHE YOUR FRIEND SHE DESERVES TO KNOW ABOUT HER HUSBAND AFFAIR..
I would personally want to know. Most women have an idea that their husband is if he is. It might just be what she needs to know. I would personally risk my friendship because no woman deserves to live with someone that would cheat on them. Your other friends aren't really friends if they wouldn't tell you the truth. She needs to know. The real thing to consider is to somehow get some evidence to show her when you tell her so that she will believe you. Also consider how you are going to tell her. If she brings up that there are problems in her marriage, that might be a better time to tell her than when she is saying that things are wonderful. Focus on getting some evidence but if you can't, you should still let her know.
- Empowermomposted 15 years ago0
First, if you have to ask, she isn't your friend. Real friends are honest with one another.
If you are only "suspicious," approach her with caution, gently laying out why you think this is happening. If you are sure, tell her as soon as possible and give facts, not opinions.
Either way, a good friend tells the truth, even when it isn't pleasant. If you can't trust your friends to be honest, who can you trust? No, do not tell her. No one knows what goes on behind closed doors. Stay out of other peoples affairs. She will find it out or already knows it. If you tell her, she will know you know also. People remember the person that gave them the bad news. See will remember you more than the other women.
Heard the old say, shoot the messenger? Well, that happens when you tell someone something bad.. You will be blamed or remember for the bad news.
Another best friend lost.
When she remarries,you will not be invited to the wedding.
Stay out of others affairs, friends or neighbors.
Stay their friend, but not a nosy one. She will confide in you in time, if she wants you to know. My guess, she suspects or knows it already.In order to tell her you have to be absolutely sure that what you believe is happening is actually happening. You also need to know if she already knows. Personal relationships are just that. You never know what agreements exist between partners. You also have to consider if she will ever find out that you knew first. Some men and women would rather not know. I would approach the subject indirectly. Gauge her responses. Once you have a better idea of where the relationship is, you will know what to do.
Also, if the guy's hanging out in "meat market" type of bars or flea bag motels you probally have to say something. Now you have reasonable concern for her health and well being. If you keep seeing the guy out with some hottie sharing an intimate lunch thats something totally different.
Finally, if I were to confront anyone, it would be the "other woman". In fact I would have a friend (one who doesn't know the wife or the husband) do it for me if I'm well known to the Wife's husband. Keep in mind the other woman may not know the guy is married or he may have said that he and his wife are working on an amicable separation. Basically confront indiscretion with discretion. If the woman was trying to lure the guy away or didn't know he was married she will likely back off. If there was something there relationship wise she will tell the cheating husband, then he has to make a decision.
I guess you see that there is ALOT more to know other than the obvious!LOL
The easiest thing to do is nothing.By not telling your friend, you are enabling him in his very bad behavior. But the price for telling your friend may be pretty big also. If you are prepared to lose the friendship, and perhaps face some personal drama over it, then you can tell her. If you put yourself in her shoes first, and see how it might feel in her situation, it will give you a lot of information on how to proceed or not at all.
You might also consider what if she found out you knew but did nothing to tell her and warn her. That may also be as much drama as not doing anything.
Eventually, whether you pull the plug on her husband or someone else, he'll be outed. This stuff doesn't stay buried forever.Wow what a dilemma, and only one in which you can truly answer. I’d consider the following:
-Does she already know? It’s possible that she knows about the affair and encourages it – it’s fairly common believe it or not.
-Are you 100% sure? – if not, then if it turns out to be false, then your friend will wonder what your motives were and probably wonder why you tried to break her marriage.
-Have you confronted him? This would seem to be a good way out for you – if you confront him, then he may end up telling his wife – for me that would be the best solution.
-Have you approached the woman – she may be unaware that he is married?
You have to take a look at your friendship and work out whether she would want you to say something or not – it may damage your friendship, but if she really is a true best friend then she’ll see that you were trying to protect her and stay your friend.
Generally, if it were me, I’d stay out of it – even though there may be deceit, it’s very hard to make comments on other peoples relationships without getting hurt or losing a friendship.I would. But only if someone wouldn't die or get seriously physically hurt as a result (e.g., if you know she is the type to shoot a cheating husband, or cut his thingy off...).
I have heard mixed opinions on this topic. Some people have told their friends, only to be hated because they were the messenger of bad news. And others have told their friends, and their friends don't believe them, and then accuse them of trying to wrongly break them up (which ends friendships). If you have a very close friendship with this girl, then I wouldn't worry about it. However, I do know two girls who were best friends for 15 years, and they now hate each other for a similar thing. Regardless, I say don't worry about it -- because if trying to save your friend from a cheater is going to make her mad at you, then you don't want a friend like that anyway.
Here's a good argument for telling her (in case she says, "Why did you tell me??!"): Cheating spouses can bring home diseases like AIDS and herpes; can make your friend feel stupid when she finds out for herself years later; can result in family finances being spent on flowers and hotel rooms for the other woman; and so much more. If your friend doesn't even know she's being cheated on, then how can she decide on her own whether she wants to stay with the guy, or leave him? Doesn't she deserve the right to make that choice on her own? If other people are keeping her in the dark, then essentially, they are making that choice for her.
I say -- honesty at all costs (except death or serious physical injury).
Another way that might help you answer this question is: If the question were reversed, would you want your friend to tell you if your husband were cheating? In other words, treat your friend how you would want her to treat you.
Good luck.If you really must stick your nose in it, then do this; Tell him to tell her,tell him if he doesn`t you will put it all on him this way you are off the hook.
If she was a great friend she would understand that you area just looking out for her well being. I would not get mad if you have told me something like that. And even if she did get mad, and stopped becoming your friend at least in the long run she would find out and know you were telling the truth.
You answered your own question - 'my friend' - if she IS your friend than you really should not have found the need to ask others about whether or not you should tell her about her husband or not..... the truth always comes out in the end so eventually she WILL find out about her husband and then she will realise you knew.....and if you decide not to tell her now then she will not consider you a friend later for keeping her husbands secret to yourself.
She will feel that you betrayed her trust by keeping her husbands secret from her.....my advice, tell her, but only if you know that her husband is fooling around 100% and be prepared for her to show anger, hurt, betrayal, humiliation and eventually she will realise that you were a true friend but expect the other emotions to surface first.
Put yourself in her shoes.....what would you expect your friend to do for you?I can understand your reluctance, but there are things you can do and still avoid telling her outright. Think of something you can do that would cause her to catch him. Sometimes, it really does pay to be sneaky.
Thats a pretty sticky situation that really needs to be gaged. I think you would really have to be 100% positive that your friends husband is indeed having an affair and then you have to be 100% sure that you are able to deal with your friends reaction no matter which way it goes and believe me, it could go South real fast! Perhaps you could somehow manage to meet your friend at the same location her husband and lover may be and let her "discover" it herself.
- subwaysadieposted 15 years ago0
If it were me, I would go talk to the Husband first. If he doesn't tell her himself, have proof before you risk your friendship, but remember that what she does with the information is totally on her.
Wow, what a loaded question! I once chatted with a friend about this topic. It can be very tricky to decide to share this sort of information with a relative or close friend, Some people want to know, while others do not and will be come angry with the person who revealed the information with them. They might also feel frustration and embarrassment that someone knows, what they hoped would remain unknown.
If you are absolutely certain the affair is really going on, I would suggest following in the "flow" that is seemingly best for your friend at this time. You might pursue discovering her flow by casually mentioning that you over heard a conversation while at work (Starbucks, etc) and the discussion was about whether to tell a friend...
Her response is likely to give you some reasonable insight into how being the bearer or recipient of such news fits her preferences.
Best wishes with this one!Wow - it never has a happy ending unfortunately - you are totally screwed for telling them and you are totally screwed for not - so the question ends up being - how can you survive the friendship if you tell her the "obvious?" (as in most people would know and see the signs) If you tell her, you have to be prepared to be the "bad guy" because HE can't be in her eyes - at least not in the beginning. I always think that anyone who has an affair is a species all their own and they need to do that anyway and will always do that - but they usually want to kill the messenger~!
I guess its better not to tell your friend about it and set up a plan because who knows she might really knew about this affair and just pretending to be blind, who can tell right? why not...bring your friend to the place where you caught her husband and his "other girl" so your friend or the wife can witness it herself and will just be "accidental" not coming from you and just be there to support her in their confrontation scene.....
If you are any friend at all, let her know. Would you want to know? If my husband was having an affair and my friend knew it, I would hope my friend would tell me. The wife will already feel betrayed when she learns of her husband's infidelity. Does she also need to feel betrayed by her friend?
Either way you end up losing -
I say "do not tell" she probably senses it anyway. Maybe you can set up a scenario for her to find out.
I've found its better to steer clear from these scenarios.Absolutely - without a doubt - tell her.
I've been that "friend" - and no, I didn't believe it.
However, in the end the truth always comes out. When that happened between my husband and I - when it finally all came out, it was very clear to me that the one person who'd tried to warn me earlier, might be one of the few people in my life I could trust.If you are without doubt aware of an on going affair than your concern should be your friends health and not the security of your friendship or her reactions to the information. Unfortunately in todays world ones health becomes the primary concern. Aids is a killer and it is not pleasant to have to live being HIV positive.
Now if you can figure a way to get her in for a physical including blood work, at least your conscience (this time) can be eased. Again I must imput the possibility that the husband may alway cheat with different partners and the percentages of getting HIV has now increased. .
I myself ,having proof of the infidelity, would inform my friend giving her my reason and leaving it up to her to make the smart choice. My conscience would be cleared and hopefully save a life which to me is more important than the relationship.Only you know your friend. Also, only you know whether you have enough evidence to prove the affair. Here are some possibilities: you could warn your friend, you could tell the husband that people suspect him or you could do nothing but be ready to help your friend when she needs it.
No, the best thing to do is to stay out of it, maybe she knows and then again she doesn't. But the best thing for yourself is to stay out of it, one cause if you tell her and she is the forgiving type your relationship with her will never be the same if she forgives him. Two if you tell her she will want to know how long you have known it and that will be a problem, depending how long so stand down.
I thought you said your friend. If she is indeed your friend you have to tell her. However, you are truely going to put your friendship through the test of trial and tribulation. It's what makes or breaks true friendship. She will find out eventually anyway, and it will be worst if she finds out that you knew and did not tell her.
You are in a tight situation ... because if she forgives her husband and sticks with him ... You can just about be certain that your name is "OFF" the Christmas list! I say tell her and be done with it. Besides what you do in the dark will soon come to light. This is always a fact.- dracaslairposted 15 years ago0
id give it time and see if the husband will be caught because ,men do get caught.men do lie about cheating but,somehow get caught.there are sighns.go ahead and tell your friend so she can check things out.
I was actually faced with this situation. I caught my girlfriend's husband in their house with a young woman whom they had befriended and given her a place to stay.
My girlfriend was at work and her husband was off that day. I went by their house to drop off the serving trays that I borrowed from her for a party I had the weekend before. His car was in the driveway, and the other woman's car, which I didn't find that suspicious because she used to live with them, BUT it was in the middle of the day and my girlfriend was at work.
I knocked, but no answer. I kept knocking, but no one came to the door. I started calling his name, her name, saying to them that I know you're in there, open this goddamn door right now. He finally opened the door, acting nervous, and the hallway door leading to the bedrooms was shut. He first lied that she wasn't even in the house. He explained that she had dropped her car for him to take a look at. When that lie fell apart, he tried to deny that anything was going on with them. But the other woman, whom I had grown to know and care about, came right out and admitted the affair to me.
I was really hurt that they could do that to my girlfriend and torn about telling her something that would devastate her and mean the possible breakup of a 24-year old marriage. I went home and contemplated what I was going to do. Then it dawned on me, it was not my responsibility to tell her...it was his.
I called him up and told him that he had until one hour after she got off work to tell her that he was having an affair or I would tell her myself.
When she called me to tell me what had happened, I admitted to her that I already knew. I explained to her how I had caught them the day before and what I had told her husband. He not disclosed to her that I had found them together. He lied to her that the affair happened a year earlier but it was now over.
She thanked me for putting the responsibility back on him, but added that if I had not told her I had caught them together, she would have held it against me for knowing something like that and not telling her.
So, my answer would be to confront him and tell him to tell her or you will.- richard vaughnposted 15 years ago0
yes. the longer its left to go on, the bigger the hurt. A true friend would let her know. Those who don't are not true friends, rather, they are moral cowards.
This is the age of technology, let her eyes convince her.Grab your camera phone.and then, just be a friend.
No, please don't because she is not going 2 believe you. Better still, lead her in such a way that she feels independent,save,secured. When this is done observe her for a while and see if she can stand up for herself. If she can, you should probably take her to the place where she can get him red-handed BUT; please don't tell her.
I think it depends how sure you are. I would want to know, but I would like proof , and not just hear say. Do you know for sure that he has cheated? Did you see this with your own eyes? I have learned that people can be cruel, and make things up to rock the boat. If you were a real friend, you would take the risk. She may be hurt to start with, but make it clear to her that you had no choice as her friend to tell her this news. Better she knows now, as he may do this again. At least she then has the choice of what to do. The worst feeling is when she does find out, and she may well do, that she finds out you knew all along, and said nothing. I am afraid you are in a no win situation here, and it comes down to you at the end of the day. Hope it all goes well.
Eeeeek !!!! No way. If your friend and her husband work things out she'll never speak to yyou again. It's a hard one I know from experience., but be very very careful if you don't want to lose your friend.
You could always send her an anonymous letter or email or simply make it obvious to her without coming right out and saying it.
Over 80% of what we *say* doesn't come out of our mouths anyway.
Plus, chances are, she may already know and simply be choosing to ignore it for now. There is NO accounting for what or how people think - even the ones you think you know best.
I would get involved in the least obtrusive way yet if you love her, let her know by one of the other means. Keeps you out of the loop so to say.I think it's the responsibility of a true person to let her friend know that her husband is deceiving her. You can do it either by indirect way or direct way depending on how much she trust and respect you. But, the key is your job is anyway send her the message of the affair.
No, you should not tell your friend her husband is having an affair. She will only end up getting hurt and hating you for it. What you should do is mind your own business.
see if you can find out if he was spotted with the other woman and then ask your friend who the girl was her husband was with the other day... sneaky but could work getting the ball rolling
Yes, You should definitely tell your friend that her husband is having an affair even if you have to be a bad girl. If she comes to know later that you knew of the affair and hided it you are going to lose her as a friend anyway. So by revealing the truth you are at least trying to help her deal with the situation. However, if you have some proof of his affair before talking to her that would be nice.
Definitely tell her. She might not believe you. That might be because she just doesn't want to believe you.You need to tell her and let her know that you have her best interest in mind. And if you don't tell her, you'll regret it. And she might too.
Yes, you should tell your friend. Having said that I must warn you of the consequences and they are:
1. As your other friend said she won't believe you and why should she? It is the man she loves you are talking about so why should she believe you without any proofs?
2. She will stop talking to you or in worst situation will shut you out. Don't feel bad by her behaviour she is reacting to what you have told her. And now that the seeds of doubt have been planted in her mind she can see them growing.
But when the truth comes out which eventually it will then she will realise that in all this chaos you are one of the few persons she can really trust and then she will need your complete support.
So while you are contemplating whether or not to tell your friend please ensure that you have the mental stamina to go through all this.Her husband could bring her the moon, and he would still have had this affair. There is nothing more intimate that trust. Take the laundry, air it out, and get it over with.
I told my friend and I ended up being the jerk. She ended up asking my to leave and never come back! I was so shocked and hurt I never went back.
You should speak to the husband and have him tell her!!!! Most times your friend will not beleive you... and it's possible to lose a friendship over this issue.
Be very certain before you drop the bomb. And if you do be prepared for the worse as most times she has a clue but doesnot want to rock the boat for many reasons. Children.income or past experiences that have pettered out.All of the cheated ons react differently and the best you can do is be a friend. You"ll know when the time is right.
Related Discussions
- 3
sould i tell my friend her husband is having an affair
by Manoj sharm 14 years ago
sould i tell my friend her husband is having an affair
- 110
Am I wrong to tell my husband about an affair?
by cdmpls 13 years ago
I felt that it was best because if I felt that guilty it was better to open up to him..
- 49
What will you do if you found out that your boss is having an affair with your c
by Dave Rogers 11 years ago
What will you do if you found out that your boss is having an affair with your co worker?I am working really hard to move up the ladder while there is this co worker of mine that is not really doing much but is just going out with the boss who promoted her. I feel so down. I can't just imagine...
- 8
Shall I tell my friend that her wife have an affair?
by urs_dipak 14 years ago
Shall I tell my friend that her wife have an affair?Shall I tell my friend that her wife have an affair?
- 28
A coworker is having an extramarital affair. Do you tell the spouse who is also
by Luke M. Simmons 9 years ago
A coworker is having an extramarital affair. Do you tell the spouse who is also your friend?In more detail: If your coworker/friend was frequently late for work because of an extramarital affair, would you tell your boss? You have reason to believe that doing so would cause the offender to...
- 4
How do I stay out of friend-zone after confessing about my feelings.
by akki 10 years ago
How do I stay out of friend-zone after confessing about my feelings.I was friend-zoned by this girl I love so much. She broke up with her ex and when I told her my feeling she said that she don't feels that way. I left and trying to move on but its so hard and I miss her a lot. I wanna talk to her...